• If The Shoe Fits
    Oct 14 2026

    The man who coined this phrase had already been pilloried and imprisoned for writing satire people took literally. So the next time he went after Parliament, he built himself an escape hatch.


    On this episode of Appraise The Phrase, Mario and Twenty unveil the origin, confirm the meaning, and assess the value of “if the shoe fits.” It starts in 1705 with Daniel Defoe — printed in London under the pretense that it came from Danzig, credited to an author who didn't exist, because the poem was a direct attack on the English Parliament. Defoe names nobody in it. He just writes that if a member recognizes himself in the satire, that recognition is the reader's act, not the writer's accusation.


    Twenty's read: he invented the disclaimer.


    Then the phrase crosses the Atlantic. May 1773, the New York Gazette and Weekly Mercury, a city weeks from tearing itself apart over the Tea Act, in the one genre where anonymity did the most work. And somewhere in that crossing, the object changes.


    Also: the Cinderella theory and why it doesn't hold, the 1773 subtweet, what Google didn't bother correcting, and a Dictionary of Misinformation entry that will make you check your own vocabulary.


    0:00 Green Goblin, Family Matters, And A Late Submission
    1:03 The ATP Intro Theme
    1:42 What's Good: LA, Venice Beach, And Morning Walks
    7:02 Shout Out To Mo And The Event
    8:01 Today's Phrase: If The Shoe Fits
    10:25 Twenty: It Went From Positive To Negative
    13:07 Mario Wrote This Episode From A Negative Place
    14:27 Shout Out To Kayla And Kinara Books
    15:27 Nobody Says “Wear It” Anymore
    16:19 You Already Have The Shoe On
    16:59 Confirm The Meaning: Four Dictionaries This Time
    18:00 The Last-Minute Submission Always Wins
    21:33 Which Ones Are Negative And Which Are Neutral
    22:05 Twenty Picks Two Dictionaries — A First
    22:53 Unveil The Origin: 1705, Daniel Defoe
    23:12 The Green Goblin Problem
    24:41 Printed In London, Credited To A Man Who Didn't Exist
    26:09 Defoe Had Already Been Pilloried For Satire
    27:13 A Legal Deniability Device
    28:56 “He Invented The Disclaimer”
    29:38 Have You Ever Jumped In Front Of A Bullet Nobody Fired?
    31:27 You Gotta Show Me My ID In The Film
    35:14 Are You Slower To Anger Now?
    36:07 Why A Point Of No Return Is A Good Thing
    37:28 Crashing Out, And The Flu Game Meme
    38:43 May 1773: The Cap Becomes A Shoe
    40:23 The Defensive Character Genre
    41:26 Hugh Gaine, The Printer Who Stayed Neutral
    42:46 Influence Before Influencers
    43:00 The Tea Act And A City About To Break
    44:41 The Original Subtweet
    45:22 Twenty's Twitter Era
    50:25 The Cinderella Hypothesis
    52:00 Why The Case Against It Is Stronger
    54:50 Google Didn't Correct The Story Either
    56:33 Pop Culture Impact: The Top Four
    57:30 #1 Hamilton, Cabinet Battle #1
    58:37 The Appraisal
    1:00:45 Dictionary Of Misinformation: The Subconscious Isn't Freudian
    1:02:23 Closing Thoughts
    1:02:55 Shop, Partners, And Credits


    REFERENCED IN THIS EPISODE
    Daniel Defoe, The Diet of Poland (1705) · Daniel Defoe, The Shortest Way with the Dissenters (1702) · New York Gazette and Weekly Mercury, May 1773 · Hugh Gaine, printer · Alexander McDougall writing as “Hampden,” New York Journal (1773) · Giambattista Basile, Pentamerone (1634) · Charles Dickens, Hard Times (1854) · Hamilton, “Cabinet Battle #1” · Spider-Man (2002) · Family Matters


    COMMENT: Have you ever gotten defensive about something nobody was actually saying about you? And settle this — is a subtweet a disclaimer or a coward move?


