Send us Fan Mail

Two public intellectuals with real differences walk onstage and do something most of us say we want but rarely practice: they disagree without demeaning each other, and they treat truth like the goal rather than the trophy. From the first minutes, Robert P. George and Cornel West tell the story of how a Princeton faculty acquaintance became a brotherhood through long arguments, shared teaching, and an unshakable respect for integrity. The result is a live, funny, and deeply serious lesson in dialogue across differences.

We dig into teaching as vocation, not career, and what it means to form students into determined truth seekers and courageous truth speakers. George argues that exhortation matters, but modeling matters more: students learn how to think by watching how we face criticism, admit fallibility, and debate without a will to victory. West adds a spiritual vocabulary for character formation, naming piety as remembrance, reverence, and resistance, then connects it to what he calls “Mormon soulcraft,” a way of sustaining joy, empathy, service, and moral courage in a grim world.

The conversation goes wide but stays grounded: the role of art in shaping the soul, the student’s duty to live an examined life, and the provocative charge to “learn how to die” as a daily practice of letting go of ego and falsehood so something better can be reborn. We also confront modern power politics by separating “how the world often is” from “how the world ought to be,” then return to Genesis and the Old Testament as a foundation for human dignity, the imago Dei, and the moral roots of justice, mercy, and family life.

If you care about civil discourse, moral philosophy, faith and public life, liberal arts education, or simply how to keep loving people you disagree with, listen through to the end. Subscribe, share this with a friend who loves a good argument, and leave us a review with the biggest idea you’re taking away.

Support the show