Episodes

  • Nancy Guthrie Follow Up- Cold Red: Mailbag
    Nov 5 2026

    The Cold Red Mailbag is OPEN! Join former FBI profiler James R. Fitzgerald (Fitz) and Ray Carr as they answer YOUR questions about the Nancy Guthrie kidnapping investigation, forensic evidence, suspicious ransom messages, and more. Was Nancy Guthrie originally targeted for a robbery? Could the phrase "buried in nature" hold a deeper meaning? And what can investigators learn from DNA evidence, jailhouse informants, and behavioral analysis? In today's LIVE episode, Fitz and Ray break down viewer theories, examine investigative possibilities, and separate speculation from evidence. *Topics include:*

    • Nancy Guthrie: Robbery gone wrong or planned kidnapping?
    • DNA evidence and the investigation
    • The mysterious "buried in nature" phrase
    • Possible connections to the 1989 Hearin kidnapping
    • Forensic evidence and investigative procedures
    • The O.J. Simpson glove controversy
    • LIVE questions from the Cold Red community

    *YOUR QUESTIONS. THEIR EXPERT ANALYSIS.* Join the conversation in the live chat! Submit your questions, share your theories, and hear Fitz and Ray respond in real time. 🔴 *Subscribe to Cold Red* for expert criminal profiling, forensic analysis, and in-depth discussions of today's biggest criminal investigations. 🌐 Visit: https://coldredpodcast.com #NancyGuthrie #ColdRedPodcast #TrueCrime #JamesFitzgerald #FBIProfiler #CriminalInvestigation #TrueCrimeCommunity

    Show More Show Less
    42 mins
  • Defending the Killer Clown: Death Row and the Mind of John Wayne Gacy
    Nov 6 2026

    What is it like to defend one of America's most notorious serial killers? In this episode of *Cold Red**, former FBI profiler **Raymond J. Carr* and former FBI forensic linguist *James R. Fitzgerald (Fitz)* sit down with high-profile trial attorney and author **Karen Conti**, who represented convicted serial killer John Wayne Gacy during his final death row appeals. With nearly four decades of legal experience, Conti offers a rare, firsthand perspective on her interactions with Gacy, his behavior behind closed doors, and the psychological challenges of defending a man responsible for horrific crimes. Drawing from her book *Killing Time With John Wayne Gacy*, Conti discusses Gacy's manipulation tactics, his ability to compartmentalize his actions, and the complexities of representing someone facing execution. Ray and Fitz bring their expertise in behavioral profiling and forensic linguistics to the conversation, examining how Gacy's words, behavior, and psychological patterns compare with what investigators know about serial predators. *In this episode:*

    • What John Wayne Gacy was really like behind closed doors.
    • The manipulation tactics and psychological behaviors Conti witnessed firsthand.
    • Whether Gacy ever demonstrated genuine remorse.
    • How attorneys mentally navigate defending notorious killers.
    • The intersection of criminal defense, FBI behavioral profiling, and forensic linguistics.
    • The role of behavioral evidence in high-profile criminal trials.
    • How media coverage influences public perception and the pursuit of justice.

    *Can you defend someone's constitutional rights without defending their crimes? And what can a defense attorney learn about a serial killer that investigators may never see?* Join Ray, Fitz, and Karen Conti for a compelling examination of criminal psychology, the justice system, and the disturbing reality of working face-to-face with one of America's most infamous killers. 📖 *Featured Book:* Killing Time With John Wayne Gacy by Karen Conti 🔴 *JOIN THE COLD RED COMMUNITY* Subscribe for expert analysis of true crime investigations, criminal behavior, forensic linguistics, and the stories behind some of the most complex cases. 🌐 Visit our website: https://coldredpodcast.com 💬 *JOIN THE CONVERSATION* Do you believe every criminal defendant deserves the strongest possible legal defense, regardless of the crime? Share your thoughts in the comments. 👍 Like this episode if you appreciate expert-driven true crime analysis. 🔔 Subscribe and turn on notifications so you never miss an episode of Cold Red. *#JohnWayneGacy #KarenConti #ColdRedPodcast #TrueCrime #FBIProfiler #SerialKillers #CriminalPsychology #ForensicLinguistics*

