Send us Fan Mail

A five-run hole, a swaggering ace on the mound, and a clubhouse tired of almost. We sit down with Michael McHenry to relive April 14, 2013—an afternoon that turned a would-be stumble into a sweep and revealed how the Pirates’ identity had finally hardened into something playoff strong. McHenry takes us inside the arc from 2011–2012 foundation-building to a 2013 culture defined by shared leadership, sharper preparation, and a bullpen that made the last nine outs feel inevitable.

You’ll hear how Russell Martin’s arrival shifted everything without swallowing the room. From AJ Burnett’s grip on the rotation to Jason Grilli’s Shark Tank swagger, and Clint Barmes’ infield calm, the team moved from good vibes to clear standards. McHenry also opens up about embracing a reduced role behind Martin: what it took to stay razor-ready after four or five days off, and how trust grew when a veteran star asked questions first. That mindset met the moment against Matt Latos, who’d owned McHenry for years—until a 2-0 heater met a ready barrel for a center-field jolt.

The comeback tightened again versus Jonathan Broxton, a towering slider machine. McHenry breaks down picking up spin, getting the ball in the air, and watching the left fielder nearly topple into the seats as the game turned. From there, the formula that defined the 2013 Pirates took hold: get to the bullpen, turn to Mark Melancon, hand the ninth to Jason Grilli, and close the book. We trace the line from that April sweep to late July, when the roster kept winning even on off nights and belief became habit.

If you love baseball strategy, clubhouse chemistry, and the way a single game can forecast a season, this one’s for you. Tap play, subscribe for more behind-the-plate stories, and leave a review with the comeback that made you a believer.

THANK YOU FOR LISTENING!!!!

www.holdmycutter.com

Send a text

Step into a hidden studio in western Pennsylvania and a sunlit shrine in Bradenton as we sit down with Pirates legend Steve Blass for a ride through memory, ritual, and the stories that make baseball feel like home. Steve opens up about retirement with Karen, the sanity of walking a quiet golf course, and the strict joy of a 4:30 happy hour that turns every day into a small celebration. The conversation moves with the ease of an old friend call—Jeopardy at 7:30, classic sitcom reruns, and an honest, can’t-look-away take on Tiger King—before we step into his museum of moments.

The memorabilia tour is a time machine. We see Steve vaulting Freddie Patek, co-managing a fantasy camp win with Bob Walk, and a row of gleaming Ford Thunderbirds circling the Forbes Field track in 1967. He brings out rare Pittsburgh artifacts from a traveling baseball school with Honus Wagner and Wilbur Cooper, proof that the game’s roots run deep and loud. We laugh at Eddie Feigner’s King and His Court showmanship and share the kind of clubhouse humor that still rings true.

Then the stories deepen. Steve remembers Willie Stargell’s grace, a dugout snapshot at Three Rivers, and an Oval Office visit with President Nixon after Roberto Clemente’s death to support the dream of Ciudad Deportiva. He reflects on how Clemente’s vision could have reshaped Puerto Rico for generations. Finally, we stand on the dugout roof for the last day at Three Rivers, a World Series ring catching the light as thousands sing Take Me Out to the Ball Game. It’s a portrait of baseball as community: history preserved in photos, laughter, and a city’s voice lifted together.

If you love Pirates history, Roberto Clemente’s legacy, and the human side of a World Series pitcher, this one’s for you. Subscribe, share with a friend who misses Forbes Field or Three Rivers, and leave a review to tell us which memory hit you the hardest.

THANK YOU FOR LISTENING!!!!

www.holdmycutter.com

Send a text

A five-story landmark from 1856 just became Pittsburgh’s most intriguing clubhouse on the river. Its part rooftop restaurant, part private cigar lounge, part music venue, part distillery and much more. We step inside the Drawing Room to trace how a decrepit shell turned into a South Shore destination with a skyline overlook, historic structural beams saved from the past, and a culture obsessed with fit, not flash.

We break down the vertical blueprint: a rooftop built for sunsets and city photos, an events floor that swings from weddings to corporate nights, a members-first cigar lounge with two simple rules and serious ventilation, a forthcoming restaurant concept shaped by neighborhood demand, and a ground-level deli, bottle shop, and distillery linking daily life to late nights. Along the way, we talk partnerships that matter city life, hotels, venues, local teams. They want highlight the riverfront so it becomes a destination circuit instead of a one-off stop. Draft week turns the volume up even more, with the Dan Patrick Show broadcasting from the Drawing Room and a calendar packed with parties, foundations, and live sets.

