Episodes

  • S5.E8 - Season 5 Finale
    Oct 20 2026

    It's the Season Five finale! We look back at all seven books they covered this season — completely spoiler-free — sharing what they loved, what surprised them, what stuck with them, and what they're looking forward to in Season Six.

    Chapters

    • (00:00) - Introduction
    • (00:44) - Season 5 Episode 8
    • (02:24) - Summarizing the season
    • (03:11) - Favorite of the season
    • (06:35) - Genuine surprise
    • (09:05) - Favorite characters
    • (11:13) - The one that's still lingering
    • (12:41) - Changing what to look for
    • (17:16) - The seasons biggest page-turner
    • (19:24) - Adaptable to the screen
    • (21:50) - If you could erase your brain
    • (23:42) - The ones he chose by himself
    • (27:37) - The most accessible for the husbands
    • (29:21) - Final thoughts
    Show More Show Less
    33 mins
  • S5.E7 - The Pirate Queen by Ariel Lawhon
    Oct 6 2026

    Time to cast off, scalawags. We're discussing The Pirate Queen by Ariel Lawhon and what it means to be a woman who refuses the life her world designed for her. We ask whether an ambitious structure pays off, what love and loyalty look like when your life is a bargaining chip, and whether the book's ending lives up to everything before it.

    Links

    • The Pirate Queen on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/223641004-the-pirate-queen)
    • Ariel Lawhon on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/485025.Ariel_Lawhon)

    Chapters

    • (00:00) - Introduction
    • (00:45) - Season 5 Episode 7
    • (01:33) - Why Kristy picked this one
    • (03:16) - Book summary (spoiler-free)
    • (05:25) - SPOILER ALERT!
    • (05:59) - Kristy's review
    • (08:38) - Jon's review
    • (13:12) - Off with her braid!
    • (17:53) - Gráinne's paternal relationship
    • (19:59) - Gráinne's maternal relationship
    • (22:42) - Gráinne's sibling relationship
    • (25:24) - Wisdom vs oppression
    • (27:45) - Brehon law
    • (30:00) - Tale of two marriages
    • (37:12) - Who says decency works against ya?
    • (40:27) - The writing structure
    • (44:18) - Gráinne vs The Queen
    • (49:34) - Final thoughts
    Show More Show Less
    53 mins
  • S5.E6 - Her Last Breath by Taylor Adams
    Sep 22 2026

    This week we splunk into Her Last Breath by Taylor Adams — a tightly plotted thriller about two best friends and a terrifying ordeal in a pitch-black cave system called the Devil's Staircase. We get into the cave as its own kind of villain, why the detective’s interview technique had them both taking notes, and the breadcrumbs Taylor Adams drops along the way.

    Links

    • Her Last Breath on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/234313865-her-last-breath)
    • Taylor Adams on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/8475510.Taylor_Adams)

    Chapters

    • (00:00) - Introduction
    • (00:45) - Season 5 Episode 6
    • (05:03) - Book summary (spoiler-free)
    • (06:30) - SPOILER ALERT!
    • (06:58) - Jon's review
    • (07:50) - Kristy's review
    • (09:21) - The 'friendly' dynamic
    • (12:18) - The man at the cave
    • (15:19) - The cave as a character
    • (22:13) - Detective Layla Washington
    • (28:41) - Following the breadcrumbs
    • (31:16) - The ultimate twist
    • (36:45) - A sudden 'villainous shift'
    • (40:13) - The friendship complexities
    • (45:43) - Final thoughts
    Show More Show Less
    51 mins
  • S5.E5 - Whistler by Ann Patchett
    Sep 8 2026

    Hop on, because we’re jumping into Whistler by Ann Patchett — a novel about a woman who reunites with her stepfather more than forty years after a car crash severed their family. We get into the two timelines, the love that doesn't fit a category, what the horse Whistler means, and the moment a mother finally tells the true thing instead of the easier one.

    Links

    • Whistler on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/242693052-whistler)
    • Ann Patchett on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/7136914.Ann_Patchett)

    Chapters

    • (00:00) - Intro
    • (00:45) - S5 E5
    • (01:37) - Why this book?
    • (02:20) - Upcoming books
    • (04:53) - Book summary (spoiler-free version)
    • (06:35) - SPOILER ALERT!
    • (06:59) - Kristy's review
    • (08:31) - Jon's review
    • (10:08) - Discussing the opening hook
    • (12:44) - 9-yr old Daphne
    • (14:39) - What's with the horse?
    • (17:16) - The mother figure
    • (21:22) - Speaking truths
    • (27:09) - Children and adult pain
    • (29:37) - The timeline structure
    • (31:45) - The ending
    • (37:50) - Final thoughts
    Show More Show Less
    43 mins
  • S5.E4 - Kin by Tayari Jones
    Aug 25 2026

    Episode four sinks into Kin by Tayari Jones — a historical novel about mothers and daughters, about friendship and sisterhood, and the complexities of being a woman in the American South. We get into the distinct voices Jones gives each woman, the historical weight of the setting, what it means to choose your kin, and whether the ending delivered on everything the book was building toward.

