• S3 E4 - Greg Fleniken, Crazy Coincidences & Pricing, Olympics
    Feb 12 2026

    Today's episode is all about many different kinds of coincidences including the wild case of Greg Fleniken.

    In the Bitching Hour we go on about today's pricing and the events that took place at the Winter olympics.

    Tell us your thoughts;

    WhatReallyHappenedPodcast@gmailcom / 845.663.3154

    Show More Show Less
    50 mins
  • S3 E3 - Laura Buxton, Alaskan Bigfoot & Groundhog Day
    Feb 5 2026

    Are coincidences really that rare, like in Laura Buxton (x2) case?

    Did this small town in Alaska disappear because of a Bigfoot-like creature?

    In The Bitching Hour we talk about the strangeness of Groundhog Day in the US.

    What are your thoughts?

    WhatReallyHappenedPodcast@gmail.com / 845.663.3154

    Show More Show Less
    51 mins
  • S3 E2 - Stranger Things, Jose Velasquez & Spam Calls
    Jan 29 2026

    What real life events influenced the creation of popular TV series 'Stranger Things'?

    Was Jose Velasquez actually a serial killer?

    What do you want to bitch about?

    WhatReallyHappenedPodcast@gmail.com / 845.663.3154

    Show More Show Less
    32 mins
  • Season 3 Premiere!
    Jan 22 2026

    We're back for season 3!

    Morgan jumps on the 2016 trend and Mike starts his new series connecting real life cases to TV/movies.

    The Bitching Hour is back as well! Today we bitch about popular trends and electronic shopping cart.

    What do you want to hear this season?

    WhatReallyHappenedPodcast@gmail.com / 845.663.3154

    Show More Show Less
    43 mins
  • S2 E35 - Season 2 Finale!
    Dec 18 2025

    The last episode of Season 2 includes the disappearance of Theresa Fusco and a messy Christmas Eve murder in the UK.

    In The Bitching Hour we yap about Christmas traditions.

    Happy Holidays!

    WhatReallyHappenedPodcast@gmail.com / 845.663.3154

    Show More Show Less
    39 mins
  • 3 Murders in Colorado Rockies & Christmas Thought
    Dec 4 2025

    Both of our stories take place in the Colorado Rockies! One a very long cold case and the other a very complicated, intertwined mess.

    I this episode we bitch about buying Christmas gifts and what kind of car you drive in the snow.

    What do you think?

    WhatReallyHappened@gmail.com / 845.663.3154

    Show More Show Less
    52 mins
  • S2 - E33 Appalachian Trail Killer, John Woodruff & Thanksgiving Topics
    Nov 27 2025

    A story with lots of twists and turns from the VA section of the Appalachian Trail.

    The still mysterious story of John Woodruff's disappearance.

    In The Bitching Hour we talk about acceptable Thanksgiving topics and food!

    Happy Thanksgiving!

    WhatReallyHappenedPodcast@gmail.com / 845.663.3154

    Show More Show Less
    45 mins
  • S2 E32 - Cannibal Cop, Zizians & World Destruction
    Nov 20 2025

    An NYPD cop wants to eat 'girl meat' for Thanksgiving dinner.

    Who are the Zizians?

    In the Bitching Hour we talk about the hours of jobs and services.

    Tell us your opinions:

    WhatReallyHappenedPodcast@gmail.com / 845.663.3154

    Show More Show Less
    49 mins