Episodes

  • FLASHBACK EPISODE: Chainsaw Murders

    FLASHBACK EPISODE: Chainsaw Murders
    Apr 18 2025
    In Season 3 Episode 40 the girls talk about Chainsaw Murders – happens more than you’d think. Gemma starts you off with the gruesome murderer Jonathan Stasiuk before Holly tells you all about the sad story of Teri Lea Zenner and her brutal murder.

    Shoutouts for the fabulous band @Battalionofflies who are dropping their EP TODAY so go check them out, Dave who recommended us (including a minor dig at the Canadian co-host – watching you Dave, watching you) and Super Fan Natalie whose children have traumatized Holly with the passing of time. HI KIDS.

    Holly forgets how to podcast for the 194th time in a row, Gemma’s murderer had no regretsies, there are some amazing sound effects in the roundup and once again cookies are being eaten by someone who shall remain unnamed.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who once again has had his glory thwarted by the girls. NO GLORY FOR YOU PC.

    Gemma edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who has been listening to Glory Days by The Boss for days now with tears in his little eyes. 0

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.


    Pre-recorded in Scotland
    Show More Show Less
    24 mins
  • FLASHBACK EPISODE: Ax Murderers

    FLASHBACK EPISODE: Ax Murderers
    Apr 11 2025
    In Season 3 Episode 38 the girls talk about Ax Murders – can you believe it’s taken 3 seasons to get here? – with Gemma kicking it off by telling us the tale of the Ax Man of New Orleans and Holly then going on to chat us through the South African murderer Henri Van Breda.

    Shoutout for Superfan Mel who is having a very busy apocalypse.

    A translator is brought in for Holly’s case but she totally ignores it and changes the first name pronunciation repeatedly throughout the story….as per usual, the girls share a brain when it comes to New Orleans, Gemma doesn’t understand Jumaji, Holly delays the start of segment two due to cookie crumbs and congratulations are given. To themselves. Well deserved.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who has given up on timers because nobody looks at them and why does he bother and like, do they even know how to tell time or have any idea what a timeframe is OMG.

    Gemma edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who is now suffering PTSD symptoms from ticking clocks.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.


    Pre-recorded in Scotland
    Show More Show Less
    34 mins
  • FLASHBACK EPISODE: Victims Who Solved their own Murders

    FLASHBACK EPISODE: Victims Who Solved their own Murders
    Apr 3 2025
    In Season 3 Episode 11 – Solved Their Own Murders – Holly tells the story of Grace May Brown who helped convict her killer after her death before Gemma goes on to tell the sad story of Simon Ng who blogged his murderer into a conviction.


    Shoutout to Natalie in Canada – thanks for recommending us! And thoughts go out to Holly’s Mom who is going through a hard time.


    In this episode we learn that Producer Craig has planted clues already to solve his own murder via Alexa, the girls figure out a numbering system that has been in place for three seasons (math is still just so hard), boat luggage choices get weird and internet time travel reveals some antique options for talking to the world.


    Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who refused to add a note to his secret evidence for Holly in case Gemma kills them both. So he’s definitely on Holly’s murder list now.


    Gemma mostly edited this week. All complaints should be sent to Producer Craig who is very selfish with his evidence storage.

    www.whichmurderer.com


    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.


    Pre-recorded in Scotland
    Show More Show Less
    29 mins
  • FLASHBACK EPISODE: Paranormal Murders

    FLASHBACK EPISODE: Paranormal Murders
    Feb 27 2025
    Which Murderer Flashback Episode!

    In Which Murderer’s 36th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Paranormal Murders. Mel starts us off with a story about the Hammersmith Ghost, before Holly terrifies you with the Greenbrier Ghost story.

    Emma Jo suggested this week's episode - thanks so much! It was a blast to research.

    In this week’s episode you find out that Holly quote, ‘loves paranormal shit!’, Jesus is claimed, there are some excellent TV recommendations, you are advised not to wear white and Holly wants to name your babies please.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who has asked Consulting Producer Craig to wear a white sheet to all future podcast recordings.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig puts a white sheet on the closest stranger and makes a run for it.

    Big thank you to all our listeners for subscribing, leaving fantastic reviews and sending in great theme suggestions.

    WE HAVE MERCH! www.whichmurderer.com - CLICK ON THE MERCHANDISE TAB FOR A LINK!

