In September of 1984, Sandy was last seen getting picked up at her local bowling alley, headed to a party. But, who was at this party? What did these people want and who did they work for? Because, Sandy was not the only young girl to go missing. Oklahoma's finest, or most corrupt? You decide as Sully and Jones put the pieces of this chilling case together.

Peggy Anna McGuire, age 28, disappeared after dropping her son off at school. After an abandoned truck is found, suspicions surround what really happenend to Peggy? Her step-father was the last to speak to her, he states she never made it home. Her husband is seen driving down the highway in a tractor. Who killed Peggy and where is her body? Listen, as we explore suspects, timelines and theories.

Episode 2 – Forensics, Suspects & Where the Case Stands
In part two, we dive deeper into the investigation—examining the forensics, early leads, and the complex web of suspects tied to the case. We explore the twists, false confessions, and controversies that have kept this case unsolved for decades. Finally, we bring the story into the present, asking: where does the Yogurt Shop case stand today, and will justice ever be found?

KTR created our own maps, pictures and timelines that you can view on our Instragram account: https://www.instagram.com/kitchen.table.research?utm_source=ig_web_button_share_sheet&igsh=ZDNlZDc0MzIxNw==

And make sure you give us a follow for short form content and other cases on our TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@marcusthebunny?is_from_webapp=1&sender_device=pc