Immigration judge and former DHS chief counsel Ashley Tabaddor joins Reset Critical
for a candid, deeply informed look at immigration in America—what’s actually legal,
what’s political theater, and what’s being done in our name. She explains how asylum
truly functions, why “undocumented” is not a crime at the border, and how COVID-era
policies like Title 42 skewed the numbers we think we understand. Drawing on
history—from the Chinese Exclusion era to today—she shows how language, law, and
executive power can dehumanize entire communities and create a “frictionless
deportation machine.” We explore myths about crime, the economic realities of labor
markets, and the costs of confusing civil immigration enforcement with criminal policing.
Ashley also clarifies the Supreme Court’s shadow-docket posture and explains why
litigation can act as a barrier, but civil society must push for change. Beyond policy, we
discuss human connection, bias, and the importance of rebuilding civic literacy—checks
and balances, federalism, and due process—in everyday conversations. It’s a tough but
hopeful discussion about defending dignity and strengthening democracy, one informed
listener at a time.