• Lisa's Pony with Floryn and Alex Honnet
    Oct 15 2026

    We've got a great episode for you today- a nice palate cleanser in between 2 Treehouse of Horrors!

    Today we're reviewing Season 3 Episode 8 of The Simpsons, "Lisa's Pony". Our guests are super-siblings Floryn and Alex Honnet. We talk about watching tv with siblings, the art of Winsor McCay, and the salacious rumors surrounding character actor Wally Cox.

    You can follow this show on Instagram at Bartannicapod.

    Eli Recommends: The White Album by The Beatles

    Harrison Recommends: Looking up facts about Wally Cox and/or Marlon Brando

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 23 mins
  • Treehouse of Horror V with Sunset Appleton
    Oct 1 2026

    Harrison is joined by returning guest Sunset Appleton (in costume!) to review our first Treehouse of Horror episode! Today we are discussing Season 6 Episode 6, "Treehouse of Horror V"- The Shinning, Time and Punishment, and Nightmare Cafeteria. We discuss the differences between The Shining book vs the movie, the infamous "non-Brazilian" joke, and why this episode is so much gorier than previous TOHs.

    Follow Sunset at complexpastiche on Instagram.

    Follow this show at bartannicapod on Instagram as well.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 7 mins
  • The Front with Joe McAdam
    Sep 17 2026

    This week we're talking about The Simpsons episode from Season 4, Episode 19 "The Front"- Bart and Lisa write an episode of Itchy and Scratchy, while Homer and Marge attend their high school reunion.

    We're joined by the hilarious Joe McAdam (BUTT, Golden Axe). We discuss our personal "I am not a crackpot" theories, Elvis shooting things, and our new favorite tv show, "The Hat Squad".

    Follow Joe on instagram.com @joemcadam and joemcadam on BlueSky.

    Follow this show at BartannicaPod.

    Joe Recommends Romy and Michele's High School Reunion Party Down ("James Rolf High School Twentieth Reunion")

    Eli Recommends "For Everyone" album by Joe Vans

    Harrison Recommends "Chuck Amok" by Chuck Jones Golden Axe on Paramount Plus!

    Butt Sketches

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 34 mins
  • Deep Space Homer with Nick Mestad
    Sep 5 2026

    Today we're reviewing the classic Simpsons episode, "Deep Space Homer" from Season 5, episode 15 with guest Nick Mestad. We talk about our favorite astronaut movies, ticker tape parades, and if we think this episode is too wacky to be a Simpsons episode.

    Please follow Nick on Instagram & TikTok: @nick-mestad

    Follow this show @bartannicapod on Instagram.

    Nick Recommends The Right Stuff (book and movie)

    Eli Recommends Deep Space Nine

    Harrison Recommends Capricorn One Packing for Mars by Mary Roach

    A Marionette at the Club NickandEliComedy

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 19 mins
  • Lisa The Skeptic with Adam Nayman
    Aug 20 2026

    Today we've got a great episode with an even better guest; we are reviewing Season 9 Episode 8 of The Simpsons, "Lisa the Skeptic"; this is the episode where Lisa finds an angel skeleton!

    We're joined by film critic and author Adam Nayman (The Ringer). We discuss the episode's views on science vs. religion, Operation F.I.S.T., and if this episode is VERY Lisa-esque, or completely non-Lisa.

    Follow Adam on Twitter @brofromanother and follow this show @bartannicapod on Instagram.

    Adam Recommends John Carpenter's Cigarette Burns Eli Recommends It's a Wonderful Life

    Harrison Recommends The Coen Brothers: This Book Really Ties the Films Together by Adam Nayman!

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 17 mins
  • Lisa's Substitute with Tim Latterner
    Aug 6 2026

    This week we're reviewing Season 2 Episode 19 of The Simpsons, "Lisa's Substitute" with guest Tim Latterner (The Bowery Review). We talk about James L. Brooks' influence on the episode, our favorite sci-fi authors, and Dustin Hoffman.

    You can follow Tim @timlatterner and @theboweryreview

    You can follow this show @bartannicapod on Instagram.

    Tim Recommends Broadcast News

    Eli Recommends Whistlestop Podcast

    Harrison Recommends Charlotte's Web

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 10 mins
  • Homer at the Bat with Rick Katschke
    Jul 24 2026

    This week we're reviewing Episode 17 of Season 3 of The Simpsons, "Homer at the Bat" with guest Rick Katschke (Catered Quiz, Pop Culture Jeopardy). We discuss his appearance on Jeopardy, his own trivia podcast, and our varying levels of baseball fandom.

    Follow Rick at TheCateredQuiz on Instagram, Hostandguest on Twitter.

    You can follow this show at bartannicapod on Instagram.

    Rick Recommends Battered Bastards of Baseball Catcher in the Wry

    Eli Recommends Baseball by Ken Burns

    Harrison Recommends The Bash Brothers by The Lonely Island

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 19 mins
  • Boy-Soutz 'n the Hood with Ariel Dumas and Jay Katsir
    Jul 9 2026

    To celebrate our podcast's 1 year anniversary we have a great episode with not 1 but 2 amazing guests. Jay Katsir and Ariel Dumas are the former head writers for The Late Show with Stephen Colbert. They are both lifelong Simpsons freaks and we talk about their love of the show while reviewing Season 5 Episode 8 "Boy-Scoutz 'n the Hood". We discuss the final week of The Late Show, ancient maritime poetry and Ariel's time as a wild child in Girl Scouts.

    Follow our guests at @arieldumasarieldumas & @akatsir on IG and @arieldumas on twitter.

    You can follow this show @bartannicapod on Instagram.

    Ariel and Jay Recommend On the Town

    Harrison Recommends Modern Manhood and the Boy Scouts of America: Citizenship, Race, and the Environment by Benjamin Jordan The River Wild

    Eli Recommends Banjoist Pete Seeger

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 20 mins