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 4 mins
  • Did secret CIA mind-control experiments help shape one of America's most notorious domestic terrorists?
    Nov 11 2026

    n this Veterans Day special of Cold Red, former FBI profiler James R. Fitzgerald (Fitz) and Ray Carr explore the disturbing history of MK-ULTRA, government-funded psychological experimentation, and the controversial Harvard studies involving Ted Kaczynski, better known as the Unabomber.

    Joining the conversation are active-duty U.S. Navy member and criminal justice researcher Kayla Draggoo and Navy veteran Luke J. Braden.

    Together, they examine declassified CIA programs, the psychological consequences of coercive experimentation, and the potential connections between Kaczynski's early experiences at Harvard and his eventual campaign of violence.

    IN THIS EPISODE:

    🇺🇸 HONORING OUR VETERANS A Veterans Day tribute to America's service members, featuring firsthand perspectives on military discipline, sacrifice, resilience, and the transition to civilian life.

    MK-ULTRA: THE CIA'S SECRET EXPERIMENTS An examination of Projects BLUEBIRD, ARTICHOKE, and MK-ULTRA, including LSD experimentation, psychological manipulation, and research conducted without informed consent.

    THE UNABOMBER'S HARVARD CONNECTION At just 16 years old, Ted Kaczynski participated in controversial psychological experiments at Harvard University. Could those experiences have influenced his later hatred of technology, academia, and institutional authority?

    PROFILING THE UNABOMBER Fitz examines Kaczynski's manifesto through forensic linguistics, exploring the relationship between psychological trauma, ideological extremism, and violent behavior.

    THE LEGACY OF GOVERNMENT MIND CONTROL What did the CIA actually accomplish through MK-ULTRA? Did these experiments produce controllable individuals, or did they leave behind a legacy of psychological harm and unanswered questions?

    THE BIG QUESTION: Was Ted Kaczynski's path to violence influenced by psychological experimentation, or were other factors responsible?

    Join the conversation and share your thoughts in the comments.

    This episode examines documented historical programs alongside disputed theories about their possible influence on Kaczynski. Participation in the Harvard experiments does not establish that he was an MK-ULTRA subject or that the CIA caused his later crimes.

    👍 LIKE if you enjoy in-depth criminal investigations and behavioral analysis.

    🔔 SUBSCRIBE to Cold Red for expert FBI profiling, forensic psychology, and investigations into some of history's most disturbing cases.

    🌐 Visit: https://coldredpodcast.com

    #MKULTRA #Unabomber #TedKaczynski #CIA #ColdRedPodcast #JamesFitzgerald #VeteransDay #TrueCrime #FBIProfiler

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 7 mins
  • On the Edge of the Ice: CTE, Concussions, and Survival with Brian Propp
    Oct 23 2026

    What happens when the hits stop, but the damage remains?

    In this powerful episode of Cold Red, hosts Ray Carr and Fitz sit down with five-time NHL All-Star Brian Propp to explore the hidden consequences of professional hockey, repeated head trauma, and the long-term neurological effects that can follow athletes long after retirement.

    With more than 1,000 career points, five Stanley Cup Finals appearances, and 15 seasons in the NHL, Propp experienced hockey during an era when toughness was everything and playing through injuries was simply part of the game.

    From the infamous 1989 playoff hit by Chris Chelios to surviving a life-altering stroke in 2015, Propp shares his remarkable journey through injury, recovery, rehabilitation, and survival.

    Building on their recent conversation with renowned neurosurgeon Dr. Philip Stieg, Ray and Fitz examine the science behind Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE) and Traumatic Encephalopathy Syndrome (TES), exploring how repetitive brain trauma may affect memory, personality, emotional regulation, and behavior.

