Episodes

  • PCA MVP, Bitter Taste
    Nov 18 2026

    PCA wins MVP and we’re sitting here asking a question that feels almost illegal as Cubs fans: why doesn’t it feel better? Carl and Mahoney open with the weird emotional math of awards season when the standings still scream “14 games back,” and we dig into what an MVP year actually means if the roster around it still cannot chase down Milwaukee. If you’ve ever celebrated a Cubs highlight and then immediately remembered the division race, you’ll feel seen.

    Then we let the maniacs run the show with a mailbag that hits every pressure point of the Cubs offseason. We settle a family argument waiting to happen with Sammy Sosa versus PCA, talk honestly about Jon Lester and Jake Arrieta showing up on the Hall of Fame ballot, and get into the uncomfortable truth about how Cooperstown standards work for starting pitchers. We also tackle the question every season ticket holder asks sooner or later: what’s the real number where you let a proven bat like Seiya Suzuki walk?

    We finish by ripping through trade and pitching hypotheticals with zero patience for bad process. Trading Matt Shaw for one year of Steven Kwan? No. Betting your rotation hopes on the next mystery arm without first buying real big-league certainty? Also no. We react to early pitching market moves, the looming lockout chatter, and why the Brewers keep turning “who is this guy” arms into weapons while the Cubs keep trying to reinvent players instead of unlocking them.

    Subscribe, share the show with a fellow Cubs fan, and leave a review if you want more mailbag episodes like this. What’s your offseason priority, paying Seiya, buying pitching, or both?

    Thanks for tuning in!

    - Carl & Mahoney

    Show More Show Less
    50 mins
  • The Mailbag Says Spend Like You Mean It
    Nov 11 2026

    Bad injury news, messy payroll math, and a fan base that can smell a half-measure from a mile away. We sit down for a fast offseason check-in and start with the thing that changes the entire pitching conversation: Ben Brown’s surgery and what it should force the Chicago Cubs to assume when they build next year’s rotation. No fantasy innings projections, no rosy timelines, just the uncomfortable planning a serious team has to do when health is a question mark.

    Then we get into the money, because “payroll coming off the books” sounds like a blank check until you remember how quickly raises, arbitration bumps, and luxury tax choices eat into that space. We talk through what the Cubs realistically have to spend, what we wish they’d spend, and why starting pitching has to be the first priority if the goal is more than just looking good on paper.

    The mailbag brings the heat: why the Brewers keep winning, what identity actually looks like over 162 games, and why Cubs talk still feels like homework even with Pete Crow-Armstrong turning into a centerpiece. We also tackle what happens if Seiya Suzuki or Ian Happ walks, whether trading prospects for pitching makes sense with a lockout looming, and the eternal ninth-inning question of when the Cubs finally pay for stability.

    If you’ve been trying to make sense of the Cubs offseason, hit play, then subscribe, share the show with a fellow fan, and leave a quick review so more Cubs people find us.

    Thanks for tuning in!

    - Carl & Mahoney

    Show More Show Less
    38 mins
  • Why Draft Picks Shape The Cubs Offseason Plans
    Nov 5 2026

    A lockout is staring MLB in the face, and you can feel it in every quiet rumor and every awkward quote teams put out to “get in front of” not spending. We’re back on the Monday Morning Cubs show (yes, on a Wednesday) to talk through what that uncertainty actually means for the Chicago Cubs offseason, and why it can drain the energy out of roster talk before it even starts.

    We get into the nuts and bolts that drive the entire market: qualifying offers, what it means when a player turns one down, and how draft pick compensation can change a team’s incentives. If you’ve ever wondered why clubs sometimes sit on their hands at the deadline or avoid certain free agents, this is the mechanism behind it. We also talk about why the Cubs seem determined to protect draft capital and “controllable talent,” and when that mindset turns from smart process into a convenient excuse.

