• Episode IX: The Hitcher
    Oct 30 2026

    The crew hits the road with the 1986 thriller The Hitcher. We start with a weird birdwalk about San Diego local musician Steve Poltz, his band The Rugburns, Java Joe's and their song "Don't Pick Up Hitchhiker Joe." Then we swap hitchhiking stories and talk about how attitudes toward thumbing a ride have changed. Next we get into the movie, our patented world's most okayiest plot summary, and a bunch of weird observations about this movie, especially about geography and the best way to drive from Chicago to San Diego. Then the dice come out for a long D&D chase and battle inspired by the film. After that we give The Hitcher our patented D20 rating, talk about Rutger Hauer's best roles and villains and name the Play of the Game.

    We're finishing spooky season with Hotel Transylvania! Also some random thoughts about Wildwood and Genndy Tartakovsky. Happy Halloween and see you then!

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 21 mins
  • Episode VIII - Inland Empire
    Oct 22 2026

    This time we take on David Lynch's Inland Empire, his three-hour digital-video fever dream. We start with first reactions, then get into the big question: does the film mean anything, or is that the wrong thing to ask of Lynch? After a spoiler summary of Nikki Grace's splintering identity and the Phantom, we talk about what worked, why so much of it still drags, and who this movie is really for. We also place it in Lynch's wider career: the move to digital video, his recurring themes, and whether it counts as horror. Then we give our final verdicts and suggest what to watch instead.

    In the second half, the tabletop segment goes to a surreal Lynch-inspired battle map. There's dancing, initiative rolls and a shredded Phantom, Robert Blake shows up to make things weirder, and Bob from Twin Peaks arrives as the final boss before a finishing elbow drop. We wrap up with ratings, MVPs and the roll for our next movie.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 46 mins
  • Episode VII: Mother Joan of the Angels
    Oct 14 2026

    This week the crew takes on an obscure possession film, the story of Mother Joan of the Angels and a convent overtaken by demons. We ask whether the film told the wrong story, compared to Aldous Huxley's account and the much stranger true events behind it. We also get into whether horror needs characters you can root for, the film's minimalist style, and how it treats possession, patriarchy, repression and eroticism. Plus, why older horror shocks can feel muted today. Then we roll dice in a D&D encounter set inside the possessed convent. The party tries to win Mother Joan over, fights through psychic attacks and works out what is really causing the possession. We wrap up with film ratings, our favorite side characters and the roll for next week's movie.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 31 mins
  • Episode VI - All About Eve
    Sep 30 2026

    This episode is all about... er... All About Eve. What a script! Wait, is that Shere Khan? The world's most okay-iest full spoiler recap and questions about the plot. The fear of aging and reality of age gap relationships for women. Does All About Eve deserve a higher spot on the AFI Top 100 list? (The various movies in the AFI top 25 we hate) In the second half, it's Dungeons and Drive-Ins battle time: Eve goes from pawn to queen, Batman villains?, Eve can't stop grabbing Roy's butt. We wrap with movie ratings, our Midge award, and a roll for next episode's movie pick. Letterboxd was having some problems but we THINK we foudn the right movie-- the first of our spooky season picks for the next month!

    Check out Roy (and Brooke... and Andy in 2 weeks) on the newest Yours, Mine, and Theirs podcast; mourning dearly departed stars on In Memoriam (sometimes featuring Andy); and 70s tv crossovers on the Fantasy-Murder-Love Triangle podcast.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 37 mins
  • Episode V: Chocolat
    Sep 20 2026
    In this episode, Brooke picks the 2000 Lasse Hallström film 'Chocolat' — and makes the case for why it works. We dig into Johnny Depp's turn, the ensemble's strength, and the movie's themes of tolerance and temptation, run through a rapid plot recap, and unpack what makes the film feel so sensual, romantic, and distinctive. We also put it in awards context, revisiting the era of adult studio dramedies, before landing on our final takeaways about the movie's humanity. Then it's back to the dungeon: a feast with magical food buffs sets up a riverboat flirtation challenge with Josephine, followed by a burning boat rescue mission that spirals into a villain reveal and combat on the river. The Count is pacified, the fire contained, and the scenario resolved — capped off with ratings, an MVP debate, next movie pick, and a playful farewell.
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 45 mins
  • Episode IV: Chaplin's Gold Rush — and a Survival Showdown in the Cabin
    Sep 13 2026
    We dig into Charlie Chaplin's The Gold Rush — why it still matters, its most iconic scenes, and Chaplin's blend of comedy and emotional power — before dropping our characters into the film's world for a survival challenge: a blizzard search, a cabin battle, a ghost fight gone wrong, and a final showdown with Black Larson on the cliff's edge. We close with movie ratings, a best-supporting-character debate, and settle on Chocolat as the next watch.
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 26 mins
  • Episode III: Love, Simon and the Henry Rollins/Channing Tatum karaoke showdown
    Sep 3 2026

    This week we put Love, Simon on the table — why it works so well as a glossy YA studio crowd-pleaser, where its more manufactured conflicts wobble, and how the movie lands now when it comes to coming out, parenting, and emotional universality. We recap the plot, argue over what still hits, reminisce over the Greg Berlanti CW Arrowverse, ask the all-timer question of what it would look like if straight people had to come out, and hand out final scores plus best supporting element. Then the RPG chaos kicks in: a Halloween-party infiltration, a beer pong hustle, a mission to steal Martin’s phone, and a magical attempt to give Simon his agency back through karaoke, honesty, and confession. We close with the dice choosing the AFI Top 100 and finally landing on "The Gold Rush," and a nod to Andy's love of Hitchcock's "The Lodger."

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 1 min
  • Episode II: Amores Perros and an Intersection... of Nat 20s!
    Aug 26 2026
    In this episode we dig into Alejandro González Iñárritu's Amores Perros — why it's so hard to watch, how its three intertwined stories fit together, and what makes it powerful despite being upsetting. Content/Trigger Warning: Dog death, violence/harm against animals. We talk love, dogs, unsafe attachments, emotional boundaries, standout characters, and hand out our ratings. Then we roll into the tabletop side of the show: a dungeon adventure kicking off at a crash site, a daring rescue of Valeria from a burning car, a trapdoor twist that drops the party into a fight with rats and a wererat, Karloff's transformation turning the tide, and a loot haul that closes with the reveal of our next movie.
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr