• A Judge Orders the White House to Produce Its Big Law Deals & What “Rich” Should Mean in a Tax on the Rich
    Nov 18 2026
    This Day in Legal History: Goodridge v. Department of Public HealthOn November 18, 2003, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled, 4 to 3, that the state could not deny marriage licenses to same-sex couples. The case was brought by seven couples, represented by Mary Bonauto of Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders, who had been turned away when they applied for licenses. Chief Justice Margaret Marshall’s majority opinion held that limiting marriage to opposite-sex couples lacked a rational basis under the Massachusetts Constitution, writing that the state constitution “forbids the creation of second-class citizens,” part of today’s opening quote.The court gave the legislature 180 days to respond. Massachusetts considered alternatives, including civil unions, but the court made clear that anything short of marriage wouldn’t satisfy its ruling. On May 17, 2004, Massachusetts became the first state to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. The decision came under the state constitution, so it couldn’t be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.The significance of November 18, 2003 is that it began the legal path to Obergefell v. Hodges twelve years later, through state courts, legislatures, ballot measures, and federal appeals courts, including Judge Richard Posner’s opinion for the Seventh Circuit that we discussed last week. It’s also a lesson about definitions: much of the case turned on what the legal term “marriage” meant and whom it included. Definitions turn out to be at the heart of today’s column, too.A federal judge has ordered the White House to hand over records in the American Bar Association’s lawsuit over the administration’s campaign against law firms. U.S. District Judge Amir Ali ordered the government to produce the agreements it reached last year with nine major firms, including Kirkland & Ellis, Skadden, Latham & Watkins, Milbank, A&O Shearman, and Simpson Thacher, in which the firms pledged free legal work for causes the administration supports. He also ordered production of White House communications with those firms and with the smaller group of firms targeted by punitive executive orders, from the start of the President’s term through June 2025. Some of the deals’ terms have never been made fully public, and the communications could show how the executive orders and the agreements came about. The judge didn’t order everything disclosed. He said some, even many, of the records may be privileged, and the administration has refused to identify members of the press secretary’s “policy team,” citing presidential communications privilege. This is a significant ruling because discovery against the White House is unusual and handled carefully. The Supreme Court has said courts should be cautious about intrusive discovery directed at the President and his close advisers, and the presidential communications privilege protects advice given to the President. But United States v. Nixon held that privilege isn’t absolute and can yield to the needs of a legal proceeding. Ordering the agreements and communications to be produced, while leaving room for privilege claims over specific documents, is the kind of narrowing courts use to balance those interests. This connects to several stories we’ve covered this fall: the EEOC’s effort to keep its law firm investigation records secret, Paul Weiss’s deal with the administration coming up as Jensen Huang hired the firm, and Judge Ali’s earlier ruling against the counterterrorism-grant conditions. The firms’ deals have been among the most controversial episodes for the legal profession in years. Now we may learn more about how they were made.White House ordered to hand over records in lawsuit over Trump’s law firm crackdown | Reuters · Bloomberg Law · Above the LawAnd, in my column for Bloomberg Tax this week, I look at the “tax the rich” measures voters just endorsed. Colorado voters approved a graduated income tax with higher rates on income above $500,000, starting in 2027. Washington voters rejected an effort to repeal the state’s tax on income above $1 million. My argument is simple: if you’re going to tax the rich, you need a definition of “rich” that matches your intent, and that keeps matching it over time. The problem is inflation. Colorado’s new brackets, a 7.4% rate on income between $500,000 and $750,000 and higher rates above that, aren’t adjusted for inflation. Assume 3% inflation a year. After twenty years, a $500,000 income would have the purchasing power of about $277,000 today. To keep the threshold’s original value, the bracket would need to start around $903,000. So without indexing, the tax would gradually reach people whose real incomes are far below what voters had in mind. Whether people earning the equivalent of $277,000 today should pay a higher rate is a legitimate policy question, but it should be decided openly, not by letting inflation decide it ...
