Text The Show and you could hear your question on the next episode!

It was a cold December evening in 2017 when the football world stood still, waiting for a referee to decide what constitutes a catch. In this edition of Sports Scar’d, we welcome Logan from the Nerd Sesh Podcast to dissect the game that still haunts the city of Pittsburgh. We are looking back at the Week 15 clash between the Steelers and the Patriots, a matchup where the top seed in the AFC was on the line and history was written by a replay booth in New York.

The Standard is the Standard
The 2017 season felt like the year the Pittsburgh Steelers would finally reclaim their throne. With Ben Roethlisberger, Antonio Brown, and Le’Veon Bell all playing at an elite level, the Killer B’s era was at its peak. Logan joins us to discuss the emotional weight of that season. For years, the New England Patriots had been the final boss that the Steelers could not overcome. This game was supposed to be the turning point. We explore the mood in the city leading up to kickoff and what that specific roster represented to fans who believed this was their best shot at a seventh Lombardi Trophy.

Building the Belief
The atmosphere at Heinz Field was high-energy, and for the first fifty-nine minutes, it felt like the curse was finally lifting. Pittsburgh matched Tom Brady and Rob Gronkowski play for play. When JuJu Smith-Schuster caught a short pass and turned it into a massive 69-yard gain late in the fourth quarter, the stadium erupted. It wasn't just a big play; it felt like a statement. We discuss the feeling of control the Steelers had and the absolute certainty that they were about to secure home-field advantage through the playoffs.

The Catch That Wasn't
Then came the moment that redefined NFL officiating. Jesse James caught a pass over the middle, turned, and lunged for the goal line. In real-time, there was no doubt: it was a touchdown. We walk through the agonizing minutes of the replay review. Logan shares his perspective on the shift from celebration to confusion, and finally, to total disbelief as the officials ruled the ball hit the ground. We break down the survivor-the-ground rule and why it felt like a robbery to everyone watching in black and gold.

The Collapse and the Aftermath
The heartbreak didn't end with the reversal. We look into the immediate fallout: the fake spike that resulted in a game-ending interception. This single loss did more than just change the standings; it seemed to drain the emotional reservoir of the team. We discuss whether this moment caused the eventual playoff exit against Jacksonville and how it altered the legacy of the Killer B’s. Looking back, does this loss hurt more than the postseason failure? Logan reflects on the long-term resentment toward the league and whether any fan can truly move past a call that felt so fundamentally wrong.

Text The Show and you could hear your question on the next episode!

What happens when the camera stops rolling, but the heartbreak keeps going? In this special Director's Commentary, we pull back the curtain on the making of Sports Scar'd, taking you behind the lens of the episodes that defined our latest run. Host and director Kevin Pearce sits down to break down the creative process, the emotional weight of these interviews, and the hidden stories that didn't make the final cut.

We are revisiting seven distinct scars that shaped not just franchises, but the lives of the fans who lived through them. From the silence of a city losing its team overnight to the shock of a dynasty collapsing in real-time, this commentary track explores how we captured the raw emotion of sports history’s most painful moments.

Kevin walks through the production challenges and storytelling decisions behind the episodes:

• The Midnight Move: Discussing the eerie recounting of the Baltimore Colts fleeing in the dead of night and the challenge of visualizing a city’s sudden emptiness with guest Matt Neufield.
• The Butt Fumble & Aaron Rodgers: A double feature on New York Jets pain. We examine the tragicomedy of the Butt Fumble with Avril Stephens (JetsGirl) and shift gears to the crushing disappointment of Aaron Rodgers’ four-play season. Kevin reveals how they balanced the humor of the fumble with the genuine despair of the injury.
• The Decision & JR Smith: Two sides of LeBron James in Cleveland. We discuss the contrast between the anger of 2010’s The Decision (with Bobby G) and the stunned confusion of J.R. Smith’s 2018 Finals mistake (with Connor Hebbeler).
• The 3-1 Collapses: We break down the parallel heartbreaks of the OKC Thunder and the 73-9 Warriors. Kevin talks about the "emotional whiplash" described by guests NoLimitRico and Dean Simon, exploring how we structured these episodes to mirror the sudden fall from grace.

This isn't just a recap; it is a look at the craft of sports storytelling. We discuss how we create the show’s signature cinematic look, how we approach sensitive topics with superfans, and why reliving these memories—no matter how painful—is a necessary part of the healing process.

Whether you are a filmmaker interested in interview techniques or a sports fan wanting to hear the uncut thoughts behind the series, this commentary offers a new perspective on the scars we carry.

Watch the full episodes discussed:

• Baltimore Colts Midnight Move: https://youtu.be/OZe-mimoQ5g
• Butt Fumble (Jets): https://youtu.be/1qs26tIGXJY
• Aaron Rodgers Injury (Jets): https://youtu.be/NMmuwhoc8MQ
• LeBron’s Decision: https://youtu.be/bDK1_KE0eJI
• OKC Thunder 3-1 Collapse: https://youtu.be/Zenc5-BoJX8
• Warriors 73-9 Collapse: https://youtu.be/MwF1ikxT7WA
• JR Smith Game 1: https://youtu.be/f8i0NsYZi3w

Connect with Sports Scar'd: Twitter/X: @KPearceTV Instagram: @KPearceTV TikTok: @KPearceTV

About Sports Scar'd: Hosted by Kevin Pearce, Sports Scar'd is the show where sports heartbreak meets cinematic storytelling. We revisit the games, plays, and moments that broke fans' hearts and defined their fandoms. It is not about stats or highlights; it is about memory, emotion, and the scars left behind.

If you enjoyed this behind-the-scenes look, please like, comment, and subscribe. Tell us which epis

Text The Show and you could hear your question on the next episode!

What happens when one of the greatest games of LeBron James’ career slips through Cleveland’s fingers in the most unbelievable way? This episode of Sports Scar’d looks back at the night everything changed, the moment J.R. Smith grabbed a rebound that should’ve been a gift, and the confusion that turned into heartbreak across the NBA world.

Kevin Pearce sits down with Connor Hebbeler from Hero Ball Media, a lifelong LeBron fan who lived every high and low of the 2018 Cavaliers. Together, they walk through the emotional weight of that season, the pressure LeBron carried, and what it felt like to enter another Finals showdown with Golden State knowing the margin for error was razor thin.

Connor breaks down the mindset of Cavs fans heading into Game 1 and why LeBron’s 51-point performance felt almost unreal. They look back at those final seconds of regulation, the free throws, the hope, and the belief that Cleveland might steal one in Oakland.

Then comes the moment that changed everything. Where were you when J.R. secured the rebound? Did you think Cleveland was about to win? What went through your mind when he dribbled away from the basket with the entire season hanging in the balance? Connor relives the shock of that play, the silence, and the look on LeBron’s face that became one of the most unforgettable images in Finals history.

The episode digs into the emotional crash that followed, the overtime collapse, and the realization that a single mistake wiped out any real chance at an upset. Connor reflects on how this moment shaped the way fans remember LeBron’s last run in Cleveland, why that game still stings, and whether time has made the meme easier to laugh at.

From pain to humor to the strange place this moment holds in NBA history, this interview gives fans a real look at the night the Cavs’ miracle run unraveled.

Follow Me On Socials @KPearceTV

Text The Show and you could hear your question on the next episode!

The 2016 Warriors felt untouchable. They won seventy-three games, rewrote what people thought was possible in a regular season, and carried a feeling that the future belonged to them. This episode sits with that memory, then walks straight into the collapse that still follows Golden State fans everywhere.

Dean Simon joins Sports Scar’d to revisit the final stretch of a year that was supposed to crown a dynasty at its starting point. He talks about the rush of watching Steph, Klay, and Draymond roll through the league, the chase for seventy-three, and the nerves that came with each win stacking higher than the last.

We go back to the OKC comeback, the adrenaline that came with surviving it, and the belief that nothing could shake this team. Then Game 5 hits. Draymond’s suspension, LeBron turning the series around, and the moment Kyrie buried the shot that ripped the air out of Warriors fans everywhere. Dean walks through where he was, what he felt, and how fast the mood changed.

The episode also sits with the silence that followed. The jokes, the memes, the way sports media felt like a place you either avoided or forced yourself to watch just to feel anything at all. Dean talks about the emotional whiplash of going from a historic season to one of the most painful endings the league has ever seen.

