• Nearly Decapitated, Still Alive: The Colleen Bush Survival Story
    Nov 9 2026

    This episode recounts the 1981 abduction and brutal attack on Colleen Bush in New Mexico, during which her friend Julie Jackson was killed. Colleen miraculously survived severe injuries—stabbed 33 times and nearly decapitated—and fought her way back to seek help.

    The hosts discuss the crime, the investigation and conviction of Michael Guzman, the survivor's recovery, and broader themes of justice, prison policies, and the psychology behind violent offenders.

    Show More Show Less
    31 mins
  • The Vampire Doctor of Dillsboro: Mob Justice in 1789
    Nov 2 2026

    Hosts Amanda and Amber explore the chilling 18th-century tale of Dr. Outford in Dillsboro, North Carolina: unexplained deaths with puncture wounds, a terrified town, and a vigilante mob that found coffins in the doctors cellar. After discovering Mrs. Outford alive in a shroud, the townspeople hanged the couple and burned their home, ending the attacks.

    The episode also places the story in context with European vampire epidemics, corpse medicine, tuberculosis fears, and how superstition and limited medical knowledge fueled terrifying legends. The hosts close with Halloween memories and a lighthearted wrap-up.

    Show More Show Less
    24 mins
  • Mandy the Haunted Doll: Museum Terror from Across the Sea
    Oct 26 2026

    In this episode, hosts Amanda and Amber share eerie tales including Mandy, a century-old porcelain doll housed in a British Columbia museum that reportedly moves, causes strange occurrences, and is linked to tragic pasts. They also discuss the infamous Bell Witch haunting from the early 1800s, explore possible explanations, and tease future spooky topics and listener-submitted stories.

    Show More Show Less
    18 mins
  • Key West's Cursed Toy
    Oct 19 2026

    In this episode Amanda and Amber explore the eerie legend of Robert the Doll — a child-sized German-made toy owned by Eugene Otto that allegedly terrorized his family and later caused strange incidents at the Fort East Martello Museum in Key West. They recount the Otto family’s tragedies, reported hauntings through the decades, and the museum’s rules about greeting Robert and asking permission before photographing him.

    The hosts also read letters from visitors claiming misfortune after disrespecting the doll and discuss theories that Robert may be a conduit for darker forces. The episode mixes folklore, eyewitness accounts, and questions about belief and consequence.

    https://robertthedoll.org/

    Show More Show Less
    29 mins
  • Potato Projectiles & Phantom Dogs: A Haunted Norway to Cryptid Chaos
    Oct 12 2026

    Hosts Amber and Amanda dive into spooky tales and cryptid lore from a haunted grocery store in Norway and the eerie Oslo Castle to the legendary Bear Lake Monster and the New Jersey Gator Man.

    Along the way they share festival finds, personal anecdotes, merch updates, and creative projects—closing with their signature sign-off: stay lovely, stay spooky, stay weird.

    Show More Show Less
    22 mins
  • Rogues' Hollow: Crybaby Bridge, Headless Horse & the Ghost Train
    Oct 5 2026

    This episode explores the eerie legends of Rokes Hollow — from Crybaby Bridge and the headless horse to haunted mines, a ghost train, and a mill haunted by a man crushed by a water wheel.

    Hosts and guests also share personal spooky encounters in apartments, houses, and local woods, plus a discussion on whether these events are supernatural or psychological.

    Show More Show Less
    28 mins
  • Loveland Frogman, Beast of Busco & the Lizardman: Reptiles, Myths, and Madness
    Sep 28 2026

    Hosts Amanda and Amber dive into famous reptilian cryptids—Ohio's Loveland Frogman, Indiana's Beast of Busco, and South Carolina's Lizardman—mixing folklore, eyewitness accounts, and personal stories.

    They also share Patreon and merch news, and invite listeners to meet them at the Curiosities & Cryptids Festival in Tremont, Ohio on October 3, 2026.

    Show More Show Less
    28 mins
  • The Harassed Nurse: The Strange Case of Cindy James
    Sep 21 2026

    After years of threatening calls, violence and baffling attacks, nurse Cindy James vanished and was later found dead under mysterious circumstances. The case—marked by missing evidence, conflicting police theories and a long coroner's inquest—remains unsolved.

    This episode traces the harassment, the mounting trauma, and the unanswered questions about whether Cindy was a victim of a stalker, driven to self-harm, or the target of a killer.

    Show More Show Less
    35 mins