    Show More Show Less
    7 mins
  • Trump Asks SCOTUS to Curb Judges’ Power Over Agency Rules, Ecuadorean Fishermen Sue Over a Boat Strike & DOJ Warns Sen. Warren
    Nov 17 2026
    This Day in Legal History: “I Am Not a Crook”On November 17, 1973, President Richard Nixon took questions from about 400 newspaper editors at a convention at Walt Disney World in Florida. Defending himself against the growing Watergate scandal, he said: “People have got to know whether or not their President is a crook. Well, I’m not a crook.” It became the most famous line of the scandal, mostly for how badly it aged.The context matters. It was less than a month after the Saturday Night Massacre, when Nixon fired Special Prosecutor Archibald Cox, and Attorney General Elliot Richardson and his deputy resigned rather than carry out the order. Just three days before the speech, on November 14, a federal judge ruled that Cox’s firing had been illegal. A new special prosecutor, Leon Jaworski, was pressing for the White House tapes, and the House had begun impeachment inquiries. Within months, the Supreme Court would unanimously order Nixon to turn over the tapes in United States v. Nixon, rejecting his claim of absolute executive privilege, and in August 1974 he resigned.The significance of November 17, 1973 is what it shows about accountability. A president’s denials don’t settle anything. The courts, Congress’s investigative power, and an independent prosecutor do. That system of checks, the power of judges to give effective relief, Congress’s power to investigate the executive, and the independence of prosecutors, is at issue in every one of today’s stories.The administration has asked the Supreme Court to further limit the power of federal judges, this time over agency regulations. Last year, in Trump v. CASA, the Supreme Court held that federal courts generally can’t issue “universal” injunctions blocking a policy for everyone, only relief needed to protect the plaintiffs. But the Court left open a different tool: the Administrative Procedure Act, which tells courts to “set aside” unlawful agency action. Courts have long read that to mean a rule found unlawful can be vacated entirely, so it no longer applies to anyone. Now the administration argues that even under the APA, courts should limit relief to the specific plaintiffs in the case and not wipe out a regulation nationwide. The case comes from a dispute over the federal rules implementing the No Surprises Act, the law protecting patients from surprise medical bills, a fight we’ve followed this year. In August, the Fifth Circuit upheld the nationwide invalidation of parts of those rules. The Justice Department filed its petition in October, and the Court is expected to decide early next year whether to take the case. Here’s why this matters so much. Vacatur under the APA has become one of the most important tools for challenging federal regulations, used by challengers on both the left and the right. Notably, Texas and Florida, along with other mostly Republican-led states, urged the Fifth Circuit to preserve it, because they’ve used it to strike down rules they opposed in other administrations. If the administration wins, a rule held unlawful in one case might keep applying to everyone else, forcing new lawsuits by each affected party. Supporters say that limits the outsized power of single district judges. Critics say it would mean the government could keep enforcing rules courts have already found illegal. Either way, it’s a question about the basic structure of judicial review of agencies.At the Supreme Court, Trump aims to cut the power of judges again | Reuters · Virginia Lawyers Weekly · IBTimesSixteen Ecuadorean fishermen have sued the U.S. government in federal court in Pittsburgh over a drone strike that destroyed their boat, the Negra Francisca Duarte II, in the Pacific in March, about 385 nautical miles off Ecuador’s coast. They allege the strike sank the boat and injured crew members, and that some of them were then held for about a day and mistreated. They’re seeking damages and a court order ending lethal strikes on boats in the Caribbean and Pacific. Some background. Since September 2025, the administration has carried out a campaign of military strikes on boats it says are operated by “narco-terrorists,” as part of what it calls Operation Southern Spear. The lawsuit says there have been 71 such strikes, killing at least 235 people. The government hasn’t claimed responsibility for this particular strike and says it has no information about it or two other Ecuadorean boats sunk this year. The Washington Post reported in August that these vessels were targeted as part of a CIA program. The White House and Justice Department didn’t immediately comment. These are allegations, and the case faces major legal obstacles. The Federal Tort Claims Act, which lets people sue the federal government for injuries, excludes claims arising in a foreign country and claims arising from combatant activities during wartime. The Supreme Court has also refused to let people sue federal officers ...
