In this episode I skip the regulation read-through and walk you through an audit case study instead. The question underneath it is one I get asked all the time: how do you know whether a cost is direct or indirect? We look at 2 CFR 200.413 and 200.414 through the eyes of an auditor.
The setup: a nonprofit I’m calling Health Services Inc. has a large federal grant. The government audits a sample of its transactions and its financial management system, and the auditors flag five areas: related party transactions, compensation, direct costs, the indirect costs tied to them, and financial management controls. Each one teaches us something about how to handle these costs before an auditor ever shows up.
What You’ll Learn:
- Direct costs: A direct cost can be identified with a specific cost objective with a high degree of accuracy, and it has to be treated consistently. “It’s related to the grant” isn’t enough. You have to understand the relationship between the cost and the cost objective.
- Leases and related parties: Don’t just look at the monthly payment. In our case study the nonprofit pays about $400,000 to lease a facility from a related entity. Ask what type of lease it is, who the lessor is, what ancillary costs are attached, and whether the cost is allowable. Having a contract doesn’t mean the federal government will reimburse it.
- Indirect costs (200.414): If a cost is later found unallowable, you can’t just back out the direct amount. Say $1 million was charged directly and an indirect rate was applied on top of it. Pulling out the $1 million isn’t the end of it. You also have to find the indirect costs that came along with it.
- Compensation: A salary being in the approved budget isn’t enough. Who received it, was it charged directly, and what’s sitting in your indirect pool? Budgets get approved months before the work happens, so compare actuals against budget.
- Policies and internal controls: My favorite question is “show me the policy.” Then I ask to see what actually happened, because the two are often very different. Internal controls are what safeguard grant assets and keep your reporting accurate and compliant.
- Quick quiz: Equipment bought for one federal project is direct. Software that supports the whole organization is indirect. An administrative employee whose work is integral to one grant and can be identified with it can be direct, as long as you’ve documented the justification and met the requirements.
Key Quote: “Your documentation needs to tell the same story as your accounting system.”
Bottom line: Picture the auditor pointing at a transaction and asking why it’s charged to the federal award. “That’s how we’ve always done it” won’t hold up. Be ready to explain what the cost is, what it supports, who benefits, why it’s direct or indirect, and which policy backs that up. Your grants management system has to connect the transaction to the compliance requirement.
💬 Connect with Jasmine & Markanday Consulting:
Instagram: @markandayconsulting
LinkedIn: @markandayconsulting
Website: www.markanday.consulting
If you found this episode helpful, please subscribe, rate, and share it with your colleagues and network. Join us next time as we continue exploring important grants management topics.
Got a question? Send it my way at hello@markanday.consulting, I’d be happy to help. Until next time, stay informed and stay compliant.