    The conversation goes beyond professional sports, examining a fascinating intersection of neuroscience, behavioral analysis, and forensic linguistics: Can brain injuries change the way someone thinks, speaks, or behaves—and how do we recognize the difference between neurological damage and intentional behavior?

    It's an eye-opening conversation about the price of greatness, the hidden battles athletes face, and the resilience required to rebuild a life after devastating neurological injury.

    Subscribe to Cold Red on Apple Podcasts and follow us on social media for more conversations exploring criminal behavior, forensic science, neuroscience, and the human stories behind the headlines.

    Visit coldredpodcast.com for more.

    Stay safe and be aware of your surroundings. It just might save your life.

    Show More Show Less
    59 mins
  • Behind the Badge & Beyond the Case: Chief David Splain
    Oct 17 2026

    Behind the Badge & Beyond the Case: Chief David Splain | Cold Red 1118

    What happens when the realities of small-town policing meet the complexities of true crime? On this episode of Cold Red, Ray Carr and Fitz sit down with Chief David Splain of the Nether Providence Township Police Department to explore decades of law enforcement experience, historical homicide investigations, and his transition from police leadership to true crime author.

    Chief Splain discusses his books, Blood on the Trolley and Secrets From the Closet, offering insight into the investigative details, hidden truths, and human stories behind real cases. Together, Ray and Fitz examine the unique challenges of investigating crimes in close-knit communities, why some cold cases remain unsolved for decades, and how behavioral profiling, forensic linguistics, and modern forensic technology can help uncover new leads.

    Plus, the team tackles audience questions about protecting victims' families, avoiding critical mistakes during the first 48 hours of an investigation, and the evolving role of investigative genetic genealogy in cold cases.

    Subscribe to Cold Red for more expert analysis, real-world investigations, and the psychology behind the cases that continue to raise questions.

    Visit coldredpodcast.com for the blog and follow Cold Red on social media.

    Stay safe, stay aware, and remember: it just might save your life.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr
  • The Biological Toll: CTE, Violence, and the Brain with Dr. Philip Stieg
    Oct 20 2026

    Can repeated head trauma change a person's behavior, destroy impulse control, or even contribute to violent actions?

    In this episode of Cold Red, retired FBI agents Raymond Carr and James Fitzgerald sit down with renowned neurosurgeon, NFL consultant, and CTE researcher Dr. Philip Stieg to explore the disturbing relationship between Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE), brain damage, aggression, and violent behavior.

    From professional football players to individuals with a history of repetitive head injuries, Dr. Stieg breaks down what science reveals about the long-term consequences of brain trauma—and what researchers still don't know.

    Together, Ray, Fitz, and Dr. Stieg examine how damage to the frontal and temporal lobes may affect emotional regulation, decision-making, and impulse control. They also explore a critical question for criminal investigators: How do you distinguish calculated criminal behavior from actions potentially influenced by neurological deterioration?

    In this episode:

    • What CTE actually does to the brain and its four proposed stages

    • The potential connection between repeated head injuries, aggression, and impulsive behavior

    • Why some individuals experience personality changes while others develop cognitive decline

    • How brain trauma can complicate FBI behavioral analysis and criminal investigations

    • Whether neurological damage can influence speech, deception, and interrogation strategies

    • The limitations of current CTE research and the challenges of diagnosing the condition

    • How substance abuse, performance-enhancing drugs, and psychological stress may complicate the picture

    • Could brain scans eventually play a role in determining criminal responsibility?

    Can brain damage help explain violent behavior—or are we at risk of confusing correlation with causation?

    Join Ray, Fitz, and Dr. Stieg for a fascinating discussion at the intersection of neuroscience, forensic psychology, and criminal behavior.

    🔴 SUBSCRIBE TO COLD RED for expert criminal analysis, true crime investigations, and exclusive conversations with leading experts in law enforcement, medicine, and forensic science.

    🌐 Visit our website: https://coldredpodcast.com

    💬 JOIN THE CONVERSATION: Do you believe a history of serious brain trauma should influence how violent offenders are evaluated in the criminal justice system? Share your thoughts in the comments.

