In this episode of V-FM Pensions, hosts Nico and Darren welcome their first-ever podcast guest back to the show: David Butcher.

They catch up with David to hear how his mindfulness coaching through Positively Aware is going and to get his thoughts on V-FM, trusteeship, and the insight he has gained from recent trustee experiences.

David also shares a brilliant story about gatecrashing a festival… a moment that somehow didn’t make it into his first appearance (and, honestly, the real reason we invited him back...).

And to round things off, David leads listeners through a short meditation at the end of the episode.

In this episode of V-FM Pensions, Darren and Nico chat through their thoughts on the FCA and TPR's latest consultation on value for money (CP 26/1).

In a must listen episode for anyone developing their response to the consultation, the duo's personal thoughts (not those of their employers...) include:

1. This isn’t Value for Money it’s a performance regime: The consultation has morphed into a capital-performance test with a costs add-on. Most of the “value” bits (service, engagement, member outcomes) have been kicked into the long grass.
2. It risks sabotaging the retirement-income agenda: Government wants schemes to deliver better retirement outcomes, but the VFM framework measures success like everyone’s just cashing out. That’s a recipe for schemes doing the wrong thing in the run-up to retirement.
3. The penalties are so harsh they’ll force providers to copy each other: Nobody is going to take investment risk, innovate, or deviate from the herd. The safest strategy becomes: hug the benchmark
4. Mansion House and VFM are pulling in opposite directions: Policy says: invest in private markets and the UK economy. VFM says: don’t you dare underperform your peers. Put those together and you get one outcome: providers won’t touch the assets government wants them to buy.
5. Costs and charges are still a mess, just with nicer spreadsheets: The consultation tries to build credibility through multiple “net” performance numbers, but exemptions, hidden costs, and inconsistent definitions mean the figures still won’t add up in the real world.
6. The whole thing dodges the real problem... people aren’t saving enough: VFM is starting to look like the policy equivalent of jangling keys in front of a baby, distracting everyone from the uncomfortable truth that adequacy and contributions matter more than almost anything in the framework.

In this episode of V-FM Pensions hosts Darren and Nico chat to Pan Trustees' Nicholas Chadha to explore what value for money means in modern trusteeship.

Nick reflects on his journey from actuarial adviser to professional trustee, and shares insight into schemes at very different ends of the spectrum, from those entering the PPF with recovery plans acting as a drag on sponsors, to schemes managing surplus and difficult decisions around how it should be shared between members and employers.

We discuss the ins and outs of the innovative Aberdeen Stagecoach deal as part of a wider conversation about future options for DB schemes. We also chat about barriers for schemes moving to superfunds and conflicts of interest within professional trustee firms.

Nick makes the case that true value for money isn’t about defaulting to industry orthodoxy... it’s about spending wisely, challenging assumptions, and ultimately improving outcomes for members.

In this episode of VFM Pensions, hosts Nico and Darren are joined by Claire Altman, who leads Standard Life’s work across pensions risk transfer and individual retirement solutions. Claire shares her brilliantly unconventional journey into pensions, from lawyer to trustee to commercial innovator.

We explore what it really means to deliver value for money in retirement, why emotional certainty often matters as much as mathematical optimisation, and how a growing web of regulation is shaping the future of both DB endgames and DC pension outcomes.

In this episode of VFM Pensions, Nico and Darren are joined by "Red" Rory Murphy, trustee chair, board adviser, pensions commentator and lifelong trade unionist.

Rory brings a refreshingly different perspective to the pensions debate, shaped by decades in the trade union movement and hands-on experience of running smaller schemes.

In a typically wide-ranging conversation we touch on the role of trustees and why they are too cautious when it comes to delivering better outcomes for members. We look at the role of trusteeship in a world dominated by master trusts and professional trustees, the importance of the member voice, and whether fiduciary duty has been interpreted far too narrowly, acting as a barrier to innovation.

At its heart, this episode asks a simple (but maybe) uncomfortable question: who is the pensions system really for and what would it take for trustees to be braver in acting for members?

In this episode of V-FM Pensions, hosts Nico and Darren chat to Kim Gubler. Kim wears many hats in the pensions industry, among them Managing Director of KGC Associates, President of PASA, and is an independent trustee Director of the Smart Pension mastertrust.

Another wide ranging conversation that, as well as talking about horses and pigeons (only on the V-FM podcast....), focuses on the importance of elevating administration to the same level as investments when it comes to assessing value for money, treating it as central to member outcomes rather than something that happens in the background.

We talk about the evolution of KGC, PASA, and problems in relying on SLAs to assess value for money. We also chat about Kim's work on small pots and the recent feasibility study looking at quick ways of addressing what is an increasingly pressing issue.

In this episode of V-FM Pensions, hosts Darren and Nico chat to SuperRatings' Kirby Rappell.

SuperRatings has been conducting value for money assessments in Australia for 17 years, starting out as the first firm dedicated to super fund research.

We hear from Kirby about how the Aussie's do V-FM and look at learnings and insights that could benefit UK thinking.

And we discuss the Pound for Pound initiative that SuperRatings has been leading with a number of large UK schemes.

In this episode of V-FM Pensions, hosts Darren and Nico chat to Willis Towers Watson's Simon Eagle. Simon has been instrumental in the development of CDC in the UK, being the scheme actuary for the Royal Mail CDC scheme.

We chatted through the evolution of CDC in the UK, the original ideas behind defined ambition, the introduction of the Royal Mail scheme, and what next for CDC, including retirement-only CDC. We also discussed the challenges of introducing retirement-only CDC and how some of these challenges can be addressed in the context of how people turn their pension pot into a retirement income.

We found out how Simon got into pensions and, of course, what value for money means to him.