In this season finale, we reflect on documented animal welfare cases from 2025 where shelters were called in after harm had already occurred.

Although this podcast only began in the final months of the year, the same patterns kept appearing: large-scale cruelty, neglect, hoarding, and shelters absorbing the fallout when systems failed upstream.

All cases discussed are real, publicly reported, and searchable. Sources and expanded reflections are linked in the companion blog.

The podcast will return in January 2026.

Content Note

This episode discusses animal neglect, cruelty, hoarding, and death. Listener discretion advised.

Cases Referenced (2025)

• Grass Valley, California: Over 200 animals rescued following a welfare complaint. Nevada County Animal Shelter and Animal Control coordinated emergency care. • Canandaigua, New York: Seventeen animals rescued and taken to Ontario County Humane Society after severe neglect was discovered. • Annandale, New Jersey: Forty-five animals seized from a home connected to a local rescue organization and placed into shelter care. • Elkhart County, Indiana: Elkhart Humane Society reported capacity strain following hoarding cases. • New Castle County, Delaware: Nearly 100 animals seized from a rescue operator’s residence and distributed among shelters.

Companion blog with sources and expanded case notes: [LINK TO BLOG]

Questions, thoughts, or stories you want to share: theunclaimedstories@gmail.com

Looking Ahead

Thank you for listening and bearing witness. Unclaimed returns January 2026.

Today’s episode pulls back the curtain on a part of sheltering that deserves way more conversation: what really happens once an adopted pet goes home. We break down the 3-3-3 Rule, talk through common post-adoption behaviors, explain why decompression matters, and share practical tools that help animals settle into their new lives safely and successfully.

If you’ve ever adopted from a shelter (or plan to), this episode is your roadmap for the adjustment period that follows.

The 3-3-3 Rule at a Glance

Three Days | Survival Confusion, overwhelm, hiding, pacing, reduced appetite, and GI upset are normal. Their system is trying to stabilize.

Three Weeks | Learning Confidence grows. Pets explore, test boundaries, and start understanding routines. True energy levels show.

Three Months | Connection Trust is established. Pets feel secure, training sticks, and their real personality becomes clear.

This rule isn’t rigid, but it’s one of the most helpful guides for understanding the typical emotional timeline of settling into a new home.

Have questions about adoption, decompression, or behavior? Want support with a newly adopted shelter pet? You can always reach out.

📧 Email: theunclaimedstories@gmail.com

Follow the podcast for more behind-the-scenes shelter education, animal-welfare insights, and real stories from inside the mind of an animal shelter worker.

In this episode, I break down one of the most common misunderstandings in animal welfare: the cats that live outside. Not every outdoor cat is lost. Not every outdoor cat wants to be rescued. And some of them? They are basically raccoons in cat suits, living their best cryptid life behind the grocery store.

This episode covers everything the public needs to know about outdoor cats, feral cats, TNR, ear-tipping, and when you should (or should NOT) intervene.

If you’ve ever wondered, “Is that cat okay?” — this is the episode for you.

Interested in supporting TNR or helping outdoor cats in your area? Contact your local shelter or rescue to ask about:

• Low-cost spay/neuter
• TNR programs
• Colony caretaking
• Volunteer trapping days
• Donations that directly help community cats

Got a porch panther? A spooky alley goblin? A neighborhood cryptid who watches you take out the trash?

Send me your stories! They might be featured in a future episode.

theunclaimedstories@gmail.com

This episode dives into one of the hardest truths in animal welfare: sometimes saving a dog means ending their suffering. After seeing a TikTok about euthanasia lists, I unpack what the public gets wrong about “just try harder,” and why shelter workers and trainers often see behaviors the average adopter can’t safely handle.

Featuring the story of Badger — a feral dog who spent six months learning to trust, only to be overwhelmed by fear again — this episode breaks down the ethics, the grief, and the weight behind making the most impossible decision: choosing peace over prolonged suffering.

⚠️ Content Warning: This episode includes discussion of euthanasia, behavior-related risk, and difficult shelter experiences. Please listen with care.

If this episode moves you, consider supporting your local shelter through adoption, fostering, volunteering, or donations. It makes a difference.

Link to Scoob & I: Watch on TikTok (Note: You’ll need TikTok access to view it.)

Content Warning: This episode includes descriptions of animal cruelty involving newborn puppies.

In this episode of Unclaimed, I share the raw and emotional story of eleven newborn puppies found tied inside a garbage bag and thrown into a commercial dumpster. What follows is told through three intertwined perspectives: the sanitation worker who discovered them, the firefighter who fought to keep them alive, and the foster who stayed awake for days to give them a chance.

This episode shines a light on the true cost of animal dumping, the burnout shelter workers quietly live with, and the everyday heroes who step up when the smallest lives need them most.

If this episode moves you, consider helping your local shelter:

• Foster a litter

• Volunteer for a shift

• Donate formula, blankets, or supplies

• Share adoptable animals

• Support the workers who show up every single day

Contact: Have a story for Unclaimed? Email: the unclaimedstories@gmail.com