Sports and city identity thread everything together. We swap memories of terrible towels and summer nights at the ballpark, and we wrestle with expectations: what “winning” really means, how culture beats clout in a clubhouse, and why a fanbase that fills seats and keeps TV numbers strong year after year. We explore the Pirates’ outlook with their young talented arms, O’Neil Cruz’s ceiling, and what it takes to keep generational stars through the lens of legacy deals and the city’s history of creative solutions. If you care about urban revival, hospitality strategy, or how a curated community can turn a building into a beacon, this show is for you.

Subscribe, share with a Pittsburgh friend, and leave a review to help more people find the show. What would you add to the South Shore to make it the city’s next great night out?

https://www.thedistillerycomplex.com/

https://www.thedrawingroompgh.com/

THANK YOU FOR LISTENING!!!!

www.holdmycutter.com

Send a text

Ken Macha, former Pittsburgh Pirates player and seasoned baseball manager, takes us on a riveting journey through his extraordinary career. From his formative days as a bench coach with the Oakland Athletics to taking the helm as their manager, Ken shares the pivotal moments that shaped his approach to coaching and management. Alongside Greg Brown and co-host Michael McKenry, we dive into fascinating anecdotes from Ken's playing days under the legendary Dick Williams in Montreal, his stint in Japan, and his strategic transition to minor league management. Listeners will gain invaluable insights into Ken's unique path in baseball, marked by both triumphs and challenges.

Discover Ken Macha's intriguing athletic journey that began amidst the competitive sports culture at Gateway High School, where he balanced a love for swimming and baseball. Despite the school's football dominance, Ken's dedication to his passions led to memorable experiences, culminating in a celebrated career with the Pittsburgh Pirates and his induction into the Pitt Hall of Fame. Hear about his minor league beginnings and the often grueling path to the majors, including the trials of limited playing time and the emotional highs and lows of narrowly missing significant baseball milestones with the Montreal Expos.

Ken also shares the importance of mastering baseball fundamentals and the strategic nuances that differentiate high-budget teams from those that must perfect their craft to compete. Reflect on his time with the Oakland A's, and the development of future stars like Tim Hudson and Barry Zito, accentuating the critical role of analytics and player belief in building a winning team. Join us as Ken Macha offers a rich tapestry of baseball history, filled with wisdom, humor, and reflections that celebrate the transformative journey of this beloved sport.

THANK YOU FOR LISTENING!!!!

www.holdmycutter.com

Send a text

What if the trait that decides who wins isn’t talent or likability, but an unshakable need to get better? We dive straight into the fire with Mike Berger—Pittsburgh native, catcher-turned-coach, and longtime executive—to redefine “makeup” as the raw drive that outlasts comfort, politics, and pain. It’s not a mood or a mantra; it’s doing the hard thing again tomorrow. We separate makeup from character and test that idea against polarizing names—from Barry Bonds to Trevor Bauer—without flinching.

This is a story-driven tour through baseball’s back rooms and dugouts. Berger traces a life in the game: catching in big league spring at 18, missing a long-awaited callup, then finding his future through a chance phone reservation that led to a 35-year marriage. We unpack how regimes protect “their guys,” why timing is brutal, and how a player-coach role accelerates leadership. Along the way, we get practical tools—reading swing angles, rehabbing around pain, and using the lineup to build the right reps. One gem: pushing a slumping Fernando Tatis Sr. into the leadoff spot to force more high-quality at-bats. It wasn’t about optics; it was about outcomes.

What holds it all together is a clean framework: confidence creates momentum, momentum produces success. Not empty hype—earned confidence that comes from real adjustments and honest feedback. We spotlight the leaders who can steward that process: Jim Leyland and Chuck Tanner as people-first masters; the “glue guys” who stabilize rooms; and the elite “cleaners” whose edge must be harnessed, not sanded down. From Pirates lore and family legacy to modern scouting rooms, this conversation threads past and present to show how teams actually get better.

If you value straight talk, layered stories, and practical insight you can use—on the field or at work—press play. Then tell us: is greatness worth the rough edges if the work never lies? Subscribe, share with a friend, and leave a review with your take on makeup vs. character.

THANK YOU FOR LISTENING!!!!

www.holdmycutter.com

Send a text

What actually turns a struggling franchise into a contender? We dig into a people-first blueprint for the Pittsburgh Pirates that prioritizes player development, modern pitching, and a culture of humility and feedback over quick fixes. From the first conversation, the focus is clear: winning is hard everywhere, and sustainable success depends on great players supported by a smart, collaborative environment.

