🔍 The Search — Episode 22: The Disappearance of Jennifer Fay

In Episode 22 of The Search, hosts Marc Lewis and Al Gaetano examine the haunting disappearance of Jennifer Fay, a Massachusetts teenager who vanished after leaving her home and was never seen again.

What began as a normal night quickly turned into a decades-long mystery. With limited physical evidence, conflicting accounts, and long stretches of silence from key figures, Jennifer’s case remains unsolved — and deeply unsettling.

Marc and Al walk through the known timeline, explore the most credible theories, and break down where the investigation may have fallen short. This episode focuses not on sensationalism, but on facts, unanswered questions, and the human cost of a disappearance that still echoes years later.

If you’re drawn to unresolved cases, missing persons investigations, and stories that demand closer attention, this is one you won’t forget.

🎙️ Hosted by: Marc Lewis & Al Gaetano
🎧 Produced by: Torro Media
📺 Subscribe for more episodes of The Search
📩 If you have information related to this case, please reach out

Who Killed Karina Holmer? | The Search Podcast Ep. 21

In the early morning hours of June 23, 1996, Karina Holmer, a 20-year-old Swedish au pair living in Massachusetts, disappeared after a night out in downtown Boston.

She was last reliably seen in Boston’s Theatre District near Tremont Street and Boylston Place shortly after midnight. Witnesses reported that she appeared intoxicated but not incapacitated. After separating from her friends, Karina left the area alone—and never made it home.

Later that afternoon, a homeless man searching a dumpster near the Fenway / Back Bay area made a horrific discovery: a trash bag containing the upper half of a woman’s body. Police soon confirmed the remains belonged to Karina Holmer. Her lower half has never been found.

In Episode 21 of The Search Podcast, hosts Marc Lewis and Al Gaetano examine one of Boston’s most disturbing and enduring cold cases. From Karina’s background as a Swedish au pair to the chilling autopsy findings, we break down the timeline, the investigation, and the unanswered questions that continue to haunt this case nearly three decades later.

Investigators believe the murder occurred indoors and that Karina was likely strangled before her body was dismembered. Despite early leads and ongoing reminders from Boston Police, the case remains unsolved.

Produced by Torro Media

Nearly 30 years later, the question remains: Who killed Karina Holmer?

In May 2001, 24-year-old federal intern Chandra Levy vanished from Washington, D.C. What began as a missing persons case quickly became a national obsession—entangling politics, media hysteria, and one of the most infamous scandals of the early 2000s.

In Episode 20 of The Search, hosts Marc Lewis and Al Gaetano break down the full timeline of Chandra Levy’s disappearance, the investigation into Rock Creek Park, and the powerful figures pulled into the spotlight as the case unfolded. From the public fixation on Congressman Gary Condit to the later arrest and conviction of Ingmar Guandique, this episode explores what investigators know—and what still doesn’t add up more than two decades later.

Was justice truly served? Or does the murder of Chandra Levy remain an unresolved mystery beneath the surface?

🎧 Listen now as The Search dives deep into one of America’s most haunting true crime cases.