Episodes

  • 76. Big Muddy Mayhem, LIVE! from the Cheshire Inn — Murder, Mayhem, and Mixers
    Oct 21 2025

    Janet shares the story of the Dentist turned Serial Killer in South St. Louis, and then Tracey shares the story of a famous writer who hid away in a hotel, much like where our Live was tonight!

    Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

    Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

    You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: bigmuddymayhem@gmail.com

    You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

    Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

    References:

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 13 mins
  • 75. The Sinquefield Cup's Chess Drama and The Vaile Mansion's Hauntings
    Oct 6 2025

    Tracey tells the story of how a chess championship where one of the major champions will no longer play a certain player and the drama that was had, then Janet tells the history of the Vaile Mansion, and how it's halls may be haunted with old residents.

    Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

    Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

    You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: bigmuddymayhem@gmail.com

    You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

    Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

    References:

    Show More Show Less
    46 mins
  • 74. The Lost Boys of Hannibal's Cave and Josephine Baker's Conclusion
    Sep 29 2025

    Janet shares the history of Hannibal and the story of the boys who got lost in a cave. Then Tracey conludes her amazing story of actor, dancer, singer and spy, Josephine Baker.

    Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

    Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

    You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: bigmuddymayhem@gmail.com

    You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

    Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

    References:

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 5 mins
  • 73. Joseph Baker Part 2 and Benbow City's Rise and Fall
    Sep 21 2025

    Tracey tells the part two story of the amazing life of Josephine Baker and how she broke barriers for a woman and woman of color, and then Janet tells the tai of the lost city , just east of Alton, Illinios, of Benbow City and about it's rise and fall.

    Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

    Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

    You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: bigmuddymayhem@gmail.com

    You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

    Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

    References:

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 12 mins
  • 72. Jesse James Part 2 and Josephine Baker: From St. Louis to Stardom
    Sep 16 2025

    Janet concludes her story of Jesse James and how people in MIssouri routed for him and the James gang till they robbed the wrong bank. Then Tracey starts her multiple part story of the amazing Josephine Baker and how she paved the way for other non white performers.

    Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

    Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

    You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: bigmuddymayhem@gmail.com

    You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

    Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

    References:

    Show More Show Less
    55 mins
  • 71. Bertha Gifford's Poison Pantry and The Infamous Jesse James
    Sep 5 2025

    Tracey tells the tail of Bertha Gifford and how she poised several people in a small town in Missouri and then Janet starts her two part episode of the Jesse James and how his family were unable to let go of losing to the North.

    Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

    Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

    You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: bigmuddymayhem@gmail.com

    You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

    Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

    References:

    Show More Show Less
    54 mins
  • 70. The Noid and Kent State University: A Mascot, a Massacre
    May 27 2025

    Tracey shares the story of the mascot of Dominoe's pizza, the Noid and then Janet tells the tale of the shooting at Kent State University and protests.

    Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

    Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

    You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: bigmuddymayhem@gmail.com

    You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

    Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

    References:

    Huey Long:

    Wikipedia

    Enfield Horrow:

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 1 min
  • 69. Huey Long pt 3 and The Enfield Horror: The Kingfish Falls and an Illinois Monster
    Apr 27 2025

    Janet finishes her three parter of Huey Long and then Tracey tells the tale of the story of the Enfield Horror.

    Join Tracey and Janet as they share these amazing stories from the Midwest and Central US and become our Muddy Buddies!

    Merch is at https://bigmuddymayhem.creator-spring.com/

    You can email us any suggestions for ideas at: bigmuddymayhem@gmail.com

    You can also join our Facebook group at: https://www.facebook.com/big.muddy.mayhem.podcast/

    Join our Patreon at only $2 a month~ Big Muddy Mayhem | Podcast about True Crime and Bad Behavior in the Midwest | Patreon

    References:

    Huey Long:

    Wikipedia

    Enfield Horrow:

    Show More Show Less
    53 mins