    ATP SHOP — every phrase gets a grade. Some of them get a mug.
    appraisethephrase.com/shop

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 4 mins
  • Go Against The Grain
    Oct 7 2026

    The first person to say “against the grain” was lying. Not figuratively. He was coaching other people to lie, and the phrase was the lie.


    On this episode of Appraise The Phrase, Mario and Twenty are joined by Kayla, founder of Kinara Bookstore in Tulsa, to unveil the origin, confirm the meaning, and assess the value of “go against the grain.” It debuts in Shakespeare's Coriolanus around 1607, in the mouth of Sicinius — a tribune coaching Roman citizens to claim they'd been pressured into their vote, and that speaking up went against the grain. They were doing exactly what authority wanted. The first recorded figurative use of the phrase describes someone going with the grain. Mario's name for it is inverted debut.


    And the carpentry story everyone repeats? Every source on earth says this comes from woodworking. Gary Martin appears to be the only person who actually checked, and none of the early citations reference wood at all — the carpentry explanation only shows up after Shakespeare. It's not what you know. It's what you can prove.


    Also: why the play itself is about grain, how a phrase gets rationalized backwards, what clickbait did to writing, and Kayla on opening a bookstore in the gap left when Tulsa's only Black bookstore closed.


    Value is in the eye of the appraiser.


    0:00 Gladiator, Holograms, And What You Can Prove
    0:51 The ATP Intro Theme
    2:30 Introducing Our Guest
    3:44 Kayla On Founding Kinara Bookstore In Tulsa
    7:17 Who Decides What The Rules Are?
    15:11 Confirm The Meaning: Merriam-Webster
    18:11 Twenty Would Have Written It Differently
    22:28 Unveil The Origin: 1607, Coriolanus
    23:33 Our First Hologram Guest Should Be Shakespeare
    23:53 Sicinius, The Tribune, And The Coached Lie
    25:47 The Play Is Literally About Grain: The Corn Riot
    28:34 Inverted Debut: The First Use Was Inauthentic
    33:47 Kayla Does Not Fly Southwest
    37:54 Every Source On Earth Says Carpentry
    38:45 Gary Martin Is The Only One Who Checked
    39:51 Retroactive Etymological Rationalization
    42:16 Seed Oils, And Things That Sound True
    44:34 What Clickbait Did To Writing
    51:39 Is Any Of This Real? Clickbait Meets AI
    53:20 À Rebours, Bad Religion, And Garth Brooks
    55:44 Evaluative Reversal: When The Act Stops Mattering
    57:36 Do You Own “Going Against The Grain”?
    58:44 Building A Space For Us, By Us
    1:00:40 Twenty: Save The Last Dance
    1:04:23 The Phrase As A Banner People Wave
    1:08:23 The Appraisal: Power
    1:11:12 Speed
    1:12:07 Preference, Handed To The Guest
    1:13:31 Dictionary Of Misinformation
    1:15:04 The Kremlin Is Not A Building
    1:16:11 Where To Find Kinara Bookstore
    1:17:43 Shop, Credits, And Where To Find Us


    REFERENCED IN THIS EPISODE
    William Shakespeare, Coriolanus (c. 1607–08) · Plutarch, via North's translation · Merriam-Webster · Dictionary.com · Gary Martin, Phrase Finder · J.-K. Huysmans, À rebours (1884), published in English as Against the Grain · Bad Religion, Against the Grain (1990) · Garth Brooks, “Against the Grain,” written by Bruce Bouton, Larry Cordle and Carl Jackson · Marion Nestle, NYU · Gladiator (2000) · Training Day (2001) · Save the Last Dance (2001)


    GUEST: Kayla, founder of Kinara Bookstore — Tulsa's pop-up bookstore centering Black, brown, queer and disabled readers. Instagram, Threads and TikTok @kinara.books · kinarabookstore.com


    COMMENT: Have you ever actually gone against the grain, or did you just say you did? And settle this for us — open seating or assigned?


    ATP SHOP — every phrase gets a grade. Some of them get a mug.
    appraisethephrase.com/shop


    THE BRACKET — the board keeps filling. Tournament comes March 2027.

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 19 mins
  • Wet My Whistle
    Sep 30 2026

    Everybody thinks medieval pubs had cups with whistles baked into them. You blew the whistle, you got a refill. It's a great story and somebody made it up.


    On this episode, Mario and Twenty are joined by Myron to trace the origin, confirm the meaning, and assess the value of "wet my whistle." The whistle was never an object. It was your throat; a usage running through Beaumont and Fletcher, where you could "cut your whistle," and all the way back to Chaucer in 1386. The cup came later, invented backwards to explain a phrase people no longer understood. Mario's term for it is retroactive prop invention.


    Then there's the H. "Whet your whistle" shows up in Thomas Flatman's Belly God in 1674 and never leaves, because whet sounds more literate than wet — a 350-year hypercorrection that people still defend today.


    Also: the requirements for a proper swig, why nobody can agree on what a thumbs-up means, the dietary guidelines dropping their actual numbers, medieval life as imprisonment by civilization, and a Dictionary of Misinformation entry that will change how you sit in meetings.


    0:00 The Departed, Cranberry Juice, And A Phrase We Might Have To Retire
    0:44 The ATP Intro Theme
    1:33 Myron's In The Building
    1:58 Spoke Too Soon About The Sports Teams
    8:39 The Requirements For A Proper Swig
    9:24 Preferably Over 32 Ounces
    11:45 Ain't Nobody Going Out For Cranberry Juice
    14:03 Myron Has Been In The Store Too Long
    16:41 Unveil The Origin: Chaucer, 1386 (Content Warning)
    18:00 "So Was Her Jolly Whistle Well Wet"
    22:25 The Northern Clerks And Tolkien's Paper On The Reeve's Tale
    26:41 Rules We Enforce And Don't Follow
    27:57 Text Me, Don't Call Me
    29:00 Don't Read My Texts In A James Earl Jones Voice
    29:08 The Thumbs-Up Problem
    33:20 Emoji Etiquette In The Group Chat
    34:24 Confirm The Meaning: Beaumont And Fletcher, "Cut Your Whistle"
    36:39 Thomas Flatman's Belly God, 1674
    37:19 Wet vs. Whet: 350 Years Of Trying To Sound Smarter
    39:25 The Dietary Guidelines Dropped The Actual Numbers
    43:39 Myron Amends His Take
    46:07 The Myth: Cups With Whistles Baked In
    47:05 Twenty: Medieval Life Was A Prison
    49:10 Retroactive Prop Invention
    50:56 "Am I Gonna Have To Stop Saying Wet My Whistle?"
    52:43 Myron's Hit List: It Is What It Is
    53:51 Why Won't You Explain Your Real Reasoning?
    56:16 Capacity, And Having Your Own Stuff Going On
    59:25 Using A Phrase To Avoid Confrontation
    59:52 Pop Culture Impact: The Top Four
    1:01:47 #1 Indiana Jones And The Last Crusade
    1:02:19 The Appraisal
    1:07:30 Dictionary Of Misinformation: Meeting Minutes
    1:09:50 Shop, Credits, And Where To Find Us


    REFERENCED IN THIS EPISODE
    Geoffrey Chaucer, The Reeve's Tale (c. 1386) · John Palsgrave, Lesclarcissement de la langue francoyse (1530) · The Towneley Plays · Beaumont and Fletcher · Thomas Flatman, Belly God (1674) · Henry Fielding, Joseph Andrews (1742) · J.R.R. Tolkien, "Chaucer as a Philologist: The Reeve's Tale," Transactions of the Philological Society · Michael Quinion, World Wide Words · The Departed (2006) · To Have and Have Not (1944) · Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade (1989)


    COMMENT: Wet or whet — which are you, and are you prepared to defend it? And settle this for us: what does a thumbs-up actually mean?


    ATP SHOP: every phrase gets a grade. Some of them get a mug.
    appraisethephrase.com/shop
    THE BRACKET: the board is filling up. Tournament comes March 2027.
    Subscribe to Appraise The Phrase on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/TheUnderdog
    Appraise The Phrase official site: appraisethephrase.com
    Check out our other ATP produced shows: appraisethephrase.com/community
    Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theappraisethephraseshow
    Follow us on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@appraisethephrase
    Follow us on X/Twitter: https://x.com/TheATPShow

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 11 mins
  • In The Nick of Time
    Sep 23 2026

    On this episode of Appraise The Phrase, Mario and Twenty trace the origin of "in the nick of time" and explains how it started out as pudding time.


    It starts in 1546 with John Heywood's book of proverbs, where arriving "in pudding time" meant showing up right as dinner started — because in the 16th century, pudding was savory, closer to sausage than dessert, and it was served first.


    Then pudding drifted to the end of the meal, and the phrase stopped making sense. The phrase never changed. The world did.


    Enter the nick: a notch cut into a tally stick, the wooden receipts the English Exchequer kept for centuries. And in 1834, when officials finally burned the obsolete sticks in the furnaces beneath the House of Lords, they burned down Parliament with them. The thing that gave us the phrase went up in smoke. The phrase survived.


    Also: Merriam-Webster watching too much Indiana Jones, referential collapse, the leap second being abolished right now, what you still say about yourself that stopped being true, and why we all keep the bags under the sink.


    0:00 Indiana Jones, Janice, Drake, And The Nick Of Time
    0:51 The ATP Intro Theme
    1:37 What's Good: Football Season Is Here
    2:34 The Dolphins, Malik Willis, And Quarterback Fit
    9:07 Yes, This Is Still A Word Show
    10:28 Today's Phrase: In The Nick Of Time
    13:14 Twenty: This Phrase Is Janice From Accounting
    15:03 Confirm The Meaning: Merriam-Webster vs. Cambridge
    16:01 Trim The Fat: What A Definition Should Actually Do
    16:53 Merriam-Webster Has Been Watching Too Much Indiana Jones
    19:03 Unveil The Origin: Before The Nick, There Was Pudding Time
    20:44 1546: John Heywood's Book Of Proverbs
    21:46 Pudding Was Sausage — And It Came First
    22:53 How Pudding Became Dessert And Broke The Phrase
    24:55 Referential Collapse: When The World Leaves A Phrase Behind
    26:00 What Do You Still Say About Yourself That Stopped Being True?
    30:37 Performative Caring In The Social Media Era
    31:37 Mario: I Still Tell People I'm An Athlete
    33:43 Twenty Has Been Avoiding Fences On Purpose
    36:29 The Tudors Want Something Sharper: Golding, Ovid, And "Nick"
    37:58 What Even Is A Notch? The Exchequer's Tally Sticks
    39:13 So The Teachers Were Wrong
    40:05 The Leap Second Is Being Abolished
    42:12 What Would You Let Drift, And What Would You Never Let Go?
    46:42 1834: The Nick Burns Down Parliament
    49:05 Turner Painted It From A Boat On The Thames
    49:24 Infrastructural Afterlife: A Fossil Metaphor
    49:54 What Have You Held Onto Past Its Usefulness?
    50:38 Keep The Bags Under The Sink, Throw Away The Boxes
    52:27 Pop Culture #4: Every Film Called In The Nick Of Time
    53:22 #3: The In The Nick Of Time Clock In Newport, Wales
    53:51 #2 Charles Dickens / #1 Turner's The Burning Of The Houses Of Lords And Commons
    54:59 The Appraisal: Impact
    56:04 Speed
    57:30 Preference
    59:58 Dictionary Of Misinformation: Typhoid Mary
    1:00:30 Closing


    REFERENCED IN THIS EPISODE
    John Heywood, A Dialogue Conteynyng the Nomber in Effect of All the Prouerbes in the Englishe Tongue (1546) · Thomas Fuller, Gnomologia (1732) · Arthur Golding's translation of Ovid's Metamorphoses (1565–67) · Caroline Shenton, The Day Parliament Burned Down (2012) · J.M.W. Turner, The Burning of the Houses of Lords and Commons (1835) · Charles Dickens, speech to the Administrative Reform Association (1855) · IERS Bulletin C · Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981) · Wanted (2008)


    COMMENT: What do you still say about yourself that stopped being true? And what are you holding onto long past its usefulness — bags under the sink count.

