Two former Major Leaguers. Two completely different paths to the big leagues. And a message about youth baseball that every parent needs to hear.
Kevin Pillar never played travel baseball growing up. He played multiple sports, spent summers at the lake, went to a Division II college, and was drafted in the 32nd round. He went on to spend 13 seasons in Major League Baseball.
Cody Allen was a highly regarded high school prospect whose career took a completely different route. Tommy John surgery, losing his scholarship, junior college, and three different colleges before being drafted in the 23rd round. He eventually became Cleveland's all-time saves leader.
Today, they're both dads, youth coaches, and co-hosts of the To the Majors podcast. And they've got some strong opinions about what's happening in youth and travel baseball.
In this episode we cover:
- Why Kevin never played travel baseball and how playing multiple sports helped his MLB career
- Cody's road through Tommy John surgery, JUCO, and multiple colleges
- Why parents need to rethink the D1-or-bust mentality
- What 12U and 13U rankings actually mean to former Major Leaguers
- The lie about getting left behind that's influencing so many baseball parents
- Why both believe playing multiple sports still matters today
- How to tell whether your son's travel team is actually developing players or just chasing trophies
- Why failure and adversity are so important to a young player's development
- The pressure parents unknowingly put on their sons
- Why winning at 10U or 12U may come at the expense of development
- When parents need to start letting their sons take ownership of their baseball dreams
Kevin and Cody also share stories about facing some of baseball's toughest hitters and pitchers, what they've learned coaching their own children, and why the path to college or professional baseball rarely looks the way parents expect.
If you're spending thousands on travel baseball because you're worried your son might fall behind, this is a conversation you need to hear before making your next big decision.
⚾ THIS EPISODE IS SPONSORED BY TRUSTED EVAL
Have a high school baseball player who's hoping to play in college?
Trusted Eval gives you feedback from 3 college baseball coaches who evaluate your son's highlight video and provide their independent assessment of what level of college baseball he projects to play.
The process is anonymous for both the player and the coaches, allowing parents to get an outside perspective on where their son may fit.
The regular price is $199, but Chasing Baseball Dreams listeners can save $50 with promo code DREAMS.
👉 Get your evaluation: https://www.trustedeval.com
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 Introduction: Kevin Pillar and Cody Allen
01:29 Kevin's path from seasonal baseball to the big leagues
05:07 Cody's Tommy John surgery and college baseball journey
09:05 Why D1 or bust is the wrong mentality
17:53 How much do 12U and 13U rankings matter?
23:25 Development, playing time, and changing travel teams
30:52 Why playing multiple sports still matters
34:00 The travel baseball fear of falling behind
39:09 Why hitting in the big leagues has gotten harder
46:12 Parents living through their sons' success
52:06 Winning at what cost?
54:20 What actual player development looks like
58:45 Why there's no single path to the majors
1:02:55 When parents want it more than their sons
1:04:46 When should your son start driving his baseball future?
🎙️ Host: Bobby Minor
⚾ Guests: Kevin Pillar & Cody Allen, former MLB players and hosts of the To the Majors podcast
🎧 Chasing Baseball Dreams Podcast
Subscribe on YouTube, Spotify, or Apple Podcasts for more conversations with former Major Leaguers, college coaches, and baseball people who can help you make better decisions for your son.