This week on Registry Matters: We examine a Colorado Supreme Court ruling that upheld the sexually violent predator designation as non-punitive under the Eighth Amendment, exploring why courts continue to refuse calling registration punishment. We also dig into Michigan’s sweeping employment ban that would prohibit all 45,000 registrants from working in youth-serving businesses, and the constitutional challenges it faces.

• [02:00] Can 45,000 Registrants Be Banned at Once? — Michigan’s broad employment ban on all registrants from youth-serving businesses faces constitutional challenges and vagueness concerns.
• [17:24] Why Courts Refuse to Call Registration Punishment — Colorado’s Supreme Court ruled the sexually violent predator designation is not punishment under the Eighth Amendment.

• [02:00] Can 45,000 Registrants Be Banned at Once?
• [17:24] Why Courts Refuse to Call Registration Punishment

Registry Matters: https://www.registrymatters.co/

FYP Education: https://fypeducation.org/

Email us: registrymatterscast@gmail.com

Leave an old fashioned voice message: 747-227-4477

Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/registrymatters

Join the Discord server: https://discord.gg/6FnxwAQm57

Want to support Registry Matters with some swag: https://fypeducation.org/shop/

Apple Podcasts: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/registry-matters/id1305039280

RSS: https://www.registrymatters.co/feed/podcast/

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3d75P7Kc37n2l79m89F9KI

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/registrymatters

The Registry Matters Podcast’s mission is to cover issues surrounding the Registry. We cover cases that will peel back the veneer of what we need to do to change our lives for the better. We cover news articles that spark conversations about the total insanity of this modern day witch hunt. This podcast will call out bad policy and call out those that are making bad policy.

To change things for the positive, we need to act. We are 6-7-8-900k strong. With that many people, plus their friends and family, over a million people are affected by the registry. We should be able to secure donations to hire lawyers and lobbyists to move the agenda in our favor. We need our people to be represented.

This week on Registry Matters: A federal court finds that Illinois’s civil commitment program violates due process by warehousing people for up to 45 years without adequate treatment. Plus, we explore the paradox of legal challenges to registry regulations — when winning in court can trigger political backlash that produces even harsher laws.

• [07:15] Can Legal Victories Create Worse Laws? — Unnecessary litigation against registry regulations risks creating worse laws through political backlash and public pressure.
• [15:00] 45 Years Locked Up for What He Might Do — Federal court ruled Illinois civil commitment program violates due process by failing to provide adequate treatment.

• [07:15] Can Legal Victories Create Worse Laws?
• [15:00] 45 Years Locked Up for What He Might Do

Registry Matters: https://www.registrymatters.co/

FYP Education: https://fypeducation.org/

Email us: registrymatterscast@gmail.com

Leave an old fashioned voice message: 747-227-4477

Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/registrymatters

Join the Discord server: https://discord.gg/6FnxwAQm57

Want to support Registry Matters with some swag: https://fypeducation.org/shop/

Apple Podcasts: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/registry-matters/id1305039280

RSS: https://www.registrymatters.co/feed/podcast/

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3d75P7Kc37n2l79m89F9KI

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/registrymatters

The Registry Matters Podcast’s mission is to cover issues surrounding the Registry. We cover cases that will peel back the veneer of what we need to do to change our lives for the better. We cover news articles that spark conversations about the total insanity of this modern day witch hunt. This podcast will call out bad policy and call out those that are making bad policy.

To change things for the positive, we need to act. We are 6-7-8-900k strong. With that many people, plus their friends and family, over a million people are affected by the registry. We should be able to secure donations to hire lawyers and lobbyists to move the agenda in our favor. We need our people to be represented.

This week on Registry Matters: A court blocks the federal government from prosecuting registrants in California, ruling that state certification of registration requirements is a prerequisite. Plus, we examine a case where a retired law enforcement officer’s son was caught in a sting operation targeting fictitious victims and received what many consider disproportionate punishment.

• [01:49] When a Cop’s Son Gets Caught in a Sting — A retired law enforcement officer’s son faces disproportionate consequences after a sting operation involving fictitious victims
• [07:24] Court Blocks Feds From Prosecuting PFRs — Federal court rules the government cannot prosecute California registrants without the state first certifying its registration requirements

• [01:49] When a Cop’s Son Gets Caught in a Sting
• [07:24] Court Blocks Feds From Prosecuting PFRs

Registry Matters: https://www.registrymatters.co/

FYP Education: https://fypeducation.org/

Email us: registrymatterscast@gmail.com

Leave an old fashioned voice message: 747-227-4477

Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/registrymatters

Join the Discord server: https://discord.gg/6FnxwAQm57

Want to support Registry Matters with some swag: https://fypeducation.org/shop/

Apple Podcasts: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/registry-matters/id1305039280

RSS: https://www.registrymatters.co/feed/podcast/

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3d75P7Kc37n2l79m89F9KI

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/registrymatters

The Registry Matters Podcast’s mission is to cover issues surrounding the Registry. We cover cases that will peel back the veneer of what we need to do to change our lives for the better. We cover news articles that spark conversations about the total insanity of this modern day witch hunt. This podcast will call out bad policy and call out those that are making bad policy.