    Show More Show Less
    8 mins
  • Intel Faces a Securities Suit After a 29% Plunge, Jensen Huang Hires Paul Weiss & New York Wins Back Its Highway Funds
    Nov 16 2026
    This Day in Legal History: Justice Pierce Butler DiesOn November 16, 1939, Justice Pierce Butler died after seventeen years on the Supreme Court. A Minnesota railroad lawyer appointed by President Warren Harding in 1922, Butler is best remembered as one of the “Four Horsemen,” the bloc of conservative justices, with Willis Van Devanter, James McReynolds, and George Sutherland, who voted repeatedly to strike down New Deal laws as beyond the federal government’s power or as violating property and contract rights. Their resistance helped provoke President Roosevelt’s failed plan to expand the Court in 1937.But Butler’s record is more complicated than that label suggests. He was the lone dissenter in Buck v. Bell in 1927, the notorious case in which Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes wrote for an 8 to 1 majority upholding Virginia’s forced sterilization of Carrie Buck, with the infamous line “three generations of imbeciles are enough.” Butler dissented without writing an opinion. He was the only Catholic on the Court, and many have attributed his vote to his faith. Whatever his reasons, history has vindicated him on that case, and not the majority.The significance of November 16, 1939 is that Butler’s death came as the New Deal Court was taking shape, and the expansive view of federal power the Four Horsemen resisted became the law. But federal power still has limits, including on how the national government can use money to pressure states, which is the question in our last story today.Intel shareholders have filed a proposed class action after the company’s stock suffered one of the worst single-day drops in its history. On October 30, the day after Intel forecast weaker-than-expected fourth-quarter revenue and profit, its shares fell about 28.6%, wiping out roughly $140 billion in market value. The suit, filed in federal court in San Jose and led by the City of Southfield Fire and Police Retirement System, names Intel, CEO Lip-Bu Tan, and CFO David Zinsner. It alleges Intel concealed how badly a prolonged slowdown in PC sales would hurt its results. The key allegation: in mid-August, halfway through what the plaintiffs call a “disastrous” third quarter, Intel sold $23 billion of new stock at $95 a share. Intel closed Friday at about $60. These are allegations, and Intel hasn’t been found liable for anything. Here’s the legal framework. A stock drop alone isn’t fraud. Companies miss forecasts all the time. Under Rule 10b-5, the main securities fraud provision, shareholders generally have to show a material misstatement or omission, made with intent to deceive or recklessness, that they relied on, and that caused their losses when the truth came out. The Private Securities Litigation Reform Act also requires plaintiffs to plead facts creating a strong inference of that intent, a high bar that ends many of these cases at the motion-to-dismiss stage. That’s why the $23 billion stock sale matters so much. Plaintiffs will argue that selling a huge amount of stock while knowing bad news was coming shows a motive to keep the price high. And if investors bought shares in that offering, they may also have claims under Section 11 of the Securities Act of 1933, which imposes nearly strict liability for material misstatements in a registration statement, without having to prove intent. Intel will argue its forecasts were made in good faith and protected by the safe harbor for forward-looking statements. Expect a fight over who leads the case and then a motion to dismiss.Intel sued by shareholders following 29% stock plunge | Reuters · MarketScreenerFormer Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has hired Paul, Weiss, the law firm that struck a deal with the President last year. On Friday, we covered the Senate Banking Committee’s request that Huang testify. Since then, Reuters reports that Huang resigned after more than 30 years leading Nvidia, following reports that he had extramarital affairs with three women, one of whom U.S. authorities reportedly suspect of spying for China. No charges have been reported against anyone. Republican leaders of several House committees have also asked to interview Huang in a closed-door session next month. According to the New York Times, Huang is working with Paul Weiss partners Walter Brown and Melinda Haag, a former U.S. attorney in San Francisco. Nvidia’s board, meanwhile, has hired Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz to conduct its own independent investigation. Paul Weiss is a notable choice. After the President issued an executive order targeting the firm in March 2025, Paul Weiss agreed to provide $40 million in free legal work supporting causes the administration favors, and the order was revoked. That deal drew sharp criticism from many in the legal profession and prompted some lawyers to leave the firm. A few legal points. First, it’s normal and wise for someone facing congressional and possibly criminal scrutiny to hire experienced defense counsel, and ...