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 2 mins
  • On The Back Burner
    Sep 16 2026

    Everybody knows what it means. Almost nobody can tell you where it came from...and that turns out to be the whole story. #OnTheBackBurner #Etymology #WordOrigins


    On this episode of Appraise The Phrase, Mario and Twenty unveil the origin, confirm the meaning, and assess the value of ""on the back burner,"" the youngest phrase this show has ever appraised. Before gas, American stoves didn't have burners at all. They had eyes — removable lids over a single firebox — so cooks were back-burning constantly, by physics, with no words to describe what they were doing. The concept sat around for a century waiting on the technology to name it.


    Then the gas range arrives in the 1920s and the phrase still doesn't show up until 1945, with Oxford holding out until 1963. Why the lag? Because a thing has to get boring before it can become a figure of speech.


    Also: the two twists that make this phrase strange — a name that may run backwards, and an American metaphor whose earliest written evidence sits in the Times of London. Plus gas stove bans in San Francisco, Colorado, New York and Virginia, what you were doing for years before you had a word for it, the gap-filling friend, and a Dictionary of Misinformation entry about what robins are actually doing on your lawn.


    Then we grade it. It does not go well.


    Value is in the eye of the appraiser.


    0:00 If Billy Don't Say It, It Ain't No Phrase

    0:57 The ATP Intro Theme

    1:45 What's Good: The Holiday We Won't Timestamp

    5:08 DC Heat vs. Southern Heat

    7:08 When Great Directors Have To Explain Their Own Movies

    8:10 Today's Phrase: On The Back Burner

    9:26 Twenty's Take: Not My First Choice, But It Gets The Job Done

    10:15 Mario's Take: Why It Feels Like Disrespect

    12:17 A Question For The Chefs: Are The Burners Actually Weighted?

    13:13 Confirm The Meaning: Merriam-Webster, Cambridge, Collins

    14:25 Priority vs. Importance

    18:00 The Youngest Phrase We've Ever Done

    18:36 Unveil The Origin: When Stoves Didn't Have Burners

    20:29 No Word For It Because There Was Nothing To Name

    21:00 The Lexical Gap

    21:47 What Were You Doing For Years Before You Had A Word For It?

    22:04 Twenty: Humor As A Defense Mechanism

    25:32 Older Generations Didn't Have ""Depression."" They Had Melancholy

    26:25 The Happiest Beat About Fighting Off Depression

    29:47 The 1920s: The Appliance Arrives, The Phrase Doesn't

    30:53 Gas Companies Lose Lighting And Move Into The Kitchen

    32:30 1945 To 1963: Why The Phrase Took 30 Years To Land

    33:22 Metaphor Lag: A Thing Has To Get Boring First

    34:20 Gas Stove Bans: San Francisco, Colorado, New York, Virginia

    37:13 Should A Restaurant Kitchen Be Told To Go Electric?

    39:53 Take Your Ass Outside And Grill

    40:38 Twist One: The Name May Run Backwards

    42:37 Twist Two: An American Phrase First Printed In London

    44:01 Is This Phrase An Industry Plant?

    45:19 Back-Formation And The Missing Paper Trail

    46:45 The Plan-Making Friend And The Gap-Filling Friend

    50:22 Check Yourself Before You Wreck Yourself

    53:13 Pop Culture Impact: Only A Top Three This Time

    54:49 #2 The Burner Branch: Burner Phone, Burner Account, Burner Email

    55:40 #1 The Wire, Season 3, Episode 7: ""Back Burners""

    57:09 The Appraisal: Impact

    58:58 Speed

    1:00:50 Preference

    1:01:26 This Phrase Is Boston Market

    1:02:09 Dictionary Of Misinformation: Birds Do Not Listen For Worms

    1:04:50 Closing Thoughts

    1:05:08 Shop, Credits, And Where To Find Us


    REFERENCED IN THIS EPISODE

    Merriam-Webster · Cambridge Dictionary · Collins Dictionary · Oxford English Dictionary · Cambridge English Corpus · The Times of London · The Wire, ""Back Burners,"" S3E7, aired November 7, 2004 — teleplay by Joy Lusco Kecken, story by David Simon & Joy Lusco Kecken, directed by Tim Van Patten


    COMMENT: Lefties — do you actually use the front left burner? And what's something

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 6 mins
  • Train Of Thought
    Sep 9 2026

    Everybody pictures a locomotive. Everybody is wrong.On this episode of Appraise The Phrase, Mario and Twenty unveil the origin, confirm the meaning, and assess the value of "train of thought" — a phrase that shows up in Thomas Hobbes' Leviathan in 1651 and John Locke's Essay Concerning Human Understanding in 1690, roughly 165 years before locomotives existed. The railroad imagery in your head? That's folk etymology doing what folk etymology always does: replacing the real reason with a better story.Along the way: why every major dictionary fumbles the definition, what "brain rot" and "train of thought" have in common as conceptual metaphors, how ideological sedimentation means you're often repeating arguments you weren't alive for, and why AI reasoning is the modern version of the same problem. Plus Twenty loses his actual train of thought live on the mic, which may be the most on-topic thing to ever happen on this show.Also discussed: Damon Darling getting banned from Walmart for buying strangers' groceries, the I, Robot Sonny conspiracy, the Mandela Effect hill we will die on, and why red Kool-Aid is not strawberry.Then we appraise it. Power grade, Speed grade, Preference. And we close with the Dictionary of Misinformation on the Thanksgiving turkey you think the pilgrims ate.Value is in the eye of the appraiser.0:00 Sherlock Holmes' Deductions, AI, And Someone Else's Train Of Thought1:08 The ATP Intro Theme1:52 What's Good: Back To School And Breaking The Monotony4:19 Today's Phrase: Train Of Thought4:41 Twenty's Take: You Only Say It When You've Lost It6:10 Mario's Take: The Phrase Paints A Picture7:25 Confirm The Meaning: Merriam-Webster vs. Cambridge vs. Dictionary.com10:15 Why "A Path Of Reasoning" Can't Be The Definition10:44 Unveil The Origin: "Train" In The 14th Century Meant To Drag Or Trail12:50 Conceptual Metaphors And Brain Rot (Oxford's 2024 Word Of The Year)13:50 Twenty Loses His Train Of Thought On An Episode About Train Of Thought14:59 Brain Rot Confessions: Instagram, Love Island, Love Is Blind20:11 Walmart Banned Damon Darling For Buying People Groceries22:36 1651: Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan, And The First Recorded Use23:57 Ideological Sedimentation: Inheriting Arguments You Never Had26:16 I, Robot: "Can A Robot Write A Symphony?" "Can You?"27:00 The Sonny Conspiracy: The Actor They Refused To Promote31:45 Why AI Gets Things Confidently Wrong32:14 Believed With Our Whole Chest: Y2K, The Mayans, And Flying Cars36:24 1690: John Locke, Association Of Ideas, And "Food For Thought"38:43 Train Of Thought Predates The Railroad By 165 Years40:11 "Sounds Like A Train To Me": How The Locomotive Got Its Name41:52 Edison Slander, Tesla, And The Prestige45:28 Institutional Formalization And Gen Z Slang Creep47:30 Folk Etymology: When The Better Lie Wins48:55 The Mandela Effect And The Shazam Hill We Will Die On50:55 Confidently Wrong: Red Kool-Aid Is Not Strawberry53:47 Pop Culture #1: Pixar's Inside Out54:44 #2: Sherlock Holmes And Guy Ritchie's Slow-Motion Deductions58:14 #3 The Greatest American Hero / #4 The Lost Train Of Thought59:28 The Appraisal: Power Grade And Impact Grade1:01:36 Final Grade1:02:37 Dictionary Of Misinformation: The Thanksgiving Turkey Myth1:04:41 The Watch List And Closing Thoughts1:05:48 Shop, Credits, And Where To Find Us

    REFERENCED IN THIS EPISODE

    Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan (1651) · John Locke, An Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1690) · David Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature (1739) · Pixar's Inside Out (2015) · Sherlock Holmes (2009, dir. Guy Ritchie) · I, Robot (2004) · The Prestige (2006) · Slumdog Millionaire (2008) · The Greatest American Hero, "Train of Thought" (1982) · The Lost Train of Thought, The Seems series (2009)


    COMMENT: Which pop culture moment captures a train of thought best — Inside Out or Sherlock? And what's a folk etymology you defended with your whole chest before you found out it was wrong?


    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 7 mins
  • In A Nutshell
    Sep 2 2026
    "Help! I'm in a nutshell!" — Austin Powers already knew this phrase was funnier taken literally. We trace "in a nutshell" back almost 2,000 years to a claim that might just be one of history's oldest fake news stories.Mario and Twenty unveil the origin, confirm the meaning, and assess the value of "in a nutshell." The trail starts with a wild secondhand claim: Pliny the Elder wrote that Cicero once said the entire Iliad was copied onto parchment small enough to fit inside a nutshell...a claim scholars now treat as an ancient game of telephone more than a fact. From there it survives centuries of translation and rebranding: a 1387 English translation by John Trevisa, a 1579 pamphlet trashing the theater world by Stephen Golson, and finally Shakespeare himself, who dropped it into Hamlet in 1603 — "I could be bounded in a nutshell and count myself a king of infinite space, were it not that I had bad dreams"... cementing it forever.Along the way: three dictionary definitions (Cambridge, Dictionary.com, Vocabulary.com), a confession from both hosts about whether they actually live by the phrase they're covering, a deeply personal debate about where bias sneaks into things that are supposed to be neutral, and one host's non-negotiable stance on mayonnaise. Then it's Power Grade, Speed Grade, and a Preference Grade twist that neither host saw coming — plus a Dictionary of Misinformation segment busting the myth behind "no love lost."0:00 Austin Powers In A Nutshell Opener0:48 Intro Theme & Catching Up9:36 Introducing "In A Nutshell"10:43 Confession: Do We Even Live By This Phrase?14:41 Confirm The Meaning: Dictionary Definitions: Cambridge, Dictionary.com, Vocabulary.com19:44 Unveil The Origin: Cicero, Pliny the Elder & the Iliad-in-a-Nutshell Claim26:00 Story Time: Reflection - The Story That Can't Get Distorted28:19 The Mayonnaise Biopic Bit32:58 Unveil The Origin: Literary Lineage - John Trevisa's 1387 Translation37:24 Unveil The Origin: William Shakespeare Enters the Chat39:39 Story Time: Reflection - Where Bias Sneaks Into "Neutral" Things43:19 Story Time: Reflection - The Modest Thing That Does the Heavy Lifting50:07 Unveil The Origin: The Line That Made It Famous: Hamlet, 160352:29 Cultural Impact: A Novel, a German Brand & the Elevator Pitch54:34 Assess The Value: Power Grade56:31 Assess The Value: Speed Grade56:54 Assess The Value: Preference Grade - A Twist Ending58:33 Dictionary of Misinformation: "No Love Lost"1:01:02 Outro & ShopLINKSSubscribe to Appraise The Phrase on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/TheUnderdog Appraise The Phrase official site: appraisethephrase.com ATP Shop — mugs & merch: appraisethephrase.com/shop Check out our other ATP produced shows: appraisethephrase.com/community Listen on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4jLFx2WLEslKF3BHWWvIlv?si=367e5762bdb9464a Listen on Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/appraise-the-phrase/id1570186367 Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theappraisethephraseshow Follow us on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@appraisethephrase Follow us on X/Twitter: https://x.com/TheATPShow Previous Episodes: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLmMMLmEcgaa3C1d_wZrZuWAJGB_mYQraB&si=Igvwjz9UT5dbnx7T Episode Clips: https://www.youtube.com/@AppraiseThePhraseClips ABOUT APPRAISE THE PHRASEAppraise The Phrase is a weekly podcast from the Underdog Podcast Network where the hosts unveil the origin, confirm the meaning, and assess the value of the everyday phrases and idioms we all use without ever asking where they came from. Each episode ends with a Power Grade and a round of the Dictionary of Misinformation, debunking a popular word-origin myth.New episodes every week. Subscribe and turn on notifications so you don't miss the next one.

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 3 mins
  • Wet My Beak
    Aug 26 2026

    Where does ""wet my beak"" actually come from? We trace it from a 19th-century Sicilian grain custom to The Godfather — and yes, we get into He Got Game too. #AppraiseThePhrase #Etymology #WordOrigins #WetMyBeak #TheGodfather


    Mario and Twenty unveil the origin, confirm the meaning, and assess the value of ""wet my beak."" The trail starts in 19th-century rural Sicily, where grain farmers were expected to give estate guards a little extra at harvest — ""fari vagnari lo pizzu,"" literally ""to wet the beak"" — the imagery being a bird dipping in to drink, not gorging itself. That custom got carried across the Atlantic and turned into something sharper: Mario Puzo used the exact Sicilian phrase in his 1969 novel The Godfather, putting it in the mouth of the extortionist Fanucci as he shakes down a young Vito Corleone. Coppola's Godfather Part II dramatized the same scene in 1974 — and the guys dig into whether the custom's original ""fairness"" survived the trip from grain tithe to mafia protection money.


    Along the way: three dictionary definitions (Free Dictionary, Wiktionary, Urban Dictionary), a debate about whether extortion can ever be ""earned,"" a Power Grade and a Speed Grade, and a Dictionary of Misinformation segment busting the myth of who actually ""invented"" the wheel. Stick around for the He Got Game breakdown — once you hear how the guys connect Uncle Bubba's ""let me wet my beak"" line to this phrase, you won't hear it the same way again.


    0:00 – He Got Game Uncle Bubba Opener

    1:20 – Intro & Catching Up


    Confirm The Meaning

    10:34 – Introducing ""Wet My Beak"" + Dictionary Definitions


    Unveil The Origin

    18:25 – Origin: 19th-Century Sicilian Grain Custom

    30:31 – Literary Origin: Mario Puzo's The Godfather (1969)

    34:19 – Is Extortion Ever Fair? A Real Debate

    45:44 – Cinematic Origin: The Godfather Part II (1974)


    Storytime

    29:16 – The ""I Can't Stress This Enough"" Delivery Bit

    50:45 – Personal Reflection: The Pettiest Toll You've Ever Collected


    Assess The Value

    55:55 – Power Grade

    58:04 – Speed Grade

    59:53 – He Got Game, Revisited


    1:02:05 – Dictionary of Misinformation: Who Invented the Wheel?

    1:04:11 – Outro & Shop


    LINKS

    Subscribe to Appraise The Phrase on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/TheUnderdog

    Appraise The Phrase official site: appraisethephrase.com

    ATP Shop — mugs & merch: appraisethephrase.com/shop

    Check out our other ATP produced shows: appraisethephrase.com/community

    Listen on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4jLFx2WLEslKF3BHWWvIlv?si=367e5762bdb9464a

    Listen on Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/appraise-the-phrase/id1570186367

    Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theappraisethephraseshow

    Follow us on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@appraisethephrase

    Follow us on X/Twitter: https://x.com/TheATPShow

    Previous Episodes: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLmMMLmEcgaa3C1d_wZrZuWAJGB_mYQraB&si=Igvwjz9UT5dbnx7T

    Episode Clips: https://www.youtube.com/@AppraiseThePhraseClips


    ABOUT APPRAISE THE PHRASE

    Appraise The Phrase is a weekly podcast from the Underdog Podcast Network where the hosts unveil the origin, confirm the meaning, and assess the value of the everyday phrases and idioms we all use without ever asking where they came from. Each episode ends with a Power Grade and a round of the Dictionary of Misinformation, debunking a popular word-origin myth.


    New episodes every week. Subscribe and turn on notifications so you don't miss the next one.

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 6 mins