We walk through why Pittsburgh is the right stage, how alignment with ownership sets the conditions for real investment, and why a player-centered philosophy can move the needle more than any single splash. You’ll hear how development becomes a compounding engine when 200-plus players each improve a bit, and how that philosophy connects scouting, coaching, analytics, and high performance into one clear system designed to raise the entire roster’s baseline. We also share lessons from Toronto on modern pitching: blending pitch design, biomechanics, and data with on-field translation so pitchers understand not just what to change, but why it works in-game.

Culture ties it all together. Humility is treated as a performance tool—the base layer that makes learning possible—while active pursuit of feedback keeps blind spots from calcifying. We break down how to invite dissent, hire diverse thinkers, and give coaches and players a voice that actually shapes decisions. And when the team earns its shot? We talk about responsible risk, signaling belief at the right time, and making moves that push a good club toward October without sacrificing the future. If you care about how real baseball organizations win—through people, process, and clear-eyed choices—you’ll feel the plan taking shape.

If this conversation resonates, follow the show, share it with a Pirates fan who needs hope, and leave a quick review so more listeners can find us.

THANK YOU FOR LISTENING!!!!

www.holdmycutter.com

Send a text

What if the true edge in baseball isn’t in a spreadsheet but in a heartbeat? We sit down with baseball lifer Mike Berger to unpack a scouting philosophy built on live looks, instincts, and the human elements analytics can’t quite capture. From the moment a prospect’s poise surfaces under pressure to the quiet ways chemistry binds a clubhouse, Berger explains why the best scouts either agree with the model—or beat it.

The stories run deep. We relive the under-the-radar chain reaction that brought Michael McKenry to Pittsburgh for $50,000 and later turned Jason Grilli from “washed up” to All-Star. We walk the shared halls of Three Rivers, connecting Steelers and Pirates lore, and trace Berger’s family imprint on the franchise’s identity—from the skull-and-crossbones to the smiling pirate inspired by Frank Gifford and a grandmother’s babushka. Culture matters, he argues, because it shapes standards long before the first pitch.

Leadership takes center stage through vivid moments: Adam Wainwright setting up a newcomer’s locker and handing him the pregame meeting, a masterclass in humility and clarity. Then comes Barry Bonds—his interview as a hitting coach, his glove-to-barrel timing lesson born from Bobby Bonds, and the ripple effects on Stanton, Ozuna, and a soon-to-explode Christian Yelich. Berger makes the case that modern staffs win with range: the truth-teller who says it once with precision and the grinder who shows up at noon for flips and stays until the last swing.

If you care about scouting, player development, and what really makes a team hum, this is your blueprint—equal parts Pittsburgh pride, clubhouse wisdom, and practical tools you can feel. Subscribe, share with a baseball friend, and leave a review to tell us the one moment that gave you chills.

THANK YOU FOR LISTENING!!!!

www.holdmycutter.com

Send a text

The door opens, a little face lights up, and suddenly the turbulence was worth it. That’s the spirit of this homecoming to Pittsburgh—a night where gratitude, memory, and the roar of a standing crowd all met before the first pitch. We revisit the moments that nearly cracked the helmet armor: spotting Maria in the suite, feeling the ovation swell, and trying to keep an at-bat alive while the heart races faster than a fastball.

We get real about the hidden cost of getting traded. Nine seasons with one franchise builds a life—friends, routines, even the color of your training gear—then a single call redraws the map. From packing with a newborn asleep in the next room to relearning spring under a new sky, we share the logistics you never see and the resilience you need to find. Along the way, we offer thanks to the front office and coaches who stepped back to let a city and a player share a rare, human moment.

Fatherhood sits at the center of it all. We talk about how a kid’s smile at the door can erase a brutal night at the plate, how priorities shift from performance to presence, and why baseball now serves the life being built at home. There’s humor too—ping pong grudge matches and a dad who’s part prophet, calling black and yellow before the draft board ever did. Most of all, this is a love letter to a fanbase that believed through losing streaks, turned handshakes into hugs, and showed that a ballplayer’s bond with a city can outlast any box score.

If this story moved you, hit follow, share it with a friend who loves baseball lore, and leave a quick review so more fans can find the show. What’s the sports moment that still gives you goosebumps? Tell us—we’re listening.

THANK YOU FOR LISTENING!!!!

www.holdmycutter.com