How much of your identity is actually yours to define?
Dr. Jonathan Adler has spent his career studying narrative identity: the evolving story we construct about who we are, where we came from, and who we might become.
His research suggests something both liberating and uncomfortable: we may be the narrator of our lives, but we are surrounded by co-narrators. Family, culture, relationships, institutions, and the people who know us all participate in holding our identities in place.
In this conversation, Jonathan and I explore what happens when the story you are living begins to change before the people around you are ready for the new version of you.
As Jonathan puts it, what feels like an evolution from the inside can feel like a revolution to everyone else.
We also talk about his research showing that changes in people’s stories can precede improvements in psychological well-being, how parents and culture teach us how a life story is supposed to unfold, the difference between telling an agentic story and actually having agency, and why cultural “master narratives” only begin to change when people are willing to tell alternative ones.
Jonathan also challenges the Narrative Intelligence inquiry itself. If Narrative Intelligence is going to become a meaningful construct, we have to determine what it is, what it overlaps with, what it is distinct from, and what it uniquely explains.
Jonathan is a professor of psychology at Olin College of Engineering, a researcher of narrative identity and psychological well-being, a playwright and theater director, and a collaborator with Health Story Collaborative.
His forthcoming book, Who We Might Become: Reimagining Our Life Stories and Our Understanding of Identity, explores what happens when we lose authority over the stories of our own lives.
CHAPTERS
00:00 — Welcome to 100 Stories
00:32 — Meet Jonathan Adler
01:11 — Why study narrative?
04:50 — How our stories become identity
06:16 — Can changing your story change your well-being?
09:15 — Family, culture, and the narrative ecology
11:02 — How parents teach us to tell our lives
12:51 — Story, illness, and identity
16:59 — When does an experience become part of your identity?
19:46 — Telling an agentic story vs. actually having agency
21:25 — Can behavior change before the story changes?
23:01 — What does it take to live a different story?
25:16 — Who gets authority over your identity?
27:55 — Your evolution may feel like a revolution
30:01 — What narrative identity can teach us about Narrative Intelligence
31:41 — Master narratives and the courage to resist them
35:36 — Can Narrative Intelligence be scientifically studied?
37:13 — Narrative identity vs. Narrative Intelligence
39:46 — What questions remain?
More about Jonathan Adler:
https://www.jonathanmadler.com/
More about Paige Williams:
https://paigewilliams.co/
StoryKeys:
https://storykeys.co/
The 100 Stories Project:
https://100storiesproject.com/