Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months
₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
EP 34. "Breaking down the Right to Substitute"
Failed to add items
Add to cart failed.
Add to wishlist failed.
Remove from wishlist failed.
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
-
Narrated by:
-
Written by:
Dive deep into the world of the right to substitute so you know you’re navigating the clause correctly.
In this episode, Dan Richards (Deputy Chief Executive) and Darryl Oung share essential insights on the right to substitute. Darryl has supported businesses engaging with self-employed workers for over ten years, making him the perfect expert alongside Dan, who has worked alongside logistics businesses for six years.
We talk about the key frameworks behind a compliant right to substitute.
You’ll learn:
✨ Contracts vs. reality on the ground - Having a contract in place is essential, but if it doesn’t match daily operations, HMRC can argue it’s a “paper clause”
✨ Unfettered substitution - How to navigate substitution rights in line with UK regulations and industry compliance rules (like CSCS cards and CPC checks)
✨ The money trail - The correct invoicing and payment structures to use when a subcontractor sends a substitute
Find more podcast events & resources: https://www.withwise.com/talking
🔗 Connect with our guests:
Dan Richards
https://www.linkedin.com/in/d-richards/
Darryl Oung
https://www.linkedin.com/in/darryl-oung-4b07341a/
⏱️ Chapters:
0:00 Teaser
1:08 Introduction
2:20 Paper clause vs genuine operational substitution
5:08 Why written substitution clauses fail HMRC challenges and how personal service is tested
14:55 What is an unfettered right of substitution under UK tax law?
17:48 Can a main contractor reject a subcontractor’s substitute for lacking a CSCS card?
19:53 Does requiring a subcontractor to have set qualifications such as CPC or site safety inductions invalidate a substitution clause?
20:58 How can logistics companies enforce driver vetting without breaking self-employment?
22:05 Who is legally required to pay a substitute worker - the client or the subcontractor?
29:25 Does direct payment to a substitute driver trigger an employment relationship?
32:24 How should invoicing be structured when a self-employed subbie uses a substitute?
33:15 Why commercial liability for a substitute worker proves self-employed status
33:53 The money trail: yes or no quick-fire questions