Send a text

A wedding weekend should have been easy: a late check-in, a sleepy forest, seven friends swapping stories by the fire. Instead, a small rug in the kitchen lifted to reveal a cellar door and a laminated warning that changed how we heard every sound after dark. Quiet became tapping, tapping became scraping, and then came the wet gnawing that turned our jokes into plans for escape. When Kathy whispered that she heard crying—thin, practiced, almost polite—the note’s emphasis snapped into focus and forced us to ask whether empathy can be weaponized.

We walk you through every uneasy beat: the suspiciously sparse Airbnb listing with nine words and no recent reviews, the overpowering cleaner scent that failed to hide something sour, and the host’s curt message that promised we “won’t hear anything else tonight.” You’ll hear how the house felt different hour by hour, how group bravado drained into calculation, and how small details—the age-yellowed tape on the warning, the ring handle rattling once, the rug shifting an inch—etched themselves into memory. We talk about why liminal spaces like rentals amplify dread, how social dynamics collapse under stress, and what it means when a boundary asks to be kept not out of safety, but because something beyond it knows how to borrow a human voice.

By morning we left without looking back, only to find the listing erased and a buried forum thread describing a near-identical night. That discovery reframed everything: maybe the crying wasn’t a plea for help. Maybe it was the hook. If you’ve ever weighed curiosity against caution, or wondered what your compassion might cost in the wrong place, this story will sit with you long after the credits. Listen, then tell us: would you have lifted the rug?

If this story got under your skin, follow the show, share it with a friend, and leave a quick review—your words help more listeners find our tales of the strange and uncertain.

Support the show

https://www.facebook.com/Thehauntedgrovepod