In this episode of Horror Whiskey Company, hosts Jamie and Practical Pete discuss the Scream trilogy, focusing on the first three films. They explore the horror genre's landscape, the significance of self-awareness in the Scream movies, and the character dynamics, particularly the motivations behind Ghostface. The conversation also touches on the cultural impact of the franchise and the evolution of horror films. In this conversation, Jamie and Practical Pete delve into the nuances of the Scream franchise, comparing it to Halloween, discussing the challenges of sequels, and exploring character development. They highlight the importance of sound design in horror films and the meta-commentary that Scream employs to engage viewers. The discussion culminates in an analysis of the trilogy's conclusion, emphasizing how it ties together various narrative threads while addressing cultural commentary.

Two young women. One historic mansion. A mystery that refuses to rest.In this episode, we dive into the unsolved murders of Kara and Marianne, two young women whose tragic deaths in the 1970s still haunt investigators, historians, and true-crime followers decades later.We explore the dark history surrounding the Lumber Baron Inn, the investigative challenges of the time, and the theories that have emerged as the case slipped further into cold-case territory. From missed opportunities and societal blind spots to the lingering questions that never received answers, this case highlights how justice can fade—but never fully disappear.We also examine why unsolved cases like this continue to resonate, the emotional toll they leave behind, and how paranormal investigations have entered the conversation as people search for closure where the system fell short.Justice delayed. Truth obscured. A legacy that still lingers.🕯️ Watch until the end for our reflections on justice, memory, and why some stories refuse to stay buried.👉 Subscribe for weekly episodes covering true crime, dark history, hauntings, and the unexplained👍 Like the video to help support the channel💬 Comment below — what theory do you find most compelling?#TrueCrime #UnsolvedMysteries #ColdCase #LumberBaronInn #DarkHistory #HauntedHistory #Paranormal #JusticeDelayed #1970sCrime #TrueCrimeCommunity #HorrorPodcast #crimediscussion Chapters00:00 Introduction to Horror Whiskey Company02:36 The Unsolved Murders and Paranormal Investigations05:03 The 28 Days Haunted Concept08:01 The Cold Case and Its Impact10:42 The Role of Ghosts in Seeking Justice13:17 The Lumber Mill Inn: A Historical Overview16:16 The Victims: Kara and Marianne's Story25:22 The Vulnerability of Runaways28:04 Understanding the Victims29:59 The Crime Scene and Investigation36:41 The Unsolved Case and Its Aftermath39:12 The Haunting of the Lumber Baron Inn50:47 Paranormal Investigations and Public Fascination55:09 The Psychic Drama Unfolds56:02 Exploring Ghost Hunting Shows57:35 Claims of Spirit Communication58:48 The Search for Justice01:00:12 Beliefs in the Supernatural01:01:07 Investigating the Murders01:03:07 The Discrepancies in Kara's Case01:05:54 Theories of Violence and Motive01:07:50 Connections to Organized Crime01:12:40 The Unsolved Mystery of Marianne01:14:03 The Quest for Closure01:17:07 Reflections on Justice and Ghosts

When real life feels scarier than the movies… you know it’s a wild episode.

In this episode of Horror Whiskey Company, we dive into the stories that blur the line between true crime and horror. From unsettling real-world cases — including a recently reopened investigation — to the latest horror films like Bone Lake and 28 Years Later, we break down why reality often feels more terrifying than fiction.

We also discuss:
🩸 The true crime cases that still don’t make sense
🎥 Upcoming horror movies we’re excited (and nervous) about
📺 How horror is evolving on streaming platforms
🧠 The Elizabeth Smart documentary and why survivor stories matter
👻 A fun debate: would you rather be a paranormal YouTuber or a small-town cop in a horror movie?

Grab a drink, settle in, and let’s talk about the stories that won’t let us sleep.

🎙️ New episodes weekly
🥃 Horror, true crime & dark storytelling
📺 Subscribe for more eerie conversations

In this episode, the hosts delve into the eerie true crime story of the Watcher, a case that revolves around the Broadus family who received unsettling letters from an anonymous figure known as the Watcher after purchasing their new home. The conversation explores the psychological impact of fear, the community's response, and the ongoing mystery surrounding the identity of the Watcher. In this gripping conversation, the hosts delve into the chilling mystery of 'The Watcher,' a case involving a family who received threatening letters from an unknown individual after moving into their new home. The discussion explores various suspects, the role of the community, the psychological impact of fear and paranoia, and the unsettling nature of the letters that escalated over time. As the investigation unfolds, the hosts analyze the implications of the case on the family's life and the broader community, ultimately leading to a haunting conclusion that leaves many questions unanswered.

