Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months
₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
Episode 34 - Maid in Manhattan - 'Not Rich Kids' Discuss
Failed to add items
Add to cart failed.
Add to wishlist failed.
Remove from wishlist failed.
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
-
Narrated by:
-
Written by:
FOLLOW US:
Not a Rich Kid - Instagram
Maid in Manhattan: Class Fantasy, Labels, and Rom-Com Chemistry
The Not a Rich Kid Discuss team reviews Maid in Manhattan (directed by Wayne Wang; story credited to John Hughes under a pseudonym; written by Kevin Wade). They recap the plot: J.Lo plays Marisa, a single mother and hotel maid mistaken for a wealthy guest when she tries on a Dolce & Gabbana coat, sparking a romance with Republican New York State senate candidate Chris (Ralph Fiennes). The conversation focuses on class mobility, early-2000s label worship, working-class tropes, and how the film functions as a Cinderella fantasy while still giving Marisa career agency by becoming a manager. They debate casting and lack of chemistry, note dated elements (music, paparazzi, a harassment gag), criticize the precocious kid and Marisa’s passivity, and compare the film to Pretty Woman and Working Girl.
00:00 Welcome and Setup
01:10 Cast and Credits Rundown
02:08 Plot in a Nutshell
02:50 Can a Coat Change Class
04:00 First Reactions and Laughs
05:28 Working Girl and Class Fantasy
09:53 Family Pressure and Mobility
12:36 Does the Romance Work
13:17 Ralph Fiennes Casting Debate
16:32 Bronx Real Talk Moment
18:49 Romcom Expectations Clash
20:02 Cinderella Fantasy Reading
20:25 Agency Ending vs Pretty Woman
20:58 Dog Leash Rant
22:24 2002 Jokes Aging Badly
24:15 Passive Protagonist Problem
24:58 Chemistry and Casting Debate
26:20 Class and Rich Villains
27:26 Ratings and Final Verdicts
31:54 JLo Praise and Realism
34:07 Wrap Up and Sign Off
Get in touch:
Are you a working class person who wants to pursue a creative career but don't know where to start? Get in touch via instagram - we'd be happy to give you some advice.
Tell us who you would like to hear from. Is there someone we should invite on the podcast? Let us know!
The Not a Rich Kid Team:
- Kath Dolheguy
- Frankie Kanatas
- Sarah Ryan-Linstrom
Post audio - Mike Tillbrook
Theme song:
‘Barry Michael Takes a Train’ by Sand Pebbles - Written & performed by Ben Michael and performed and mixed by Murray Ono Jamieson.
Not a Rich Kid would not be possible without the support of:
- VCA who provided studio space
- City of Melbourne Arts Grants
Supported by the City of Melbourne Arts Grants