We close by asking what that loss did to the Warriors’ legacy. Would 2016 have changed how people see the original core? Did needing Durant shift the story more than fans like to admit? And even after more titles, does that summer still sting? Dean opens up about pride, regret, and the words no Warriors fan ever wants to hear: “seventy-three and nine and they blew a three-one lead.”

If you lived through it, you’ll feel every beat of this one. If you didn’t, you’ll understand why that season sits heavy in Golden State history.

Text The Show and you could hear your question on the next episode!

The 3–1 collapse still hits like a punch to the chest for anyone who lived through it, and this episode sits with someone who felt every second. NoLimitRico joins Sports Scar’d to talk through the rise, the heartbreak, and the aftershock of the 2016 Western Conference Finals. This wasn’t just a blown lead. It was a moment when a dynasty felt close enough to touch before it slipped away one cold jump shot at a time.

We open by stepping back into the mid-2010s and the hope that surrounded the Thunder. Fans believed this was the year things would finally break their way. KD and Russ carried the energy of a duo built for greatness, and the roster around them felt ready for a real run. Rico talks about what that season meant at the time and why the belief in that group was so strong.

Then we move to the high point. OKC going up 3–1 on a 73-win Warriors team felt unreal. Game 3 blew the roof off the building and made the Finals feel close. Rico walks through the emotion of watching KD and Russ outplay a team everyone called unstoppable and how fans started to picture a parade that suddenly seemed possible.

The collapse still hurts to retell. From Game 5 onward, everything tightened. Game 6 brought one of the coldest shooting nights Thunder fans have ever seen while Klay Thompson turned into something supernatural. Rico breaks down where he was, how the mood shifted, and the exact moment he sensed it was slipping away. By Game 7, the final buzzer felt like a door slamming shut.

The fallout carried shock, anger, and confusion. Fans spent that week trying to figure out how something so promising turned into heartbreak. Rico talks about the mood in the fan base, the early signs that this might be the end of an era, and whether he believed they’d bounce back.

And then came the move that changed everything. KD choosing Golden State didn’t just reshape the franchise. It changed how people viewed those three losses forever. Rico speaks honestly about whether the collapse broke something inside that team and how he remembers that era now with distance and clarity.

We close with reflection. Pride, pain, forgiveness, unresolved frustration—Thunder fans carry all of it. Rico shares what he’d tell his 2016 self and what that run still represents today.

This is a story about hope, loss, and the kind of sports memory you never quite shake.

Text The Show and you could hear your question on the next episode!

On Thanksgiving night in 2012, millions watched one of the most infamous moments in NFL history: The Butt Fumble. For Jets fans, it wasn’t just a blooper—it was heartbreak broadcast live in front of the nation.

In this episode of Sports Scar’d, host Kevin Pearce sits down with lifelong Jets fan Avril Stephens, known online as Jetsgurl, to revisit the night everything fell apart. From the hope of the Rex Ryan years to the sting of Mark Sanchez running into his own lineman, Avril opens up about what it was like to witness a viral disaster that redefined her team’s identity.

Before the play, the Jets were still hanging onto belief. Two straight AFC Championship runs had fans dreaming of another shot. But by Thanksgiving 2012, frustration was building. The offense was sputtering, Sanchez was struggling, and the Patriots rivalry was already bitter. Then came that play.

Avril walks us through the exact moment she saw Sanchez collide with Brandon Moore, the stunned silence that followed, and how the replay looped endlessly before halftime. She recalls waking up the next morning to ESPN and social media replaying it again and again—turning one mistake into a meme that has lived on for more than a decade.

This episode dives into the emotional side of being a fan when your team becomes the joke. It’s about humiliation, loyalty, and the weird kind of pride that keeps you wearing green no matter what. For many, the Butt Fumble wasn’t just a loss—it was the moment the Jets’ heartbreak became part of pop culture.

Avril reflects on how her feelings toward Mark Sanchez have changed over time: once frustration, now empathy. Because every fan knows, deep down, that one play doesn’t define a player—but sometimes, it defines an era.