Summary

In this episode, the hosts discuss their personal experiences with alcohol, including the challenges of Dry January. They transition into a disturbing kidnapping story involving a young woman and her mother, who orchestrated the kidnapping to prevent her from communicating with an online predator. The conversation shifts to the legal implications of the case and the shortcomings of the justice system. The episode concludes with a shocking story about a grave robber, Jonathan Garlic, who was caught with human remains, leading to a discussion about the bizarre nature of his crimes and the societal implications. In this conversation, the hosts delve into the finale of Stranger Things, discussing character arcs, the stakes of the plot, and the overall quality of the series. They express disappointment in the finale's execution, particularly regarding character deaths and the pacing of the final battle. The discussion transitions to the nostalgia factor of the show and how it resonates with audiences. They also critique the acting quality, especially among adult characters, and share their thoughts on new horror films and true crime documentaries, highlighting the evolving landscape of horror and storytelling. In this engaging conversation, the hosts delve into various topics, including the controversial practices of parenting coaches, the influence of social media on parenting, and their personal preferences regarding true crime documentaries. They also discuss upcoming horror movies and engage in a fun segment called 'Questions for the Crypt,' where they humorously debate fictional characters and their potential as roommates.

Summary

In this engaging podcast episode, hosts Punctual Pete and Jamie reflect on the year 2025 in horror cinema, sharing their top 10 horror movie picks. They discuss the unique aspects of each film, from the heartwarming yet chilling 'Good Boy' to the graphic body horror of 'The Ugly Stepsister', and the campy slasher fun of 'The Monkey'. The conversation is filled with humor, insights, and a deep appreciation for the horror genre, making it a must-listen for fans. In this conversation, Punctual Pete and Jamie delve into various horror films, discussing unexpected plot twists, the dynamics of cult themes, and the effectiveness of body horror. They explore the surprising entry of 'Final Destination Bloodlines' and the visual mastery of Guillermo del Toro's 'Frankenstein', while also analyzing the unique experience of 'Sinners'. The dialogue highlights the evolution of horror storytelling and the impact of cinematography on viewer experience. In this conversation, Pete and Jamie delve into various themes surrounding music, film, and the horror genre. They explore the impact of storytelling, the evolution of horror movies, and the emotional connections that arise from cinematic experiences. The discussion highlights the significance of rewatching films to uncover deeper meanings and the influence of personal experiences on their perceptions of movies. Ultimately, they reflect on the best horror films of the year and the emotional weight they carry, especially in light of personal losses.

Summary

In this conversation, the hosts delve into the Montauk Project, exploring its origins, the experiments conducted, and the emergence of Duncan Cameron's abilities. They discuss the escalating nature of the experiments, the physical anomalies observed, and the introduction of Al Beelick, linking the Montauk Project to the Philadelphia Experiment. The conversation is filled with humor and insights into the bizarre world of government conspiracies and psychic phenomena. This conversation delves into the Philadelphia Experiment and its alleged connection to the Montauk Project, exploring themes of time travel, government experiments, and the psychological manipulation of children. The discussion highlights the disturbing realities of Project Phoenix, where children were subjected to extreme emotional conditioning to create psychic operatives. The narrative builds towards a climactic moment where a dangerous experiment leads to the emergence of an unknown creature, raising questions about the ethical boundaries of scientific exploration. This conversation delves into the Montauk Project, exploring the chaotic events surrounding a creature encounter, the subsequent evacuation, and the psychological implications of memory suppression. The discussion also touches on the blurred lines between truth and fiction in Preston Nichols' accounts, the government's secretive nature, and the enduring fascination with conspiracy theories.

Summary

In this episode, Jamie and Pete explore various themes ranging from personal updates to true crime discussions. They delve into the Gilgo Beach serial killer case, the Brian Walsh trial, and a disturbing story about a retired teacher turned Santa Claus facing serious charges. The conversation also touches on the latest horror news and reviews of a popular horror show, highlighting character development and impressive CGI. In this conversation, the hosts delve into various themes surrounding the series 'Stranger Things' and its connections to Stephen King's lore, particularly focusing on the character development, the anticipation for the finale, and the implications of Netflix's strategies on the movie theater industry. They also explore conspiracy theories related to the Montauk Project and how these elements intertwine with the narrative of 'Stranger Things'.