It’s episode 112 where the players dwell on their failure in identifying what’s true or false in this anthology quiz! In this episode, Lily shares 4 horror stories that keep you guessing which story truly haunts this world. Afterwards, Chase debunks an Albuquerque panic encounter and then later revives a Miami, Florida spectacle that left local cops scratching their heads.

When most people hear the name Sir Francis Bacon, they likely don’t think of his contribution to the paranormal world. Vegans beware, as this episode details Bacon’s Ghostly Chicken. Afterwards, Chase details a haunting in Fiji as a result of Cyclone Winston. Finally, we cover this years “31 days of Horror” haunted movie list.

Bad ghosts, bad ghosts, whatcha gonna do? Whatcha gonna do when they come for you? These Honolulu police officers weren’t sure when they faced their own ghostly intruders. In this episode, Lily shares an anthology of real stories from the Honolulu Police Department. Afterwards, Chase discusses a trip HOTW took to the allegedly haunted Casey Moore’s Oyster House in Phoenix, AZ.

Earth, Wind, Fire, and Meteors are just a few elements that haunt this week’s episode. Join Lily as she recounts the many spooky stories told around the University of Montevallo’s campus. Afterwards, Chase delights us with The Hodges Meteorite Incident that occurred in Sylacauga, Alabama.

What do you think happens when a skeptic comes face to face with a ghost? Why shoot it of course! This episode Lily dishes the deets on the Mysterious Brown Lady of Raynham Hall, and how it provided one of the earliest alleged photographs of an actual spectre. Afterwards, Chase tackles all the UAP's that have been appearing above New Jersey and the neighboring states. Are they Drones, Planes, or the Firefly overlords returning to earth?

New England is the perfect place to enjoy the changing leaves, clam chowder, and unsolved double homicides. This episode Lily details the infamous murders that took place at the Lizzy Borden house in Fall River, MA. Afterwards, and just slightly North of there, Chase covers the history of the ominous "House of Seven Gables" in Salem, MA.

Did you know that 4 out of 5 paranormal investigators think that size matters? Grab your extra-large Crocs, because this week Lily tackles the famous sightings of Bigfoot near Pikes Peak, Colorado. Afterwards, Chase delves into the Dover Demon of Massachusetts, a cryptid with notably smaller feet.

Looking for a dead body? So is Highgate Cemetery! This week, Lily shares the countless reports of hauntings and misplaced corpses at the Highgate Cemetery in London, England. Afterwards, Chase delights us with tales of torture and cannibalism caused by the Werewolf of Bedburg, Germany (aka Peter Stumpp). Lastly, Lily and Chase breakdown their October horror movie calendar for those brave enough to follow.