Watch, laugh, and maybe wince a little as we revisit the play that turned Thanksgiving into a nightmare.

🎥 Subscribe for more episodes of Sports Scar’d, where fans relive the moments that broke their hearts but never broke their loyalty.
💬 Comment: Where were you when the Butt Fumble happened?
#SportsScard #Jets #MarkSanchez #ButtFumble #KPearceTV #NFL #ThanksgivingFootball

Text The Show and you could hear your question on the next episode!

Sports Scar’d returns with a story that still makes Cleveland fans wince. This episode sits with Bobby G, a lifelong Cavaliers supporter who watched his hometown hero rise, leave, return, and rewrite a city’s future. The Decision aired on national TV on July 8, 2010, and the fallout carried years of anger, confusion, pride, and eventually a kind of healing that only sports can create.

The episode walks through the different stages of that night. You hear what it felt like to grow up with LeBron as a symbol of hope, a kid from Akron who carried the dreams of an entire region. Bobby explains what it meant to believe that a championship was coming, and how every playoff run felt like one step closer to something that would finally change Cleveland sports forever.

Then the mood shifts to that night on ESPN. Viewers were glued to the screen with a mix of nerves and excitement. Bobby walks us into the moment the announcement dropped. The line taking my talents to South Beach hit fans like a punch to the chest. You hear about rooms that went silent, people who yelled at their TVs, and a city that felt abandoned in real time.

The aftermath hit even harder. Bobby talks about the next morning when the news was everywhere. Jerseys burned, local radio exploded with emotion, and Dan Gilbert’s letter fueled even more tension. Bobby breaks down how that letter landed among fans, and why it became its own part of the story.

Years of frustration followed while Miami stacked trophies and Cleveland searched for direction. Still, everything shifted again when LeBron returned in 2014 and pulled off the 2016 championship run. Bobby reflects on whether that moment closed the wound or simply softened it. His answers show how sports memories stay with us long after the final buzzer.

This episode gives space to the heartbreak, the anger, the pride, and the strange comfort that comes from looking back at a moment that changed a city. If you lived through The Decision, this will feel like a time capsule. If you only know the headlines, this will show you why the moment still matters.

Written by Kevin Pearce.

Text The Show and you could hear your question on the next episode!

Aaron Rodgers was supposed to be the savior of the New York Jets. After years of searching for stability at quarterback, the franchise finally landed one of the greatest passers in NFL history. Then, on the night of September 11th, 2023, under the lights of MetLife Stadium, it all fell apart in just four plays.

In this episode of Sports Scar’d, host Kevin Pearce sits down with returning guest Avril Stephens, known to Jets fans online as “JetsGirl,” to unpack one of the most shocking and haunting nights in recent sports memory — the injury that changed everything. Together, they revisit the chaos of Rodgers’ debut, the emotion that swept through the stadium when he went down, and the fallout that followed for the team, its fans, and Rodgers himself.

From the soaring preseason hype to the crushing silence of that cart ride off the field, this conversation explores the emotional and psychological impact of a moment that symbolized more than just a torn Achilles. For Jets fans, it felt like déjà vu — another cruel chapter in a history defined by heartbreak. For football fans, it was a stark reminder of how quickly hope can vanish under the weight of expectation.

Avril shares her firsthand reaction as a lifelong Jets supporter who watched her dream season implode before it even began. Kevin examines how the injury reshaped the team’s locker room, Zach Wilson’s unexpected return to the spotlight, and the national media storm that followed. The two also discuss Rodgers’ controversial recovery journey, his public comments, and whether redemption is still possible in New York.

This episode blends storytelling, emotion, and analysis — reflecting on how fandom and trauma often intertwine in sports. It’s a conversation about belief, disappointment, and the unshakable loyalty that keeps fans coming back no matter how much it hurts.

Whether you’re a Jets diehard, an NFL historian, or just someone fascinated by sports moments that leave scars, this interview captures the heartbreak, the hope, and the human side of one of football’s most unforgettable nights.

Written and produced by Kevin Pearce
Guest: Avril Stephens
Series: Sports Scar’d – The Stories That Still Sting
Episode Theme: The Aaron Rodgers Jets Saga
Game: Buffalo Bills at New York Jets – September 11th, 2023