In 1966, traveling salesman Woodrow Derenberger claimed he encountered a smiling, telepathic being on a dark West Virginia highway. Unfortunately for him, it was an encounter that would spiral into years of alleged visits, alien worlds, public harassment, Men in Black sightings, and the collapse of his personal life.

We're diving into the deeply unsettling case of Indrid Cold, better known as The Grinning Man—a figure who looks human, speaks without moving his mouth, and doesn't fit any one description.

But Indrid Cold isn't just isolated to one case. There are reports of other grinning figures in different states, strange phone calls, unexplained lights, and a broader wave of high strangeness spreading across West Virginia.

One investigator, John Keel, begins to suspect that this isn’t an alien story at all, but something stranger: an ultraterrestrial, a being not from another planet, but from somewhere overlapping our reality.

In this episode, we discuss:

• The original highway encounter and why it feels so wrong
• The rise of the Grinning Man sightings beyond West Virginia
• Why Indrid Cold triggers such a strong uncanny valley response
• The ultraterrestrial theory and how it reframes the entire case
• Skeptical explanations, psychological interpretations, and hoax concerns
• How folklore, culture, and media helped turn Indrid Cold into modern myth

Was Indrid Cold an extraterrestrial explorer? An interdimensional observer? A psychological break under extreme pressure? Or the modern face of an ancient archetype that’s been with us far longer than we realize?

Text us something cool or fun and we'll read it on the show!!

Support the show