Freshly Squeezed True Crime cover art

Freshly Squeezed True Crime

Freshly Squeezed True Crime

Written by: Suhailly Nieves
Listen for free

About this listen

Freshly Squeezed True Crime is a Florida-only true crime podcast. We have it all: hoaxes, deceptions, murder, mayhem, organized crime, white collar crime, serial killers, and of course Florida Man. Grab your fried gator tail, conch fritters, cuban sandwich, publix sub, and pitcher of sweet tea and join me, Suhailly; as we travel through this sunny place for shady people.





© 2026 Freshly Squeezed True Crime Social Sciences
Episodes
  • #15, Circus Circus

    #15, Circus Circus
    Jan 14 2026

    This week we travel to Gibsonton & tell the story of Grady Stiles Jr.

    Shownotes:

    John Ringling - Wikipedia

    Ringling brothers - Wikipedia

    Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus - Wikipedia

    Meet Grady Stiles, The Murderous Lobster Boy Who Killed His Daughter's Fiance (ranker.com)

    Grady Stiles - Wikipedia

    Grady Stiles Jr. - The Murderous Lobster Man (thehumanmarvels.com)

    Murder on the Midway: Sordid Life and Death of Lobster Boy : Crime: Family supports wife's claims of familial abuse, citing incident in which carnival attraction killed daughter's beau. - Los Angeles Times (latimes.com)

    Lobster Boy - Some Kind of Moment

    Grady Stiles Murder: Where Are Chris Wyant, Harry Glenn Newman Jr, and Mary Teresa Now? Update (thecinemaholic.com)

    Gibsonton, Florida - Wikipedia

    Circus - Animal Rights Foundation of Florida

    Grady Stiles Murder: Where Are Chris Wyant, Harry Glenn Newman Jr, and Mary Teresa Today?

    Sideshow - Wikipedia

    Freak show - Wikipedia

    Grady Stiles Jr. – The Murderous Lobster Man | KickassFacts
    Show More Show Less
    39 mins
  • Bonus, #2, Love Letter to Florida & Florida Man

    Bonus, #2, Love Letter to Florida & Florida Man
    Jan 1 2026

    This week we discuss the origins of Freshly Squeezed, Florida, & Florida Man... Let me tell you a story.

    Shownotes:

    Top 8 Wildest Florida Man Arrests And The Laws They Broke

    LIST: Top 10 wackiest Florida Man (and Woman) headlines of 2024 | CBS 42

    Florida Man - The Official Site of The Legendary Florida Man

    Best Florida Man (and Woman) Stories of 2022
    Show More Show Less
    25 mins
  • #14, 12 days of dismemberment

    #14, 12 days of dismemberment
    Dec 30 2025

    This week we travel around the state as we discuss Florida dismemberment

    Shownotes:

    https://people.com/grindr-lawsuit-murder-florida-miranda-corsette-teenager-torture-dismemeber-1175173

    Meth Murder Mom Has Convicted Sex Offender Dad, Drug Dealer Husband | Inside Edition

    The Psychology of Murder Concealment Acts - PMC

    Murder of Shad Thyrion - Wikipedia

    Oscar Solis could get death in stabbing of Randall Cooke (lawandcrime.com)


    Woman Whose Remains Were Found in 3 Suitcases Is ID'd, Husband Arrested (people.com)


    Penny Rebecca Pospisil gets life for killing boyfriend (lawandcrime.com)


    Fla. Couple Facing Charges in 4 Deaths in Two States (people.com)


    Winter Haven man takes plea deal for life in prison (theledger.com)


    Jefferson man arrested in death and dismemberment of Florida partner and "friend" (ktalnews.com)


    Man, 44, gets life sentence for murder of Belleview woman (ocala.com)


    The Story Of Florida's "Nub City," Where Residents Cut Off Their Own Appendages For Insurance Money (allthatsinteresting.com)
    Show More Show Less
    37 mins
No reviews yet