In this special edition of Beyond the Filter, hosts Brandy Brightman and Jeremy Malcolm present the global launch of the Drawing the Line Watchlist—a groundbreaking report examining how ten countries around the world are increasingly blurring the line between personal expression (art, fiction, advocacy, consensual adult material) and lived abuse involving real victims.

Joined by three members of the project’s Advisory Board—Emma Shapiro, Ashley Remminga, and Zora Rush—this live podcast-webinar explores how censorship, moral panic, and poorly drafted laws are reshaping the digital landscape for artists, queer communities, and marginalized creators.

Together, the panel unpacks:

• Why fictional content is being conflated with real sexual abuse, and how law enforcement resources are being redirected away from crimes with actual victims
• How artists, especially those depicting bodies or erotic themes, face uneven and often punitive moderation
• The impact of moral panics on queer and trans fandom spaces, and the historical roots of these controversies
• How AI systems struggle with context, nuance, and cultural bias—and what it means for sexual expression and safety online
• Examples of global overreach, including prosecutions of artists, writers, and even teenagers for fictional material
• Five key reforms governments should adopt to restore clarity, protect children, and uphold human rights

Guests share on-the-ground insights from their domains—arts advocacy, queer cultural research, and responsible AI—while Jeremy previews the Watchlist’s findings, including startling shifts in enforcement patterns and international case studies.

The conversation closes with actionable recommendations for policymakers, platforms, and civil society about how to genuinely keep children safe without eroding creative and queer expression.

For the full report and the Drawing the Line Principles, visit: drawingthelineprinciples.org.

You can also watch this episode as a webinar, with bonus live Q&A content.

The post Beyond the Filter: Drawing the Line Watchlist appeared first on Center for Online Safety and Liberty.

Hosts Brandy and Jeremy talk with Dr. Craig Harper of Nottingham Trent University about his research on whether fantasy sexual materials—like AI-generated images, cartoons, or sex dolls—are linked to real-world offending.

Dr. Harper explains that, despite common policy assumptions, there’s no evidence such materials increase risk. Across multiple studies, his team has found no connection between fictional sexual content and offending, and in some cases, higher sexual satisfaction may even relate to lower self-reported risk.

He discusses the ethical limits of this research, why criminalization may target low-risk individuals, and how therapists can thoughtfully navigate disclosures about fantasy material use. Harper also addresses the backlash researchers face when data challenge moral intuitions, urging listeners to base prevention efforts on evidence, not instinct.

The post Beyond the Filter: Fantasy Sexual Materials and Offending appeared first on Center for Online Safety and Liberty.

Brandy and Jeremy unpack the political turmoil after the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk. They highlight the double standards in how violence is mourned across party lines and how Kirk’s death was used to justify sweeping crackdowns—from visa cancellations to labeling Antifa a terrorist group.

The hosts then explore the suspension of Jimmy Kimmel after he mocked the right’s narrative, exposing how Trump-era pressure on media threatens free speech. With historical parallels to authoritarian propaganda, they warn of growing censorship while noting the pushback that forced Kimmel’s return. Their message is clear: defending satire and dissent is essential to defending democracy itself.

The post Beyond the Filter: The Assassination of Charlie Kirk and the Censorship of Jimmy Kimmel appeared first on Center for Online Safety and Liberty.

Brandy and Jeremy speak with journalist Michael McGrady Jr about two growing threats to online sexual expression: financial censorship and age verification laws. They discuss recent crackdowns, including the financial censorship of adult games on Steam and itch.io, and the effects of the UK’s Online Safety Act requiring ID checks for many sites. Michael explains how these measures harm both privacy and the livelihoods of sex workers, game developers, and queer creators. Learn how long-running moral campaigns combined with corporate risk aversion are creating a perfect storm for the suppression of lawful expression worldwide, and discover real ways to protect children without censorship.

The post Beyond the Filter: Age Verification, Payments, Porn, and Censorship appeared first on Center for Online Safety and Liberty.

In this episode of Beyond the Filter, hosts Jeremy and Brandy delve into the creation of Fan Refuge, a new social media platform designed for fans by fans. Jeremy shares insights into how Fan Refuge aims to provide a censorship-free space while ensuring user safety through innovative tools and community guidelines. Discover the challenges and inspirations behind this project, and learn how Fan Refuge plans to stand out in the landscape of fan websites. Join us as we explore the future of fan communities online.

The post Beyond the Filter: Fan Refuge appeared first on Center for Online Safety and Liberty.

In this episode, hosts Jeremy and Brandy speak with F15-H (Fish), an artist from Hong Kong now living in mainland China, about a shocking wave of arrests targeting fanfiction writers on the Chinese platform MyHD Books. Over 500 authors—predominantly young women and college students—were arrested in May on charges of public indecency, facing penalties of up to 10 years in prison simply for writing erotic fanfiction. Fish reveals how these arrests were triggered when the Taiwan-based platform introduced monetization features, giving authorities a pretext to crack down on content that had existed for years. The conversation explores China’s gendered approach to censorship, where female-created content faces harsher penalties than male-oriented material, and draws troubling parallels to rising puritanical movements worldwide. From doll nipples getting creators shadow-banned from payment systems to fans reporting writers to the government over shipping preferences, Fish paints a picture of a surveillance state where fiction is treated more seriously than real crimes—and warns that similar trends are emerging globally.

The post Beyond the Filter: Fanfic arrests in China appeared first on Center for Online Safety and Liberty.

This month on Beyond the Filter, Brandy and Jeremy are joined by Aurélie Petit, PhD candidate in Film Studies at Concordia University and author of the recent Porn Studies article The Limits of Zero Tolerance Policies for Animated Pornographic Media.

Together, they explore the complex and often contradictory ways digital platforms moderate animated sexual content. Why is animation treated with suspicion, and how do automated moderation tools fail to understand its nuances? What risks do creators face when ambiguous, stylized, or queer content gets lumped in with illegal material under blanket zero-tolerance policies?

Aurélie unpacks the cultural history of hentai, lolicon, and shotacon, discusses her analysis of 30 platform policies, and calls for a more nuanced, community-informed approach to moderation. Along the way, the discussion touches on censorship, consent, creative freedom, AI-generated porn, and the politics of representation in animation.

• “The Limits of Zero Tolerance Policies for Animated Pornographic Media” (Aurélie Petit, 2024)
• “The Hentai Streaming Platform Wars” (Aurélie Petit, 2024)
• Indie Porn: Revolution, Regulation, and Resistance (Zahra Stardust, 2024)

The post Beyond the Filter: Aurélie Petit on Censorship of Animated Porn and its Limits appeared first on Center for Online Safety and Liberty.