    Show More Show Less
    8 mins
  • Gibson Dunn Lands Weil’s 120-Lawyer Funds Team, the Senate Calls Jensen Huang and Howard Lutnick & SEC and CFTC Nominees Head to the Senate
    Nov 13 2026
    This Day in Legal History: Browder v. GayleOn November 13, 1956, the Supreme Court affirmed a lower-court decision in Browder v. Gayle, holding that segregation on the buses of Montgomery, Alabama, was unconstitutional. The case was brought by four Black women, Aurelia Browder, Claudette Colvin, Mary Louise Smith, and Susie McDonald, each of whom had been mistreated or arrested for refusing to give up their seats. Their lawyer, Fred Gray, filed it in federal court in February 1956, in the middle of the Montgomery bus boycott that had begun after Rosa Parks’s arrest the previous December.A three-judge federal court ruled for the plaintiffs that June, 2 to 1, holding that Brown v. Board of Education’s rejection of “separate but equal” applied beyond schools. The Supreme Court affirmed without a full opinion, in a one-line summary order. It denied rehearing in December, and on December 20, 1956, after the order was delivered to city officials, the boycott ended. Black riders returned to Montgomery’s buses after 381 days.The significance of November 13, 1956 is that a single-sentence order from the Supreme Court helped end segregation on public transportation, and with it one of the defining campaigns of the civil rights movement. The boycott showed the power of collective action; the lawsuit turned that pressure into a binding legal rule. It’s also a reminder, relevant to how much law this year has been made on the Court’s emergency docket, that short, unexplained orders can carry enormous consequences.Two weeks ago we covered the collapse of Weil, Gotshal & Manges. Now its partners have approved a wind-down plan, and the biggest pieces of the firm are being picked up. Gibson Dunn is hiring Weil’s private funds practice, a team of about 120 lawyers, including 23 partners, across New York, Washington, and London. Among them is Jonathon Soler, one of Weil’s co-managing partners, along with the heads of its private funds practice in New York and London. Weil’s other co-managing partner, Ramona Nee, is moving to Kirkland & Ellis with a team of about 40 private equity and finance lawyers. These large group moves, sometimes called “lift-outs,” raise legal questions that are worth understanding. First, lawyers generally can’t be bound by non-compete agreements. Under the ethics rules, a law firm can’t restrict a lawyer’s right to practice after leaving, because clients have the right to choose their lawyers, and they can follow lawyers to their new firm. Second, departing partners still owe fiduciary duties to their current firm until they leave. That generally means they can prepare to leave, but they shouldn’t secretly solicit clients or colleagues in ways that harm the firm before they go, and clients have to be told about their options fairly. In an orderly wind-down approved by the partnership, many of those tensions ease, because the firm itself is helping its practices find new homes. But as we discussed, dissolutions often still lead to litigation over money: clawbacks of partner distributions, unpaid compensation, and fees from matters taken to new firms. Private funds work is valuable, recurring, and highly relationship-driven, so moving the whole team together makes sense for clients and for Gibson Dunn. It also shows how a firm’s value lives in its people and client relationships, which is why it can disappear so quickly.Gibson Dunn taps Weil co-managing partner Soler as part of 120-lawyer hire | Reuters · Legal Business · Global Legal PostSenate Banking Committee Chairman Tim Scott has asked former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick to testify before the committee. Huang recently stepped down as Nvidia’s chief executive after reports of a romantic relationship with a businesswoman whom U.S. authorities reportedly suspect of spying for the Chinese government. To be clear, these are reports, and no charges against anyone have been reported. Lutnick has faced criticism from lawmakers over the administration’s decision not to add dozens of Chinese companies to a key trade blacklist, and over its oversight of Nvidia’s chip exports to China. Scott wrote that “recent reports raise serious concerns about our national security and the protection of sensitive US technology.” He said he’d consider a subpoena if Huang doesn’t appear voluntarily. A Lutnick spokesperson said he has agreed to appear, and the White House said the President has complete confidence in him. Reports differ on whether both hearings are set for December 3, or whether Lutnick is scheduled a week later. Here’s the legal setting. As we discussed after the election, congressional oversight is one of the powers that doesn’t require the President’s signature. Committees can hold hearings, demand documents, and issue subpoenas, and someone who defies a valid subpoena can be held in contempt. A former CEO can still invoke his Fifth Amendment privilege against ...
