On July 10, 2012, 17-year-old Paige Summer Moore vanished from her home in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, after 1:00 a.m. wearing only a Goo Goo Dolls sleep shirt, polka-dotted boxer shorts, and red house slippers. Dismissed as a runaway for 13 years—and despite her body never being recovered—her case was officially reclassified as a homicide after a social media tip prompted detectives to re-interview over 70 witnesses, culminating in a November 2026 FBI push and a $25,000 reward. In Episode 3 of What Likely Happened, we trace the timeline, examine the hunt for Arthur Carlson’s 2002 green Chevy Tracker and a stolen Ruger P89 9mm, compare the drug-house overdose theory against a violent escalation, and evaluate whether this case will actually be solved.
Have a tip? Contact the Broken Arrow Police Department at (918) 451-8200 or the FBI Oklahoma City Field Office at (405) 290-7770. A $25,000 FBI reward is active.
Episode Chapters:
00:00 - Welcome & Cold Open
00:55 - July 10, 2012: Slippers in the Middle of the Night
03:00 - The New Crowd, The Green Tracker & Arthur Carlson
07:45 - Cross-Referencing the 3 Theories
10:00 - Applying Occam's Razor: Fact vs. Deduction
13:15 - Solvable vs. Will It Be Solved? & Final Verdict
Sources & Case Records:
- FBI Kidnappings & Missing Persons – Paige Summer Moore ($25,000 Reward Poster): https://www.fbi.gov/wanted/kidnap/paige-summer-moore
- News On 6 (November 2026 Update on $25,000 FBI Reward, Chevy Tracker & Stolen Ruger P89 9mm): newson6.com
- FOX 23 Tulsa (14-Year Homicide Reclassification & Chain of Custody for Carlson's Tracker and "Ramon"): fox23.com
- KFOR News (FBI & Muscogee Nation Lighthorse Tribal Police Joint Appeal): kfor.com
- Tulsa World (January 2015 Court Coverage of Arthur Gunner Carlson's Rape/Sodomy Plea & Sentencing): https://tulsaworld.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/article_a95febb1-a7d6-5e2a-b3d0-3ceeef24bba0.html
- News On 6 Archive (September 2013 Arrest Report for Arthur Gunner Carlson Holding 17-Year-Old Captive): newson6.com
- NamUs #MP17870 (Tribal Land Jurisdiction & Case File): https://namus.nij.ojp.gov/case/MP17870
- The Charley Project – Paige Summer Moore Case Summary: charleyproject.org