To change things for the positive, we need to act. We are 6-7-8-900k strong. With that many people, plus their friends and family, over a million people are affected by the registry. We should be able to secure donations to hire lawyers and lobbyists to move the agenda in our favor. We need our people to be represented.

{ "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "FAQPage", "@id": "https://www.registrymatters.co/podcast/rm372-does-protecting-kids-require-spying-on-all/#faq", "mainEntity": [ { "@type": "Question", "name": "Can police lose qualified immunity for arresting a sex offender who followed their instructions?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Yes. In a North Carolina case discussed on Registry Matters, officers lost qualified immunity after arresting a registrant who was traveling with the sheriff office's own authorization. The court found that arresting someone for doing exactly what law enforcement told them they could do violated clearly established rights." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "What was the Meta $375 million verdict about?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Meta was hit with a $375 million verdict related to child safety concerns on its platforms. However, as discussed on Registry Matters, the more significant issue isn't the fine itself but the expanding surveillance infrastructure being built in the name of protecting children, which has broader privacy implications for all users." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Does protecting children online require mass surveillance?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Registry Matters examined how efforts to protect children are increasingly being used to justify building large-scale surveillance systems that monitor all users, not just potential offenders. The podcast argues that the real story behind cases like Meta's $375 million verdict is the normalization of this surveillance infrastructure rather than the financial penalties themselves." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "What happens if a registered sex offender travels with law enforcement permission and still gets arrested?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "According to a North Carolina case covered on Registry Matters, a registrant who followed the sheriff's office's own instructions to travel was arrested anyway. The officers involved lost their qualified immunity defense, meaning they could be held personally liable — a rare and significant outcome in cases involving law enforcement accountability." } } ] }

This week on Registry Matters: North Carolina officers lose qualified immunity after arresting a registrant who was following their own instructions to travel — a stunning case of law enforcement accountability. Plus, we dig into Meta’s $375 million verdict and why the real story isn’t the fine, but the expanding surveillance infrastructure being built in the name of protecting children.

[0:00] Introduction [2:35] Does Protecting Kids Require Spying on All? [33:21] Arrested for Following the Sheriff’s Orders

Registry Matters: https://www.registrymatters.co/

FYP Education: https://fypeducation.org/

Email us: registrymatterscast@gmail.com

Leave an old fashioned voice message: 747-227-4477

Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/registrymatters

Join the Discord server: https://discord.gg/6FnxwAQm57

Want to support Registry Matters with some swag: https://fypeducation.org/shop/

Apple Podcasts: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/registry-matters/id1305039280

RSS: https://www.registrymatters.co/feed/podcast/

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3d75P7Kc37n2l79m89F9KI

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/registrymatters

The Registry Matters Podcast’s mission is to cover issues surrounding the Registry. We cover cases that will peel back the veneer of what we need to do to change our lives for the better. We cover news articles that spark conversations about the total insanity of this modern day witch hunt. This podcast will call out bad policy and call out those that are making bad policy.

To change things for the positive, we need to act. We are 6-7-8-900k strong. With that many people, plus their friends and family, over a million people are affected by the registry. We should be able to secure donations to hire lawyers and lobbyists to move the agenda in our favor. We need our people to be represented.

This week on Registry Matters: NARSOL takes West Virginia to federal court, arguing the state's $125 annual registry fee is actually an unconstitutional fine that funds unrelated police services — a case that could reshape how states fund their registries. We also examine NARSOL's broader legal campaign challenging internet identifier disclosure requirements for registrants, with strategic litigation targeting unconstitutional laws across multiple states.

• Is Your Registry Fee Actually a Fine? — NARSOL files a federal lawsuit arguing West Virginia's $125 annual registry fee functions as an unconstitutional fine, with revenue diverted to fund general police services rather than registry operations.
• Fighting WV's Internet ID Disclosure Law — NARSOL mounts a legal challenge against unconstitutional internet identifier disclosure requirements imposed on registrants, part of a broader strategic litigation effort spanning multiple states.

registry fees, unconstitutional fines, West Virginia, NARSOL lawsuit, internet identifier disclosure, NARSOL litigation, sex offender registry, registrant rights

• [01:46] Is Your Registry Fee Actually a Fine?
• [35:28] Fighting WV's Internet ID Disclosure Law

Registry Matters: https://www.registrymatters.co/ FYP Education: https://fypeducation.org/ Email us: registrymatterscast@gmail.com Leave an old fashioned voice message: 747-227-4477 Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/registrymatters Join the Discord server: https://discord.gg/6FnxwAQm57 Want to support Registry Matters with some swag: https://fypeducation.org/shop/ Apple Podcasts: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/registry-matters/id1305039280 RSS: https://www.registrymatters.co/feed/podcast/ Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3d75P7Kc37n2l79m89F9KI YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/registrymatters

The Registry Matters Podcast's mission is to cover issues surrounding the Registry. We cover cases that will peel back the veneer of what we need to do to change our lives for the better. We cover news articles that spark conversations about the total insanity of this modern day witch hunt. This podcast will call out bad policy and call out those that are making bad policy.