    #ColdRedPodcast #CTE #BrainInjury #TrueCrime #Neuroscience #FBI #JamesFitzgerald #PhilipStieg #CriminalPsychology #ForensicScience

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 1 min
  • New Evidence in the Zodiac Killer Case? Researchers Analyze “Subject X”
    Sep 25 2026

    Could new forensic research point investigators toward a previously overlooked Zodiac suspect? Ray Carr and Jim “Fitz” Fitzgerald sit down with researchers Chad and Kylie to examine newly acquired research surrounding the Zodiac Killer case and an individual referred to as “Subject X.” The discussion explores the Zodiac’s known crimes, behavioral profile, cryptic communications, and the linguistic patterns found in the killer’s letters. Fitz examines the case through the lens of forensic linguistics and questioned authorship, including contraction rates, British phrasing, word choice, misspellings, and other structural patterns. The researchers also present potential connections involving handwriting characteristics, blue felt-tip pen usage, schematic drawings, and distinctive phrases found in the Zodiac communications. What would it take to move this research from theory to evidence? Ray and Fitz discuss the additional forensic testing that could help confirm or eliminate “Subject X,” including archival fingerprints, travel records, and genealogical DNA. **Cold Red Podcast** brings true crime through the eyes of former FBI agents, examining behavioral analysis, forensic evidence, investigative procedure, and the questions that remain unanswered. Subscribe to Cold Red Podcast and visit coldredpodcast.com for more. #ColdRed #ZodiacKiller #Zodiac #TrueCrime #ColdCase #FBI #ForensicLinguistics #CriminalProfiling #UnsolvedMystery #ForensicAnalysis

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 17 mins
  • 4 Cases, MAJOR New Twists | Cornell 7, Gypsy Rose, Nolan Wells & Kratom Deaths
    Oct 9 2026

    Four major true crime stories. New legal battles, disturbing allegations, and serious questions about how investigations are handled.

    On this episode of Cold Red Podcast, retired FBI agents Raymond J. Carr and James R. Fitzgerald break down four developing stories, examining the evidence, investigative procedures, behavioral patterns, and legal consequences.

    🔴 THE CORNELL 7 INVESTIGATION A major shift in a high-profile sexual assault investigation raises questions about local prosecutors, state intervention, and whether the case was properly handled. What happens when higher authorities take control?

    🔴 "GAS STATION HEROIN" — THE KRATOM CRISIS Deadly synthetic kratom derivatives are raising alarms across the country. From a college student's fatal overdose in Mississippi to reported deaths in Utah, Ray and Fitz examine the dangers of unregulated substances and potential criminal accountability.

    🔴 GYPSY ROSE BLANCHARD — FACTS VS. INTERNET SPECULATION Online rumors and allegations surrounding Gypsy Rose Blanchard and Ken Urker highlight the dangers of social media investigations. Fitz explores confirmation bias, digital behavior, and why speculation should never replace forensic evidence.

    🔴 NOLAN WELLS — FEDERAL INVESTIGATION & TERRELL OWENS LAWSUIT The Nolan Wells case continues to raise questions about accountability and justice. The family seeks federal intervention following a grand jury decision, while a defamation dispute involving NFL Hall of Famer Terrell Owens adds another legal dimension.

    Four stories. Four complicated investigations. What does the evidence actually tell us?

    Join Ray and Fitz as they separate facts from speculation and explain how experienced federal investigators approach these cases.

    🔔 SUBSCRIBE for expert FBI analysis, criminal profiling, and true crime investigations.

    🌐 Visit: https://coldredpodcast.com

    💬 LET US KNOW IN THE COMMENTS: Which of these four stories deserves a deeper investigation?

    #ColdRedPodcast #TrueCrime #FBI #GypsyRoseBlanchard #NolanWells #Cornell7 #Kratom #CriminalProfiling #JamesRFitzgerald #RaymondCarr

    Show More Show Less
    51 mins