This episode brings us a new perspective - someone who has been in their home for nearly two decades. Today, we sit down with Scott Choppin, a Long Beach, California homeowner who completed a full scrape-and-rebuild of his family home nearly twenty years ago. We explore what it means to live with your design decisions over the long term and how perspective changes when you’ve raised a family in the house you built from scratch. Scott’s project is a 4,600-square-foot Spanish-style home built on a 5,000-square-foot lot in Belmont Shore, replacing a modest 1940s house that no longer met his family’s needs.

We talk about how Scott and his wife decided that renovation wasn’t realistic and why starting over ultimately made more sense. With a growing family and limited lot constraints, we discuss how the existing footprint would have restricted the design and forced compromises that didn’t align with their goals. Scott’s comfort with new construction, shaped by his professional background in real estate development, made the decision to scrape the house easier than it might be for most homeowners. (Also, Taylor vows to bring the term "scrape" to Alabama.)

We walk through the design process, starting with a “core” family space his wife envisioned and building the rest of the house around it. We discuss how big-picture planning came first, followed by detailed decisions about room sizes, circulation, and everyday functionality. Scott shares how bringing the general contractor on early helped filter design ideas through a buildability lens and how trust played a major role in their team dynamic. He also reflects on moments of friction with the architect during construction and how those experiences shaped the process.

During construction, we hear a memorable story about severe rain, high groundwater, and a bulldozer sinking into the site—an early reminder that building a house is fundamentally about problem-solving. We emphasize the importance of asking, “What’s the plan?” rather than panicking when things go wrong, and how trust, communication, and patience are critical during setbacks.

Looking back after nearly two decades, Scott shares valuable lessons about long-term durability, maintenance, and material choices. We talk about plumbing fixtures, flooring, electrical systems, decks, and the importance of choosing well-supported brands and keeping detailed records. Scott also reflects on what he would not do again—like Juliet balconies and overly complex lighting systems—and what he still loves, including the timeless Spanish exterior and neutral interior finishes that have aged gracefully.

We conclude by emphasizing that no project is perfect, every house requires ongoing care, and thinking beyond move-in day is one of the most important lessons homeowners can take away.

(00:00) Introduction & Guest Overview
(02:10) Project Background & Timeline
(05:59) Renovate vs. Rebuild Decision
(10:51) Design Process & Core Planning
(17:22) Zoning, Setbacks & Tradeoffs
(21:06) Construction Begins & Site Challenges
(26:13) Managing Stress & Problem-Solving
(35:11) Long-Term Materials & Maintenance
(40:56) What Still Works After 19 Years
(43:12) Final Advice & Takeaways

Have questions? Want to be on our show? Email us! admin@htsspodcast.com

Learn about our hosts:

Taylor: TPD Architecture and Design: https://tpdarchitect.com

Marilyn: Runcible Studios: https://runciblestudios.com

SherI: Springhouse Architects: https://springhousearchitects.com

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.