Welcome back to episode 9! We’ve got a packed house this week with six chilling tales: four curated from the depths of Reddit and two harrowing submissions from our very own listeners. Grab a drink, dim the lights, and let’s get into it.

This Week’s Stories:

• The Ghost of Julia: We start with Reddit user SpookyMoth2, who shares a haunting account of being followed by a spirit attached to their sister.
• Red Door, Yellow Door: Masada831 takes us through a firsthand experience with the infamous mind game. Some doors should stay closed.
• The Man in The Shadows: Listener Sarah wrote us to share her terrifying, real-life encounter with a persistent stalker.
• The Thing Wearing My Husband: Reddit user Proof_Poem3707 shares a bone-chilling account of realizing her husband might actually be an SW (flesh pedestrian, dermis slow jogger).
• The Conjuring in Real Life: Listener Annalise recounts a paranormal experience so intense it mirrors the cinematic scares of The Conjuring.
• The Trilogy Continues (Part 2): We wrap up with the highly anticipated second installment from I_go_by_kk. Last week we heard one side—now, we see the story through the husband’s eyes.

Connect With Us

Do you have a story that keeps you up at night? Or is there a specific urban legend you want us to dive into? We want to hear from you!

• DM us on Socials: @OfMaliceAndMirth (Instagram/Twitter/TikTok)
• Email us: OfMaliceAndMirth@gmail.com

If you enjoyed this episode, please rate, review, and subscribe to help more listeners find our circle of malice and mirth!

Happy Listening!

Welcome to the eighth installment of Of Malice and Mirth! This week, we’re diving deep into the dark waters of mermaid lore.

In this episode:

• The Origin Myth: Whitney takes us back to the beginning with the history of Atargatis, the world’s very first mermaid.
• Original Fiction: Mena shares a terrifying, original tale of a mermaid that is far from a fairy tale.
• From the Depths of Reddit: We wrap up with two spine-chilling creepypastas from Reddit users u/I_go_by_kkand u/pentyworth223.

💌 Share Your Stories Have a creepy encounter or a hilarious "palate cleanser" story? We want to hear it!

• Email: OfMaliceAndMirth@gmail.com
• DMs: Reach out on any of our social platforms.

📱 Follow @OfMaliceAndMirth on socials!

Happy Listening!

Hello hello! Welcome back to Of Malice And Mirth!

Today you get a double whammy. First, Whitney leads us through the conspiracy theory that is the Montauk Project, with a special appearance from the Montauk Monster! Then Mena takes us to the bottomless pit of Hell that is IN the Houska Castle!

After that, we have the next two chapters in the ELECTRIFYING dinosaur saga by Jacob The Narrator.

Then Mena brings it home with another one of her creations- this one will make Whitney lose sleep. It was wonderful.

Don't forget to follow us on socials, and leave us a review, please!

And definitely don't forget to send in your own story submissions to OfMaliceAndMirth@gmail.com

Happy Listening!

HEY HEY HEY! Welcome to episode 6 where WE GOT NEW MICS! And we attempted and failed at video. So, sorry about that. But we will continue to work on getting visuals.

Today, we have a little history lesson on the absurdity that was MK Ultra. Then Mena delivers an absolute mindfuck of a story that she wrote! Followed by the first installment of a very intense story by Jacob The Narrator, AKA Reddit user Turbulent-tale-8738. The final story is a true one that had us rolling from Angel R!

Please send in your story submissions to OfMaliceAndMirth@gmail.com or you can DM us on any of the socials. Just search Of Malice And Mirth! Don’t forget to follow, and share us with your loved ones who you think need a good scare!

Welcome back to Of Malice and Mirth!

In Episode 5, we kick things off by checking into one of the most haunted locations in the U.S.: the infamous Jefferson Palace Hotel. From shadowy figures and phantom children to deeply unsettling encounters reported by guests and staff alike, this place has earned its terrifying reputation. We end it with a true experience by a paranormal investigator named Adam!

Then we have a truly unsettling story from Reddit user Donavan221, followed by insane stories by Shane 1 and Shane 2!

Don't forget to send in your own stories to OfMaliceAndMirth@gmail.com and please rate and review if you love us as much as we love you :)

Mena's Sources:

https://www.hauntedrooms.com/texas/haunted-places/haunted-hotels/jefferson-hotel-jefferson

https://cravedfw.com/2025/09/12/the-jefferson-hotel-a-historic-gem-in-jefferson-texas/

https://npiweb.com/blog/posts/haunted-places-series-jefferson-hotel/

Welcome back for week 4, where we cover DOPPLEGANGERS!

This week, Whitney starts us out with some info and history on doppelgängers, including the story of Emilie Sagee and a little story about Abraham Lincoln! Then Mena reads a story she wrote that has all the twists and turns. Next is a story by GamalFrank on Reddit that had us on the edge of our seats, followed by a story from Shane 2 that unlocked a new fear in our poor little hearts.

Don’t forget to send in your story submissions to OfMaliceAndMirth@gmail.com

Happy Listening!

Whitney’s sources:

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/readersblog/james/emilie-sagee-and-the-

strange-case-of-the-doppelganger-5362/

https://www.curiousarchive.com/emilie-sagee-bilocation-doppelganger/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Émilie_Sagée

Welcome to week 3! “She Was A Fairy” - bonus points if you can name that movie!

First, Whitney tells us all about the Mooinjer Veggey- the “little people” of the Isle of Man. Then, Mena reads us a story that her and AI came up with together called “A Cold Night.” Whitney almost cried, y’all. Get ready. THENNNN Whitney reads us a more comical fairy story by AI. Lastly, Mena reads a spooky story about what happens when you enter a fairy trap!

Don’t forget to send us your spooky submissions to OfMaliceAndMirth@gmail.com

Happy Listening!

paranormal podcast, spooky folklore, creepy storytelling, listener submitted stories, unexplained phenomena, fairies, little people folklore, fae, fairy traps

It's week 2, baby! If you're back for more, what's wrong with you? But also, WE LOVE YOU!

Today Whitney tells us the story of the alien abduction of Antonio Villas Boas, followed by Mena telling a crazy story involving skin suits, extraterrestrials, and an alarming amount of nasty smells.

Don't forget to send in your own creepy tales, true or fictional, to OfMaliceAndMirth@gmail.com

Thanks for listening!!

Sources for Whitney's story:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antônio_Vilas-Boas?utm_source=chatgpt.com

https://www.livescience.com/20250-alien-abductions-origins.html

paranormal podcast, real alien encounters, true alien abduction stories, UFO, spooky podcast, listener submitted stories, creepy storytelling podcast