To change things for the positive, we need to act. We are 6-7-8-900k strong. With that many people, plus their friends and family, over a million people are affected by the registry. We should be able to secure donations to hire lawyers and lobbyists to move the agenda in our favor. We need our people to be represented.

This week on Registry Matters: A New Jersey appellate court delivers a significant ruling requiring states to perform a similarity analysis before charging out-of-state registrants with registry violations. We also examine a Fresno city council's scramble to pass legislation blocking a registered person from running for office, and break down Wyoming's proposed grooming felony bill that would criminalize manipulative behavior before any physical abuse occurs, raising serious civil liberties questions.

• Council Scrambles to Stop PFR Candidate: Fresno council members rush to craft legislation that would prevent a registered person from seeking a city council seat.
• Can Kindness Become a Felony?: Wyoming introduces a grooming felony bill that criminalizes manipulative behavior prior to physical abuse, sparking debate over civil liberties implications.
• NJ Court Blocks Registry Charges: New Jersey's appellate court rules that states must conduct a similarity analysis before charging out-of-state registrants with failure to register.

sex offender registry, Fresno city council PFR candidate, Wyoming grooming felony bill, New Jersey registry ruling, similarity analysis, civil liberties, out-of-state registrants, registry compliance

• [02:40] Council Scrambles to Stop PFR Candidate
• [08:22] Can Kindness Become a Felony?
• [19:47] NJ Court Blocks Registry Charges

Registry Matters: https://www.registrymatters.co/ FYP Education: https://fypeducation.org/ Email us: registrymatterscast@gmail.com Leave an old fashioned voice message: 747-227-4477 Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/registrymatters Join the Discord server: https://discord.gg/6FnxwAQm57 Want to support Registry Matters with some swag: https://fypeducation.org/shop/ Apple Podcasts: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/registry-matters/id1305039280 RSS: https://www.registrymatters.co/feed/podcast/ Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3d75P7Kc37n2l79m89F9KI YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/registrymatters

The Registry Matters Podcast's mission is to cover issues surrounding the Registry. We cover cases that will peel back the veneer of what we need to do to change our lives for the better. We cover news articles that spark conversations about the total insanity of this modern day witch hunt. This podcast will call out bad policy and call out those that are making bad policy.

To change things for the positive, we need to act. We are 6-7-8-900k strong. With that many people, plus their friends and family, over a million people are affected by the registry. We should be able to secure donations to hire lawyers and lobbyists to move the agenda in our favor. We need our people to be represented.

On episode 368 of Registry Matters, Michigan's House Bill 5425 threatens to broadly ban registered persons from working at any business serving minors with penalties that could cost taxpayers $200K per incarceration, Nebraska courts side with the state in ruling that retroactive registration extensions are mere civil regulations rather than criminal punishment protected by ex post facto clauses, and New Mexico's legislative session killed most criminal justice reform bills but managed to pass one eliminating the statute of limitations — raising serious concerns about whether defendants can receive fair trials when witnesses and evidence have long since disappeared.

[0:00] Introduction [01:42] Michigan HB 5425 would broadly ban registered persons from working at any business serving minors, with steep felony penalties for violations. [11:57] Nebraska courts ruled that retroactive extensions of registration requirements are civil regulations, not criminal punishment, rejecting ex post facto challenges. [36:53] New Mexico's legislature killed most criminal justice bills but passed one eliminating statutes of limitations, threatening defendants' ability to mount a fair defense decades later.

https://www.registrymatters.co/podcast/rm368-is-registration-really-not-punishment/ Email us: registrymatterscast@gmail.com Leave an old fashioned voice message: 747 227-4477 Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/registrymatters Join the Discord server: https://discord.gg/6FnxwAQm57 Want to support Registry Matters with some swag: https://fypeducation.org/shop/

Apple Podcasts: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/registry-matters/id1305039280 RSS: https://www.registrymatters.co/feed/podcast/ Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3d75P7Kc37n2l79m89F9KI YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/registrymatters

The Registry Matters Podcast's mission is to cover issues surrounding the Registry. We cover cases that will peel back the veneer of what we need to do to change our lives for the better. We cover news articles that spark conversations about the total insanity of this modern day witch hunt. This podcast will call out bad policy and call out those that are making bad policy. To change things for the positive, we need to act. We are 6-7-8-900k strong. With that many people, plus their friends and family, over a million people are affected by the registry. We should be able to secure donations to hire lawyers and lobbyists to move the agenda in our favor. We need our people to be represented.