The daddies are back—and this time they’re hungry, stranded at sea and breaking badly.

In Bite Me Daddy, Andrew and Jason try The Domino, Domino’s new personal-sized Detroit-style pizza. Does it deliver the crispy, cheesy edges that define Detroit-style pizza, or is it simply Domino’s pan pizza wearing a Michigan costume?

Next, Daddy Duel takes to the high seas with Sail, Allplay’s cooperative two-player trick-taking game. The daddies must navigate dangerous waters, avoid obstacles and battle a Kraken—all without discussing the cards in their hands. Will they sail to safety or discover that silent cooperation is harder than it looks?

Finally, Daddy Culture Club dives into Netflix’s Untold: Raygun — Breaking Badly. The documentary gives Australian Olympic breaker Rachael “Raygun” Gunn a chance to tell her side of the story after her infamous Paris performance turned her into a worldwide meme. Did it change the daddies’ opinions, or does the film dance around its most difficult questions?

Welcome to the first episode of Dueling Daddies, the bite-sized Gaymer Daddies spin-off where two daddies square off over food, a two-player board game and a piece of pop culture. Each contender receives a letter grade before we reveal our final Daddy Report Cards.

In this episode:

• BITE ME DADDY — We taste Jimmy John’s new PB&J Cookie, a soft-baked peanut butter cookie filled with grape jelly and topped with crunchy peanuts. Does this childhood favorite deserve a spot in our lunchbox, or should Jimmy John’s stick to sandwiches?

• DADDY DUEL — We go undercover with Agent Avenue, a two-player game of bluffing, deduction and double-crossing. We break down how it plays, what makes its face-up-or-face-down card choices so tense and whether this neighborhood is big enough for both of our spies.

• DADDY CULTURE CLUB — We head back to summer camp for Jane Schoenbrun’s Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma, starring Hannah Einbinder and Gillian Anderson. This queer, surreal and blood-soaked reimagining of the summer-camp slasher gives us plenty to sink our axes—and our opinions—into.

Which contender earns the highest grade? Who makes the honor roll, and who is getting sent back to summer school? Grab your Daddy Report Card and find out.

Dueling Daddies is a Gaymer Daddies spin-off featuring fast, funny reviews of food, two-player board games and the latest movies, television, video games and pop culture.

Pack the bug spray, stay out of the woods and never trust a camp counselor—the Gaymer Daddies are heading to Camp Grizzly!

Andrew, Jason and Jacob explore the idea of “grail games”: the rare, expensive and out-of-print titles that board gamers dream of adding to their collections. Andrew shares why Camp Grizzly has been at the top of his list since its original 2013 Kickstarter campaign—and how the game’s fulfillment problems, missing expansions and limited availability turned it into one of board gaming’s most infamous collector’s items.

Then the daddies put the new Second Edition from Trick or Treat Studios through the SERVE review and reveal their final Daddy Scores.

In this episode:

• A Quickie with Jason

• Why summer camps make such great horror settings

• The troubled history of the original Camp Grizzly Kickstarter •

• How to play Camp Grizzly

• The official SERVE review and Daddy Scores