Julie Hare and Ant Bagshaw take on university governance. In the past year it has drawn state parliamentary inquiries, an ICAC investigation, a federal expert council and a merger between the chancellors and Universities Australia. Jason Clare says that if you don’t see a problem, you’ve been living under a rock. So how big is the rock? Julie calls it a crisis and asks why it’s happening now. Ant thinks the rules are mostly fine, and that the real problem is how people behave and use power.
They start with who ends up on councils and how they get there. That means small talent pools, recruitment at Christmas parties, and the question of whether chancellors fill councils with their mates. Elected staff and student members get a seat at the table but often no real say, and appointed members too often treat challenge as disloyalty.
Next they look at what might fix it. The expert council’s principles are sound, but there’s a gap between those principles and what happens in the room. The NSW inquiry led by Sarah Kaine went further, proposing an independent council secretariat answerable to the minister. Ant was a student member of the Council at Cambridge; he has doubts that a council with a majority of staff and students would solve anything.
Finally, the University Chancellors Council is joining Universities Australia. That brings two tribes and a lot of egos together, and Julie can’t find her optimistic hat. Ant’s verdict is that governance has a chronic condition rather than an acute crisis, and the cure is reconnecting universities with their public purpose.
Recorded at Australian Parliament House, thanks to InnovationAus.
Support the show