    From there, we zoom out to what actually moves the needle: run prevention. We argue about whether small bullpen signings should ever feel like headlines, react to Alex Bregman’s Gold Glove news, and then build a post-lockout wish list focused on arms that can win real games. Tarik Skubal, Freddy Peralta, Michael King, and the bigger question underneath it all: are the Cubs ready to pay for pitching that can dominate a season and a postseason?

    If you enjoyed the chaos, subscribe so you don’t miss the next one, share it with a Cubs fan who’s already doomscrolling, and leave us a review so we can keep the giveaways going. What’s the one move you’d make the day the lockout ends?

    Thanks for tuning in!

    - Carl & Mahoney

    Show More Show Less
    41 mins
  • The Cubs Cannot Keep Settling For Good Enough
    Oct 27 2026

    The Brewers are on the doorstep of a World Series win and I’m feeling every ugly emotion that comes with it as a Cubs fan. So I grabbed the mic solo and said the quiet part out loud: I’m tired of “good enough,” tired of watching the Cubs drift, and tired of leadership acting like 89 wins is the finish line instead of the warning sign. If you’ve been doomscrolling the Cubs offseason and wondering what the plan even is, you’re in the right place.

    We talk about the MLB lockout that feels inevitable, why owners will lean on ratings and revenue arguments, and why that could lead to a weird, stingy winter for teams that rely on game-day cash. From there I get into what’s actually broken on the North Side: no real accountability, constant excuses, rising prices, and a roster that still screams for healthy starting pitching and more impact. Yes, I’m mad, but it’s the kind of mad that comes from caring.

    Then it’s Baller or Strike time: Pete Crow-Armstrong’s viral moment and the graduation “obligation,” John Mallee staying with the Cubs, why I don’t care about safe veteran moves, and why “injured pitching” can’t be a strategy anymore. We also hit trade and roster speculation, including Reed Detmers, a big swing for a starter like George Kirby, and the messy reality of Matt Shaw’s spotlight versus his on-field standing.

    If you want honest Cubs talk with zero sugarcoating, press play. Subscribe, share the show with a fellow suffering Cubs fan, and leave a review so this little community keeps growing.

    Thanks for tuning in!

    - Carl & Mahoney

    Show More Show Less
    45 mins
  • Who’s Actually Pitching for the Cubs Next Year?
    Oct 20 2026

    The Cubs need three starters, Happ and Seiya could be heading out the door, and the Brewers are playing for a championship. What exactly is the plan for 2027?

    Carl and Mahoney dig into the biggest questions facing the Cubs this offseason, starting with a rotation that can’t simply count on healthy versions of Justin Steele and Cade Horton. Where does Jed Hoyer find the pitching this team needs—and how do you replace Ian Happ and Seiya Suzuki if both leave?

    Watching Milwaukee succeed brings out some familiar frustration with a Cubs organization that keeps spending B-plus money on B-minus players. We get into where the money should go, why another big trade might create more problems than it solves, and whether the front office will learn the right lessons from this October.

    Plus: five Gold Glove finalists, Ian Happ’s complicated relationship with Cubs fans, and why rooting against the Brewers still doesn’t come close to hating the Cardinals.

    Thanks for tuning in!

    - Carl & Mahoney

    Show More Show Less
    59 mins
  • Cancel Marquee And Buy Yourself Some Thirsty Vaquero
    Oct 13 2026

    October baseball is supposed to feel like a celebration, but as Cubs fans we’re stuck watching it from the outside while the Brewers look annoyingly legit. We start with that exact mood: a little relief, a lot of bitterness, and zero patience for Major League Baseball decisions that make the sport harder to follow. When playoff games start in the middle of a workday, we’re not just nitpicking, we’re calling out a league that keeps choosing convenience for TV windows over the actual fan experience.

    From there we jump into the kind of headline that makes you do a double take: benching Shohei Ohtani. We talk through why it sounds impossible unless there’s a real injury behind it, and what it says about how teams manage stars when the stakes get high. We also get into who we’re pulling for with the Cubs out, why Cleveland has a weirdly compelling case, and how MLB’s “best script” doesn’t always match what fans want.

    Then we go where every serious baseball conversation is headed: the lockout cloud. We explain why owners love turning fans against players, why that framing is backwards, and why “lost time” hits players in a way it never hits billionaires. After that, it’s pure Cubs offseason reality: Convention uncertainty, outfield questions, prospect stat inflation from minor league ball changes, bullpen role envy, and real frustration with how unprepared the team looked when it mattered. We close on the biggest long-term question of all: can the Cubs actually build around Pete Crow-Armstrong, or are we watching the start of a wasted window?

    If you’re riding the same Cubs roller coaster, hit subscribe, share this with a friend, and leave a review so more fans find the show.

    Thanks for tuning in!

    - Carl & Mahoney

    Show More Show Less
    47 mins
  • Jed Hoyer’s Stupid Press Conference + Playoff Reactions
    Oct 5 2026

    That Jed Hoyer press conference hit a nerve, and I’m not going to pretend it didn’t. I’m coming in hot after the Cubs’ playoff loss to the Padres because the messaging and the reality do not match. You can’t watch a short series swing on non-competitive at-bats at the top of the order, early crooked numbers allowed, and a bullpen that never scares anyone, then walk to the mic and act like the answers are vague or far away.

    We talk through the three on-field reasons the Cubs lose that series, then pull the camera back to the bigger Cubs pitching problem: dead-last velocity, not enough swing-and-miss, and decision-making that makes a thin staff look even thinner. I also get into the health side, because year after year of key arms missing time stops being “baseball luck” and starts looking like an organizational failure. If the Cubs can build a top offense and still finish well behind the division standard, the roster construction and pitching development plan deserve real heat.

    Then we get into what I think is coming next: mutual options declined, payroll walking out the door, and the MLB lockout threat becoming the easiest excuse in the world for Tom Ricketts and the business side to slow spending. My view is simple: stop bargain hunting and pay for real frontline starting pitching in free agency, even if it’s uncomfortable, because wasting elite seasons is the most expensive choice of all.

    If you’re a Cubs fan who feels like you’re being sold a story instead of a plan, you’ll want this one. Subscribe, share the show with another Cubs fan, and leave a review with your one non-negotiable offseason move.

    Thanks for tuning in!

    - Carl & Mahoney

    Show More Show Less
    43 mins
  • Game 1 Wild Card Recap + Game 2 Preview
    Sep 30 2026

    One hit. Eight runs allowed. Zero room to hide. That’s the kind of playoff opener that makes you question everything, from roster construction to the first pitch plan, and I’m not pretending I’m calm about it. I’m Carl, and this Monday Morning Cubs Show is a special recap and Game 2 preview built for Cubs fans who need to vent first, then refocus fast because it’s winner go home tonight at Petco Park.

    We start with the hard part: accountability. I break down why starting Matt Boyd in Game 1 felt like a leadership failure, why the matchup against the Padres lineup looked wrong on paper and looked worse on the field, and how a “gutless” vibe can spread once you fall behind early. Then we dig into what actually happened between the lines. Michael King’s movement, command, and ability to work both sides of the plate turned our at-bats into weak contact and ugly swings, and it exposed how quickly a top offense can look lost in October.

    From there, we turn the page to real adjustments for Cubs vs Padres Game 2. I give a scouting report on Nick Pivetta, why his vertical approach and strikeout stuff create a different kind of pressure than King, and what the Cubs need to do to avoid pressing. On the mound, Kevin Gausman becomes the fulcrum: I lay out why pitching “backwards” with early splitters and discomfort inside can change the tone, and why we need length from him to avoid bullpen chaos.

    If you’re riding the emotional swing of the MLB postseason, hit play, then tell me what you’re watching for tonight. Subscribe, share the show with a Cubs fan who’s spiraling, and leave a review so we can keep firing these off when the games demand it.

    Thanks for tuning in!

    - Carl & Mahoney

    Show More Show Less
    31 mins