City of Fallen Angels

multiple readers

didn't like the fact that there was more than reader for this audio book. it took away from the experience. I preferred how the other books in the series were done

2 people found this helpful

.

What didn’t you like about Ed Westwick and Molly C. Quinn ’s performance?

The narrators... why did they change them?

All the accents and characters sound like different people. And they’re different again, depending on whether Ed or Molly is doing the voice.

I hate the way the men sound in his voice, especially Luke. It puts a completely different picture in my mind of what he looks like.

She speaks almost in a monotone. You can’t tell who’s talking half the time. The Fairy Queen has lost her lovely accent completely. The males speak in the same high pitched voice as the females. She even read parts with only male characters for some reason.

Sigh. Narration really let down the story.

1 person found this helpful

Okay storyline but the narration is off.

I didn’t really like the change in narration, the previous books were much better! In this one the narrators pronounce some of the nouns differently, for example “stele” is pronounced “steely”?? “Idris”- “eedris”, and “Armatis”-“Amartis”. It’s hard because you get into the book and then are pulled out when they mispronounce it. I’m a bit disappointed that the Seelie Queen has completely lost her accent, but I do like how Simon is read.

Does good always win?

Another angst ridden instalment of the on again off again world of Jace and Clarissa as they battle the demon world. I love the way other characters are enlarged and embroidered as the story unfolds and can't wait to see what Cassandra has in store for us as she awakens the evil Sebastian.
The story is read well although sometimes I crave for some more emotion. At times the readers are a little flat.

The Mortal Instruments just keeps getting better.

Where does City of Fallen Angels rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

City of Fallen Angels is the best listen in the Mortal Instruments series so far.

What was one of the most memorable moments of City of Fallen Angels?

Simon coming to terms with his vampirism.

Which character – as performed by Ed Westwick and Molly C. Quinn – was your favorite?

Simon was my favourite character in this book, as he struggles to come to terms with his condition and the Mark of Cain.

If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?

I would not attempt to make this into a film, considering how bad City of Bones was when made into a movie.

Awesome story starter, great cliffhanger

What about Ed Westwick and Molly C. Quinn ’s performance did you like?

I found Ed a great contrast to Molly, though I wish they would settle on one kind of narrator. In book 5 we only get Molly and the previous 3 have all been read by different people. The discontinuity does the story a disservice. I particularly like these 2.

Any additional comments?

What a great way to kick off a new trilogy (/ continuation from the first trilogy) and all we took for granted goes out the window! Quick paced, witty, and dark, it is a delight from beginning to end and its a quick roll from 4 to 5 and then join in the anticipation for book 6!

Like Nails On A Chalk Board

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

Yes and no. I love this series, I really do. However, I feel that City of Glass would've been a fine way to finish the series if the ending had been more final. The loose threads at the end of City of Glass felt a little forced. But all that aside, I was glad to have the opportunity to further the Mortal Instruments journey. Though the connection really wasn't there for me. I'll finish the series because I feel like I should, not necessarily because I want to. I definitely don't feel the enthralling engrossment I felt with the first three books.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Simon. As the story is predominantly about him I guess that it's only natural to feel the connection with his character grow this time round.
At the risk of sounding cliche', his character really comes into his own in this book, meaning he is no longer a sub-character just playing the role of Clary's faithful sidekick, following her through her life and her story. Simon has developed his own story, his own life outside of Clary. I kind of feel that he was owed this and I was glad that this is the route Clare took with his character. We'd seen this change in his character start to unfold in City of Glass so I found the follow through of this new Simon in City of Fallen Angels very satisfying and thoroughly enjoyable. Plus, he's a great comic relief amongst all of the Clary/Jace relationship angst. Really. Enough.
Kyle was a nice addition to the cast as well.

Did the narration match the pace of the story?

Fail.
I could listen to Ed Westwick for hours. What a voice! And I thought he did a great job. And I liked the novelty of switching up narrators. Though, I would have been just as content if Natalie Moore had remained the narrator.
Molly C. Quinn though, different story altogether. I got to the point where I was actually tempted to skip the parts she narrated. The heading says it all, like nails on a black board. I'm probably nit-picking because I've been spoilt with audiobooks read by a variety of truly brilliant narrators, but her poorly inflected and almost bored delivery was painful for me. The stiff, over-pronounced narrative was distraction and disappointing. And honestly, the "soft-voice" she adopted when completing a sentence or, for example, reading a conversation between Clary and Jace made my eye twitch. Again, I'm probably being pedantic, but it really, REALLY annoyed me and significantly lessened my enjoyment of this audiobook and did not do justice to the story.

Do you think City of Fallen Angels needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

We've come this far! Let's finish the series with a bang! It deserves it.
Thus far, the Mortal Instruments series has delivered a wonderful and innovative world to escape to that is thoroughly entertaining. Sure, you can't throw a stone in a book store these days without hitting a supernatural/para-romance young adult novel, but the Mortal Instruments offers enough refreshing contrast to other series within it's genre to make it a stand out, must read story. No easy feat in a flooded market and a true credit to Cassandra Clare.
I'm looking forward to the final chapter of this enchanting story as, I'm sure, are the many other readers who have invested in the world of Shadowhunters, Downworlders and Demons.

Ed Westwick The Narrater is hopless

What would have made City of Fallen Angels better?

A Narrator that could be heard his voice was one flats nothing. I could not follow the story because his voice never changed between character infact his tone never changed I had no idea which character was talking I turned the story off after 9 mins Please bring back Ari Graynor or Natalie Moore I will never by another book read by Ed Westwick.

What was most disappointing about Cassandra Clare’s story?

I have listen to the whole series up to this book and was forced to turn it off.

Would you be willing to try another one of Ed Westwick and Molly C. Quinn ’s performances?

NEVER I could do better than Westwick standing on my head drinking a beer

What character would you cut from City of Fallen Angels?

love them all

Any additional comments?

when you start a series with a females voice stay with a females voice

Another great read from clare

What did you love best about City of Fallen Angels?

C.C keeps the teen angst coming and left us with a gripping cliffhanger

Who was your favorite character and why?

Clary, the bumbling yet powerful newbie

Have you listened to any of Ed Westwick and Molly C. Quinn ’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

It was a little off putting to swap to a two person read after being accustomed to the previous solo readings, not that Ed and Molly don't give a winning reading i have to admit i preferred the other works.

Any additional comments?

Found it slightly odd at the shifting prospectives between clary and simon

The heading I hated

This book wasn’t for you, but who do you think might enjoy it more?

Book was OK I just disliked the ending. Anyone who had read the series would be disappointed.

What was most disappointing about Cassandra Clare’s story?

I have read many others previous books in this series, loved them all. this one the ending was horrible left too many unanswered questions. Felt confused. This book seemed unnecessary and the series could have finished with the third book

What about Ed Westwick and Molly C. Quinn ’s performance did you like?

These guys did OK, but it is annoying when the narrators are changed during a series

What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?

Disappointment