Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
Is AI the Real Thief? Signatures, Bullets, and the Trust Nobody Reported Stolen cover art

Is AI the Real Thief? Signatures, Bullets, and the Trust Nobody Reported Stolen

Is AI the Real Thief? Signatures, Bullets, and the Trust Nobody Reported Stolen

Listen for free

View show details
About this listen
IntroductionWhen a thief uses a crowbar to break into a house, do we arrest the crowbar?It sounds like a silly question. Of course we don't. We arrest the thief. The crowbar goes into an evidence bag and, presumably, into a very dull retirement. And yet, when it comes to artificial intelligence, a great many of us are standing in the street shouting at the crowbar."AI is stealing our jobs!" "AI is stealing our art!" "AI is stealing our words!" And some of that is true, or partly true, and we'll get to it. But I've been noticing something. When an illustrator who has spent fifteen years mastering her craft uses AI to speed up her work, nobody accuses her of theft. She's still the illustrator. She just has a faster brush. The same goes for the composer, the programmer, the teacher, the translator who uses these tools to do more of what they already know how to do.So why do some uses feel like robbery and others don't? And if there really is a thief in this story, who is it? The machine? The companies that built it? The man who has never written a paragraph in his life and published sixty books last month on psychology, medieval cheese, and the private lives of the Victorians, none of which he has read? Or, and this is the one nobody likes, is it us?That's what this episode is about. We'll look at all the suspects, one by one, like a detective in an old novel gathering everyone in the library. We'll talk about bullets and bridges and used cars, and an old Latin word that I think holds the key to the whole case.Here's how we'll do it. First, a story: a composer, a blackout, six flights of stairs, and a room full of glowing phones. Then you and I will talk, laughing where we can, until we reach the part where laughing doesn't fit anymore. And at the end, I'll leave you with some questions.So let's go to Beirut. The generator is humming, and someone's phones are listening to music nobody wrote.The StoryNour Khalil found out where her royalties were going on a Sunday, over stuffed grape leaves, from her cousin's husband, who didn't know he was confessing."Music," Rabih was saying, waving a fork. "Music is the future, Nour. You of all people should know that. I've got a label now.""A label," Nour said."Forty-two artists." He grinned. "Well. Forty-two names. Lo-fi, ambient, sleep sounds, rain on a tin roof, that kind of thing. People love rain on a tin roof. Very relaxing. Streams all night."Nour was thirty-three. She had been composing since she was nine, when her grandmother put her in front of an old upright piano and she refused to get up for dinner. She had a degree from the conservatory and a master's from a university in Lyon that she was still, technically, paying for. She had released four albums of piano and string music, mostly on her own. Her most-streamed track had eighty-one thousand plays. Last month, from every streaming platform on earth combined, she had earned thirty-eight dollars and forty-one cents."Who composes it?" she asked.Rabih laughed and tapped his temple. "The machine. I just tell it what I want. 'Sad piano, rain, a bit of cello.' Two minutes, done. Then another one. And another one." He leaned over. "You should see my streams, Nour. Honestly. You should come see the setup."His wife, Nour's cousin Lina, was not laughing. She was looking at her plate.That night, at 11:20, Lina called."Can you come? Please. He's in the flat in Dekwaneh. He's been there since dinner. He's got the generator bill here on the table, nine hundred dollars, Nour. Nine hundred. For one month. He says it's for his servers." Her voice cracked. "I don't even know what he's doing. You understand music. Can you go talk to him?"Nour didn't really want to. But she knew Lina had been carrying the rent on her teacher's salary since Rabih lost his job at the bank in 2020, when the whole banking system froze and people's savings vanished behind glass doors that no longer opened. She knew Rabih had been one of the IT men who kept those very systems running. She knew he'd come home one day with a cardboard box and not spoken for a week.She took a taxi to Dekwaneh.The building was one of those half-finished concrete towers that had been waiting for its final coat of paint since before she was born. The power was out on the whole street. The only light came from the generator shops, their cables looping across the road like black vines, and from one window on the sixth floor, which was glowing a strange, flickering blue.The elevator was dead, of course. She climbed six flights of stairs by the light of her phone, her breath loud in the stairwell, a cat watching her from the fourth-floor landing with profound disapproval.The door to the flat was open a crack. She pushed it.For a moment, she simply stood there.The living room had been emptied of furniture. In its place, along every wall, stood metal shelving, the kind you'd find in a warehouse, and on every shelf, in neat rows, sat phones. Hundreds of them. Old phones, ...
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet