This Seemed Like A Good Idea Podcast cover art

This Seemed Like A Good Idea Podcast

This Seemed Like A Good Idea Podcast

Written by: This Seemed Like A Good Idea Podcast
Listen for free

About this listen

Not Sure YetThis Seemed Like A Good Idea Podcast Social Sciences
Episodes
  • Episode 5 - The Dark Episode
    Feb 3 2026

    Nick and Scott have returned with Episode 5!

    It's just us for this episode after the last 2 episodes had fantastic guests, that we're still talking about.

    This one has some darkness to it, with the stories we tell, but we love that shit.

    In this episode Scott presents Nick with a couple of "instant challenges", that turn out remarkably well and hysterical.

    We also did a "Karma Got That Bitch!" segment with a couple of "Karen" stories, where Karma got those crazy bitches.

    We play a game called "Real or Bullshit", where Nick has to pick the fake story out of 3 of them.

    We get back to our infamous "What in the Fucking Fuck!?" segment about an illness called POIS, where people are allergic to orgasms. WHAT IN THE FUCKING FUCK!?

    There are some audio pauses in the episode that were left on purpose due to the visual being so good. I (Scott) should have narrated during those times, but was laughing myself. There was no technical issue, just Scott staring in awe of Nick. LOL

    To close out the episode, Nick mentions a challenge to be proposed to Scott for the next one, that will happen on the spot.

    We'd love to hear your comments about this episode.


    Cheers!

    Nick & Scott




    Show More Show Less
    54 mins
  • Episode 4 - Stud Muffin Supreme - Aaron Hartman
    Jan 13 2026

    Welcome to episode 4.

    We have a couple of treats for you in this episode.

    First, and the appetizer (literally), we start out with our food pairing challenge from our previous episode, where Nick had to eat a hotdog with chocolate syrup and Scott had to eat a banana with ketchup (3 different ketchup's to be specific).

    We then talk about our next challenge for Episode 5.

    Finally, we get onto the main course - Aaron Hartman: AKA: Stud Muffin Supreme, who joins us and we had a blast with him.

    Aaron has a huge following on both Instagram with over 27,000 followers, and TikTok with over 883,000 followers, plus a YouTube channel.

    Aaron has awesome content like his dancing videos, Tit-Tar videos, Ten Second Top Ten videos and so much more. Including one of Scott's favorites - The 2 pallet jacks scissoring with the South Park background audio.

    Aaron was also on America's Got Talent Season 19, and he talks about that experience in depth.

    In addition to all of these things, Aaron also has his own Podcast called "Now It's a Podcast", and has been on some others.

    The second we saw one of Aaron's videos, we knew we had to get him on!

    We are big fans of Aaron and everything he does, he fits perfectly into what we're doing on this podcast, and we hope you enjoy the episode.


    We thank Aaron for joining us and spending so much time with us. He's a great guy and is extremely entertaining.


    P.S. Check out Nick's hat.


    We'd love to hear your feedback.


    - Nick and Scott


    https://www.instagram.com/the_studmuffin_supreme/?hl=en

    https://www.tiktok.com/@studmuffinsupreme

    https://www.youtube.com/@TheStudMuffinSupreme

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dDHW-WEjjFE

    https://www.instagram.com/p/DQuyAG8kjNq/?hl=en




    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 31 mins
  • Episode 3: The One With Nicole Csabai
    Dec 30 2025

    In this week's episode, Nick and Scott develop their challenge plans for episode 3, and Scott reveals video of his challenge that was issued to him from week 2.


    For the interview portion of the episode, we were joined by Nicole Csabai, who is a former senior VP of revenue and worked for Interscope Records and Big Machine.


    During our chat, Nicole tells us some in depth information about the inner workings of the music industry.


    We also discover that Scott has never heard of K-Pop? Listen in to see what he ACTUALLY thought it was.


    We'd love to hear your feedback and comments, drop them in the comments section!

    Show More Show Less
    2 hrs and 6 mins
No reviews yet