Johnny Frank Garrett was executed for the murder of a Catholic nun in Texas, but decades later, serious doubts continue to surround his conviction. Confessions later recanted, allegations of abuse, missing evidence, and posthumous appeals have turned this case into one of America’s most controversial executions. In this episode, we examine what happened, what may have gone wrong, and why many believe justice was never truly served.

Johnny Frank Garrett was executed for the murder of a Catholic nun in Texas, but decades later, serious doubts continue to surround his conviction. Confessions later recanted, allegations of abuse, missing evidence, and posthumous appeals have turned this case into one of America’s most controversial executions. In this episode, we examine what happened, what may have gone wrong, and why many believe justice was never truly served.

Elisa Lam’s death inside the Cecil Hotel water tank became one of the internet’s most dissected mysteries, spawning countless theories, viral videos, and supernatural claims. But as online speculation grew louder, important facts were often distorted, exaggerated, or ignored altogether. In this episode, we examine what the internet narrative missed, what the evidence actually shows, and how digital obsession reshaped a real human tragedy.

Lauren Thompson vanished after a night out, leaving behind fragments of a timeline but no clear explanation of what happened next. Sightings conflicted, witnesses remembered things differently, and critical moments slipped through the cracks.

In this episode, we examine Lauren’s final known movements, the gaps that defined the investigation, and how uncertainty rather than evidence became the most enduring feature of her case.

In July 1988, Keith Reinhard left his small Michigan town for a quiet drive and told friends he was going to take a walk. He was never seen again. His car was found abandoned, his personal items left behind, and the surrounding forest yielded no answers.

In this episode, we examine Keith’s final hours, the search that followed, and the unsettling reality of a disappearance with no witnesses, no evidence, and no clear motive only a vast wilderness and a question that still lingers decades later.

In October 2005, high school teacher and beauty queen Tara Grinstead disappeared from her small hometown of Ocilla, Georgia. Her car was parked outside her home, her belongings were undisturbed and there were no signs of a struggle.

For more than a decade, the case became one of the most haunting unsolved disappearances in the United States. In this episode, we walk through the night Tara vanished, the silence that followed, and how long-buried secrets eventually surfaced raising difficult questions about justice, memory, and how well we truly know the people around us.

In March 1977, Charles Morgan Jr. was found dead in the Arizona desert shot once in the back of the head, his death ruled a suicide. But that ruling only deepened the mystery.

Days earlier, Morgan claimed he had been abducted, tortured, and warned not to speak. He told friends and family that if he turned up dead, it wouldn’t be by his own hand. In this episode, we re-examine the strange events leading up to Morgan’s death and the theories that continue to unsettle investigators and internet sleuths alike.

In February 2013, 25-year-old Tiffany Daniels left her Pensacola apartment and vanished without a trace. Her car was later found abandoned near a boat ramp, her belongings still inside yet Tiffany was gone.

In this revisited episode, we re-examine Tiffany’s final movements, her connection to military intelligence work, and the theories that continue to circulate online. Was this a tragic accident, a targeted disappearance, or something still hidden beneath the surface?