    Show More Show Less
    7 mins
  • Remembering Judge Richard Posner & Alaska’s Ballot-Data Fight in the Last Uncalled Senate Race
    Nov 12 2026
    This Day in Legal History: Justice Douglas RetiresOn November 12, 1975, Justice William O. Douglas retired from the Supreme Court after serving since 1939, longer than any justice in the Court’s history: thirty-six years and seven months. He had suffered a serious stroke at the end of 1974 and tried for months to continue working before finally stepping down.Douglas was a former Yale law professor and chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission when Franklin Roosevelt appointed him at 40. On the Court, he became one of its most liberal and most individualistic members, a fierce defender of free speech and civil liberties, and the author of Griswold v. Connecticut, which recognized a constitutional right to privacy. He was also famously prolific and impatient, writing quickly, dissenting often, and publishing books on everything from conservation to travel. He survived two impeachment efforts, including one led by then-Representative Gerald Ford, who as president would name his successor.The significance of November 12, 1975 is partly about a remarkable career, and partly about the hard question of when a judge should step down, a question that arises again and again with life tenure. It’s a fitting anniversary on a day when we remember another long-serving, prolific, opinionated, and deeply influential judge, one who also left the bench on his own terms, and who, like Douglas, didn’t fit neatly into anyone’s ideological box.Judge Richard Posner has died. He was 87. The University of Chicago Law School, where he taught for decades, confirmed that he died on Tuesday. Posner had largely withdrawn from public life after being diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease in 2018, a few months after he retired from the bench. It’s hard to overstate his influence. Posner was born in New York in 1939, studied English at Yale, graduated first in his class at Harvard Law School, where he was president of the Law Review, and clerked for Justice William Brennan. He worked at the Federal Trade Commission and in the Solicitor General’s office under Thurgood Marshall before joining the University of Chicago faculty in 1969. His 1973 book, Economic Analysis of Law, helped found the law and economics movement: the idea that legal rules can be understood, and often improved, by asking how they affect incentives and efficiency. Along with Robert Bork, he reshaped American antitrust law around the effects on consumers and prices, an approach that still dominates the field. Studies have identified him as the most-cited legal scholar of the twentieth century. President Reagan appointed him to the Seventh Circuit in 1981, where he served for 36 years, including as chief judge, while writing nearly 40 books and an enormous number of opinions, apparently all of them himself, and in plain, direct prose. He disliked the Bluebook, calling it “a monstrous growth.” He co-wrote a blog with the Nobel economist Gary Becker. And he often illustrated points in his opinions with examples involving his cats. What made Posner unusual was his willingness to change his mind publicly. He described himself as a pragmatist: in his view, a judge should first ask what a sensible resolution of a dispute would be, then check whether the law stands in the way. That approach drew sharp criticism, including from people who thought it gave judges too much room, and some of his views, on privacy, on education, and in a 2016 column dismissing the value of studying the Constitution’s history, drew strong objections. But it also produced some of his most important rulings. In 2007, he wrote the opinion upholding Indiana’s photo voter ID law, later affirmed by the Supreme Court in Crawford v. Marion County Election Board. Six years later, in his book Reflections on Judging, he wrote that he would “plead guilty to having written the majority opinion (affirmed by the Supreme Court) upholding Indiana’s requirement that prospective voters prove their identity with a photo ID—a type of law now widely regarded as a means of voter suppression rather than of fraud prevention.” He later clarified he wasn’t formally recanting his vote, but he said judges hadn’t had the information they needed. And in 2014, in Baskin v. Bogan, he wrote the unanimous Seventh Circuit opinion striking down Indiana’s and Wisconsin’s same-sex marriage bans. Responding to the states’ reliance on tradition, he wrote the line at the top of today’s episode: “Tradition per se therefore cannot be a lawful ground for discrimination—regardless of the age of the tradition.” And he added that when a tradition provides no social benefit and harms people beyond offending them, “it is not just a harmless anachronism.” He retired in 2017, earlier than he’d planned, after disagreements with colleagues over how the court treated people representing themselves, a cause he took up in his last years. Whether you agreed with him or not, and many people didn...
