Episodes

  • 128 | Branden Banfield | The Au Pair Affair

    128 | Branden Banfield | The Au Pair Affair
    Jul 9 2026
    The three mustaches tackle a spicy and sensational case that has all of our favorite things, and more. In 2023, a bizarre home invasion gone wrong in Herndon, Virginia resulted in the deaths of both the victim, and the alleged perpetrator. But, as detectives started trying to make sense of the senseless crime, it began to look as though the victim may have inadvertently orchestrated their own murder. Now it was up to the investigators to determine whether this really was a random act of violence, or one of the most brilliant murder plots they had ever seen. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
    Show More Show Less
    2 hrs and 16 mins
  • 127 | Susan Monica | Like Lipstick on a Pig... Farmer

    127 | Susan Monica | Like Lipstick on a Pig... Farmer
    Jul 2 2026
    The three mustaches head to rural Oregon to help track down a guy named Robert Haney. According to his enchantingly beautiful landlord / employer, Susan Monica, he went hog wild a few months ago and she hasn't seen him since. Robert's son, on the other hand, thinks Susan knows exactly where his father is and she's just being pig-headed about it. All we know for sure is wherever Robert went, he's definitely not living high on the hog without his EBT card. Brace yourselves for this one because this tale has more twists than a pig's tail. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 34 mins
  • 125 | Joyce McKinney | The Manacled Mormon Part One

    125 | Joyce McKinney | The Manacled Mormon Part One
    Jun 29 2026
    The three mustaches head to jolly old England to cover the controversial case of the Manacled Mormon. In 1977, an American missionary named Kirk Anderson vanished from a Latter-day Saints church in Surrey, England. Three days later, he returned with a chilling tale involving chloroform, bondage, and a blonde bombshell named Joyce McKinney. But, according to Joyce, it wasn't an abduction, it was a honeymoon. So was it a multi-day sex-fest between two consenting adults, or a felony kidnapping served with a side of sexual assault? You'll have to listen to find out. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 38 mins
  • 126 | Joyce McKinney | The Manacled Mormon Part Two

    126 | Joyce McKinney | The Manacled Mormon Part Two
    Jun 25 2026
    The three mustaches reconvene to finish the scandalous tale of Joyce McKinney and the Manacled Mormon. When we last left off, Joyce and her friend-zoned lackey, Keith May, had just been arrested for the abduction and assault of a Mormon missionary named Kirk Anderson. What started as a shocking headline soon exploded into a worldwide media hurricane with Joyce at the center. Now hang on tight as we take you on the rollercoaster ride that Joyce McKinney called life. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 44 mins
  • 124 | Timothy Molnar | Into the Waukesha

    124 | Timothy Molnar | Into the Waukesha
    Jun 11 2026
    The OG mustaches are joined by their new producer, Bluke, to discuss the mysterious disappearance of Timothy Molnar. In 1984, Tim left his home in Daytona Beach, Florida, to attend classes at Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University. But, before he could reach the school, he vanished into thin air. Was his disappearance the result of foul play, or did Tim just need to blow off some steam? And how the hell do you pronounce 'Wisconsin'? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 14 mins
  • 123 | Helle Crafts | Body Parts and Crafts

    123 | Helle Crafts | Body Parts and Crafts
    Jun 4 2026
    The three mustaches convene for one last episode in Texas before moving to their new studio. To mark the occasion, they have chosen an exceptionally "chilling" case. In 1986, a flight attendant named Helle Crafts failed to show up for her scheduled shift. According to her husband, Richard, she had made a last minute trip to Denmark to visit her mother. Or maybe she went to the Canary Islands with a friend. It's hard to tell because Richard can't seem to keep his story straight. Wherever she went, I'm sure she's fine. It's not like she fell into a wood chipper or something... right? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 27 mins
  • 122 | The Evidence Locker | Smiley Face Killer

    122 | The Evidence Locker | Smiley Face Killer
    May 28 2026
    The mustache mafia is setting up shop in a new studio in North Carolina! To give them time to finish decorating the new studio -- and bury the bodies of the previous tenants -- we present to you an episode pulled from the darkest depths of the Evidence Locker. Between 1990 and 2010, the remains of at least 45 young men have been found in or near bodies of water in the Midwest. Near each alleged victim, investigators discovered graffiti depicting a smiley face. Was the presence of the grinning image simply a coincidence, or the calling card of one of the most prolific serial killers in US history? The answer may surprise you... Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 42 mins
  • 121 | Kathy Middleton | Butterfingers in Blue Springs

    121 | Kathy Middleton | Butterfingers in Blue Springs
    May 21 2026
    The three mustaches tackle a controversial case from Blue Springs, Missouri involving a highly suspicious accident. On a sunny afternoon in February of 1990, a single gunshot rang out from the home of Ken and Kathy Middleton. When first responders arrived, they found Kathy dead from a single gunshot wound to the head. According to Ken, her tragic death was the result of a freak accident, but investigators were suspicious of his story. So, did Kathy die from a terminal case of butterfingers, or was she murdered? Well, that depends on who you ask... Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 36 mins