Thanksgiving weekend, 1972. Greg Nickell was 21, home in Vernal, Utah, after thirteen months in Vietnam. He'd broken a date that Saturday night so his sister's friend, visiting from Idaho, wouldn't be left out. After a dance, the two of them drove out to the scenic overlook on U.S. 40, west of town, to see the valley. A man came to the window and said he needed help.
Greg said sure.
By dawn on Sunday, an 18-year-old girl was running down the highway toward a farmhouse near Duchesne, on the far side of the Uinta Basin. What she told the sheriff that morning set off what the hometown paper called probably the largest manhunt ever organized in the Basin. It came up empty.
Twenty years later, a man was arrested for the killing, and a DNA test showed he wasn't one of the two men. Fifty-two years later, to the day, another man was arrested. He has pleaded not guilty, and as of November 2026 his case is still waiting for a trial.
This is Carving Season: all November long, Forgotten True Crime is telling the stories of crimes that happened around Thanksgiving. So when you sit down at the table with the family this year, be careful what you say at dinner.
CONTENT WARNING: This episode includes a killing with a gun, a body that was burned, and the kidnapping and sexual assault of a young woman.
THIS CASE IS OPEN. As of November 2026, the man charged in 2024 has pleaded not guilty and has not been tried or convicted of anything in this case. Accusations in this episode are attributed to the people who made them. When there's an outcome, we'll update this episode.
CHAPTERS
0:00 Cold Open
2:23 Show Introduction
4:11 Home
7:58 The Dance
10:56 Sure
14:59 Good Chick
19:03 The Book Cliffs
23:10 Emphatically Yes
28:26 Bingo
33:23 The Pants
38:02 Gene
THE RECORDS
The front pages from Thanksgiving weekend 1972 and the hometown paper's own photographs are on our blog: Section29.com
IF YOU KNOW SOMETHING
At the 2024 arrest, the Uintah County Sheriff's Office asked anyone with information to call 435-781-6700 or email coldcase@uintah.utah.gov.
IF YOU NEED SUPPORT
RAINN, the National Sexual Assault Hotline: 800-656-HOPE (800-656-4673) or rainn.org. Free, confidential, 24/7.
Forgotten True Crime is an independent podcast. Subscribe, and tell a friend. That's how a show like ours grows. Find us on YouTube and Facebook at Forgotten True Crime.
SOURCES
Newspapers: Deseret News; Vernal Express; Salt Lake Tribune. Later coverage: KSL, KUTV, KVEL.
PHOTOS
John Vachon, Duchesne County, Utah, 1942. Library of Congress (loc.gov/item/2017815107, 2017815108, 2017815139)
John Margolies, Vernal, Route 40, 1991. Library of Congress (loc.gov/item/2017704088, 2017703845)
Nationwide Post Card Co., Millecam's Motel 40, Vernal, c. 1950s. Via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)
An Errant Knight, Ashley Valley from Asphalt Ridge, 2017. Via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Famartin, Uintah County and the Book Cliffs from the air, 2022. Via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Bruce McAllister, Salt Lake City, 1972. DOCUMERICA, National Archives (public domain)
SSgt Harry G. Giffen, SP5 Frank R. Sullivan III, SP4 James Ensign: U.S. Army in Vietnam, 1970. Via Wikimedia Commons (public domain). None show Greg's unit.
MAPS
State of Utah shaded relief map, U.S. Bureau of Land Management, 1993. Library of Congress (loc.gov/item/95682023)
United States, Central Intelligence Agency, 1975. Library of Congress (loc.gov/item/76695655)
State of Utah, 1937, and State of Idaho, 1939, U.S. General Land Office. Via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)
Washington, Collier's New Encyclopedia atlas, 1921. Via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)
Music: "I Drank Alone" by TrackTribe.
Also in this episode: Willard Dale Taylor , Daniel Arthur Bell (named by the sheriff’s office in 2022; never charged; died 2019), and Darrel Eugene Choate.
#TrueCrime #ColdCase #Utah