    Links

    • Kin on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/241126800-kin)
    • Tayari Jones on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/292970.Tayari_Jones)
    • Author’s website: (https://www.tayarijones.com/)

    Chapters

    • (01:52) - Why this book?
    • (02:28) - Upcoming books
    • (03:56) - Book summary (spoiler-free)
    • (05:33) - SPOILER ALERT!
    • (06:00) - Jon's review
    • (08:29) - Kristy's review
    • (10:03) - The character that resonated
    • (13:36) - Niecy
    • (17:05) - Annie
    • (19:10) - The setting
    • (21:17) - Niecy's secret
    • (28:24) - Setting the bar
    • (32:57) - The title into the ending
    • (35:10) - Crystallization
    • (37:58) - The quiet ending
    • (40:50) - Final thoughts
    Show More Show Less
    44 mins
  • S5.E3 - The Burning Side by Sarah Damoff
    Aug 11 2026

    Next up in season five is The Burning Side by Sarah Damoff — a story about a marriage in freefall after a house fire forces them to move in with their parents. We get into the asymmetry of guilt between April and Leo, Deb’s quietly devastating storyline, the lines that stopped us mid-read, and whether the ending was earned.

    Links

    • Official author website: (https://www.sarahdamoff.com/)
    • The Burning Side on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/242977911-the-burning-side)

    Chapters

    • (00:00) - Intro
    • (00:45) - Season 5 Episode 3
    • (01:58) - Why Kristy picked this book
    • (04:34) - Book summary (spoiler-free)
    • (06:06) - SPOILER ALERT!!
    • (06:36) - Kristy's review
    • (08:26) - Jon's review
    • (10:28) - Getting hooked right out of the gate
    • (14:54) - The POV that landed the hardest
    • (23:37) - Ok, Leo, we need to talk
    • (27:16) - The affair
    • (33:11) - Guilt and innocence
    • (36:23) - In the middle of the plot
    • (40:02) - 10,000 choices
    • (42:29) - The ending
    • (46:10) - Final thoughts


    Show More Show Less
    50 mins
  • S5.E2 - Wild Dark Shore by Charlotte McConaghy
    Jul 28 2026

    Episode 2 analyzes Wild Dark Shore by Charlotte McConaghy — a haunting, atmospheric novel set on a remote island near Antarctica. We get into the mystery of Rowan’s arrival, the quiet devastation of the Salt family’s situation, the climate grief baked into the world of the book, and whether the ending is brilliant or heartbreaking — or both.

    Links

    • Official author website: (https://www.charlottemcconaghy.com/)
    • Wild Dark Shore on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/231127223-wild-dark-shore)
    • Charlotte McConaghy on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/2869149.Charlotte_McConaghy)

    Chapters

    • (00:00) - Introduction
    • (00:45) - Episode 2
    • (02:12) - Why this book for Jon?
    • (03:34) - Upcoming books
    • (05:44) - Book summary (spoiler-free)
    • (07:43) - SPOILER ALERT!
    • (07:59) - Jon's review
    • (09:50) - Kristy's review
    • (12:06) - Jon's expectations going in
    • (15:57) - Oh, Dom...
    • (21:06) - Orly's attachment to Rowan
    • (23:17) - Rowan's mystery
    • (27:59) - The seed bank metaphor
    • (31:41) - The climate backdrop
    • (33:13) - The island as a living entity
    • (36:09) - Rowan and Dom's dynamic
    • (39:18) - Let's talk about... the ending
    • (44:27) - Final thoughts
    Show More Show Less
    50 mins
  • S5.E1 - The Night We Met by Abby Jimenez
    Jul 14 2026

    We’re kicking off Season Five with The Night We Met by Abby Jimenez — a companion novel to Say You’ll Remember Me set in the same world. We get into the wrong-person trope, the slow build between Chris and Larissa, what loyalty and timing do to two people who are trying to do the right thing, and whether the pacing of the resolution worked for us.

    Links

    • Official author website: (https://www.authorabbyjimenez.com/)
    • The Night We Met on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/231801371-the-night-we-met)
    • Abby Jimenez on Goodreads: (https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/18446724.Abby_Jimenez)

    Chapters

    • (00:00) - - Introduction
    • (02:12) - - Why this book, Kristy?
    • (02:58) - - Upcoming books
    • (07:50) - - SPOILER ALERT
    • (08:06) - - Summary (with spoilers)
    • (09:18) - - Kristy's review
    • (11:35) - - Jon's review
    • (14:34) - - First impressions of Chris
    • (15:51) - - Blind to the universe
    • (17:18) - - Trope talk
    • (22:23) - - The convenient plot devices
    • (25:05) - - The struggle is real, people
    • (29:14) - - The (slow) burn
    • (34:16) - - Quiet acts of service... what a guy
    • (39:52) - - Earning the ending
    • (42:39) - - Recommend this or SYRM?
    • (44:38) - - Final thoughts
    Show More Show Less
    47 mins