Weirder After Dark cover art

Weirder After Dark

Weirder After Dark

Written by: WeirderAfterDark
Listen for free

About this listen

Think you know New England? Think again. Join three cousins—Sean, Cathy, and Chris—as they uncover the region’s darkest, weirdest secrets. From haunted mansions and ancient artifacts to cryptids, cults, and murderous mysteries, Weirder After Dark is where humor meets history, and the eerie meets the unexplained. It’s New England like you’ve never imagined.WeirderAfterDark True Crime
Episodes
  • 64. The Oracle of Lynn: The Prophecies of Molly Pitcher
    Feb 17 2026

    Molly Pitcher was known as a psychic, a seer, and an oracle. So well known that George Washington and other revolutionary leaders regularly sought her guidance while drafting their war plans. Cool, right? But when you look up Molly Pitcher, this isn't the story you'll find in the history books. In fact, you'll find a completely different heroic story...

    Tonight, we unravel the documented accounts, the folklore, and the cultural panic surrounding the woman they called The Oracle of Lynn, and explore a provocative question: could this mysterious fortune-teller be the real woman behind the “Molly Pitcher” many of us learned about in history books?

    Was history rewritten to drive a particular narrative? Were our founding fathers ashamed of their psychic and spiritual guidance? Are these two completely different stories of the heroic Molly Pitcher referncing the same person? We'll explore all these questions tonight!


    ---> We Finally Have Merch<---

    Check out our Weirder After Dark Candle Collection here!

    Or go to Ghost Poppy.com to check it out!


    Contact Us:

    TheGang@weriderafterdark.com

    Reddit | Facebook | Instagram @WeirderAfterDark


    Show More Show Less
    26 mins
  • 63. Wallace Tillinghast's Mystery Machine
    Feb 10 2026

    In the early 1900s, a wealthy Boston inventor named Wallace Tillinghast made an unbelievable claim: he had built and successfully flown a secret airplane over New England! However, this was years before most people thought it was even possible. Then, just as suddenly, he vanished from the aviation world and moved, never commenting again on his flying machine.

    So what really happened to Wallace Tillinghast?
    Was his “Mystery Machine” an elaborate hoax fueled by early aviation mania or was he silenced, pressured, or erased to keep something far bigger out of the public eye? Join us as we dig in to decide if this is a hoax or a cover-up!


    Do you like candles? We offically have our first merch/collab with GhostPoppy! Check out the Weirder After Dark Collection here. Or by visiting GhostPoppy.com.


    Want to Contact Us?

    Socials: Instagram | Reddit | Facebook @WeirderAfterDark

    Email: Thegang@WeirderAfterDark.com


    Show More Show Less
    29 mins
  • 62. New Hampshire's Tilton Inn: Built to Burn
    Feb 3 2026

    On busy Main Street in Tilton, New Hampshire, thousands of cars pass a stately Victorian building every day without realizing how many times it’s been nearly erased. The Tilton Inn has welcomed travelers for more than a century, but its history is marked by repeated fires and tragic deaths.

    In this episode, we dig into the building's history and the alleged hauntings that won't seem to stop. From shadow figures, disembodied voices, to toys moving across the room on their own. This inn earns a 5-star rating for the amount of activity it experiences!


    Like Candles? We've officially announced our Weirder After Dark Collection in collaboration with Ghost Poppy! Sales start on 2/10! So if you've been digging the pod, it would mean the world to have your support!


    Visit Ghost Poppy's website here!

    Show More Show Less
    37 mins
No reviews yet