A San Jose officer fired a 40mm less-lethal round into a protest crowd and hit a man who threw nothing and was running away. In Johnson v. Adgar, the Ninth Circuit held that everyone hit when an officer fires into a crowd is seized, and that this shot was excessive force. The officer still got qualified immunity because no earlier case was close enough. Now that this published opinion has decided the constitutional question, the next officer in the Ninth Circuit who fires the same kind of shot may not be protected. This episode covers what happened, the seizure, force and immunity rules behind the decision, and how to identify your target, document it and train for the next protest.