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland
    Show More Show Less
    26 mins
  • FLASHBACK EPISODE: Children that Murder

    FLASHBACK EPISODE: Children that Murder
    Feb 21 2025
    Which Murderer Flashback Episode!

    In Which Murderer’s Episode 41 Season 5 the girls cover chilling cases of Children Who Murder. Holly starts us off with the shocking case of Alyssa Bustamonte before Mel goes into the unbelievable murder by Amarjeet Sada.

    Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Blink twice if you are in danger.

    In this episode you will go around the world with a tour of German foods (that actually aren’t German) and apologies to India…again. Mel gets pretty mad at numbers, you will get education you didn’t ask for…or possibly want…on the Seven Wonders of the World and there is a big Charles Bronson debrief.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who is currently speaking to Consulting Producer Craig in broken German about editing all the episodes for the rest of his life.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig hires a translator to make his wishes extra clear to Holly.

    Big thank you to all our listeners for subscribing, leaving fantastic reviews and sending in great theme suggestions.

    WE HAVE MERCH! www.whichmurderer.com - CLICK ON THE MERCHANDISE TAB FOR A LINK!

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland
    Show More Show Less
    37 mins
  • FLASHBACK EPISODE: Murders Solved by Psychics

    FLASHBACK EPISODE: Murders Solved by Psychics
    Feb 14 2025
    Which Murderer Flashback Episode!

    In Season 4 Episode 36 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Murders Solved by Psychics. What a great idea! Mel kicks it off with the sad story of Melanie Uribe before Holly tells you about a lovely man named Andre Daigle.

    Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Keep them coming…..you guys are doing a fantastic job.

    Mel is on the running bandwagon while Holly remains on a health not-kick, we learn that Holly skates like a sailboat, Mel tells us about her love for the Olympics and Italy - but that she is not likely to honeymoon there due to the Mafia, the girls decide all carpenters are nice people and Holly reveals yet more childhood trauma.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who is trying hard to psychically connect to Consulting Producer Craig and get him to take over editing again.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig tries to figure out why he’s suddenly craving maple syrup and has an itch inside his brain.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland
    Show More Show Less
    42 mins
  • FLASHBACK EPISODE: Murderers Haunted by Ghosts

    FLASHBACK EPISODE: Murderers Haunted by Ghosts
    Feb 7 2025
    Which Murderer Flashback Episode!

    In Season 3 Episode 44 the girls talk about Murderers Haunted by Victim’s Ghosts. Gemma starts you off with the case of Adrian Daou before Holly goes over Jose Ferreira’s story.

    Shoutout for Scott who is smitten with Producer Craig apparently. The girls are trying not to let Craig hear his praise or he will take over and kick them out of the team.

    The girls are engrossing you all with endless stories of Wotsits, Holly weighs in on Gemma’s case and comes down on Canada, both girls struggle with names because they know you like consistency in your life and there are some rather unexpected flashbacks from Gemma.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who is currently lacing up his giant kicking out boots while waiting for listener Scott to show up as backup.

    Gemma edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who is not about to be tied up and placed in the ‘hole’ Gemma has been building under the Kitchen. Nope.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.


    Pre-recorded in Scotland
    Show More Show Less
    28 mins
  • FLASHBACK EPISODE: Decapitation Murders

    FLASHBACK EPISODE: Decapitation Murders
    Jan 28 2025
    Which Murderer Flashback Episode!

    In Episode 26 Season 2, Gemma and Holly talk about murderers who lost their heads!....while decapitating people. Gemma covers the murderer Mathew Borges who took 'troubled teens' a step or ten too far and Holly speaks about the Kingsbury Run murders from the 1930s.

    The girls plug Gemma's guest appearance on the podcast 'Good Nurse Bad Nurse', Holly has another Reddit breakdown, the girls guess a movie correctly for the first time in history (wink wink Kevin Costner) and Holly give age specific murder advice.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who somehow found himself committed to a remote weekend away with the crew for a recording session in the wilds of Scotland next year. His eyes are glazed over with joy.

    Gemma mostly edited this week. All complaints should be sent to Producer Craig who is currently googling how to survive in the wilderness while recording a podcast.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Recorded in a secret location somewhere in Scotland
    Show More Show Less
    31 mins