Question 5: How could there have been light on the first day if God didn’t create the sun and moon until the fourth day? Isn’t that a contradiction? cover art

Question 5: How could there have been light on the first day if God didn’t create the sun and moon until the fourth day? Isn’t that a contradiction?

Question 5: How could there have been light on the first day if God didn’t create the sun and moon until the fourth day? Isn’t that a contradiction?

Listen for free

View show details

About this listen

Episode Summary

It is one of the most common "gotchas" in biblical study: How could there be light on Day 1 if the sun wasn't created until Day 4? In this episode, we tackle this perceived contradiction. We explore the nature of divine light, the difference between light and "light-bearers," and why this sequence is a powerful statement about God’s independence from His creation.

Key Discussion Points

1. The Source vs. The Bearer

Genesis 1:3 records God commanding light into existence long before the sun (the "greater light") appears in verse 14. This distinction teaches us that light is not dependent on the sun; rather, both are dependent on God.

  • Day 1: Light is created and separated from darkness.
  • Day 4: God creates "light-bearers" (the sun, moon, and stars) to govern and manage that light for the earth's seasons and calendar.

2. God as the Uncreated Light

The Bible consistently portrays God Himself as the ultimate source of illumination.

  • Revelation 21:23: In the New Jerusalem, there is no need for the sun because "the glory of God gives it light."
  • 1 John 1:5: Declares that "God is light," suggesting that the light of Day 1 may have been a direct manifestation of His presence or a unique physical light sustained by His word.

3. The Functional View of Day 4

Some scholars suggest that "the heavens" created in Genesis 1:1 included the celestial bodies, but they were not "appointed" or made visible from the earth's surface until Day 4. On this day, God gave them their specific "ruling" functions—marking days, years, and religious festivals.

4. Spiritual Symbolism: From Creation to Christ

The physical light of Genesis sets the stage for the spiritual light of the Gospel.

  • John 8:12: Jesus identifies as the "Light of the World." * Just as God brought physical light to a dark, formless earth, He brings spiritual truth to a world darkened by sin. The order of creation proves that God doesn't need the sun to give us light; He provides it directly.

Notable Quote

"God creating light before the sun isn’t a contradiction; it’s a declaration of independence. It shows that the physical elements obey Him, and that creation depends on God—not the other way around."

Scriptural References

  • Genesis 1:3-5 – The creation of light.
  • Genesis 1:14-19 – The appointment of the sun, moon, and stars.
  • Revelation 21:23 – The sunless light of the New Heaven.
  • 1 John 1:5 – The nature of God as light.
  • John 8:12 – Jesus as the light of the world.
No reviews yet