    Show More Show Less
    8 mins
  • Weil’s Lawyers Scatter, Anthropic Faces a Suit Over Claude Max Marketing & the Paper Trail Behind Florida’s New Property Tax Cut
    Nov 10 2026
    This Day in Legal History: Buckley v. Valeo Is ArguedOn November 10, 1975, the Supreme Court heard argument in Buckley v. Valeo, a challenge to the campaign finance reforms Congress had passed after Watergate. The 1974 amendments to the Federal Election Campaign Act limited how much individuals could contribute to candidates, capped how much candidates and independent groups could spend, created public financing for presidential campaigns, and established the Federal Election Commission. A broad coalition, from conservative Senator James Buckley to the American Civil Liberties Union, argued that the limits violated the First Amendment.In January 1976, the Court split the difference. It upheld limits on contributions to candidates, reasoning that large contributions create a risk of corruption or its appearance. But it struck down limits on independent spending and on candidates’ spending, reasoning, in today’s opening quote, that in modern society spending money is closely tied to the ability to communicate ideas. Limiting spending, the Court said, limits speech.The significance of November 10, 1975 is that Buckley’s distinction between contributions and expenditures still frames campaign finance law fifty years later. It led to Citizens United, the rise of super PACs, and, this June, the Supreme Court’s decision striking down limits on coordinated spending by parties and their candidates, which shaped the election we just held. It’s a reminder that how the law treats money as speech, or as a source of corruption, can reshape elections.Weil, Gotshal & Manges is coming apart quickly. Two weeks ago, the firm’s leadership recommended an orderly wind-down after a wave of partner departures. Now its lawyers are scattering to rival firms. Reports say Kirkland & Ellis is taking around 40 Weil lawyers, Latham & Watkins is hiring several, and firms including Cravath, Paul Weiss, Simpson Thacher, Sullivan & Cromwell, Davis Polk, and Sidley have absorbed others. Weil’s restructuring group, roughly 100 lawyers and among the most sought-after teams in the market, may end up split among several firms. Trainees and junior lawyers face more uncertainty, though some firms have reportedly offered places to incoming trainees. Weil plans to wind down out of court, with restructuring advisers and outside counsel managing the process. Now the legal fights are starting. Law.com reports that at least 10 former Weil attorneys have hired a litigator, and notes that nine of the 12 major law firm dissolutions of the last 20 years ended up in litigation. Those disputes usually center on money: whether the firm’s estate can claw back distributions already paid to partners, whether departing partners owe the firm a share of fees from matters they take with them, and whether partners will be paid compensation they’re owed. That’s the “unfinished business” question we discussed when the wind-down was announced, and how it plays out will depend on the firm’s partnership agreement and New York law. One more detail is worth noting: reports say two AI-focused firms have bid for Weil’s data. Any sale of a law firm’s data raises serious confidentiality questions, because client files and work product belong to clients and are protected by privilege and lawyers’ ethical duties. A firm can’t simply sell what it holds on behalf of clients. The lesson from Weil, as with Dewey a decade ago, is how quickly a firm can unravel once partners start leaving.Weil lawyers scatter to rival firms amid planned wind-down | Reuters · ABA Journal · Law.comA federal judge has ruled that Anthropic must face a proposed class action alleging it misled customers about its Claude Max subscriptions. Claude Max is Anthropic’s higher-priced subscription, advertised as offering “5x” or “20x” more usage than its lower-priced Pro plan. The plaintiffs, Max subscribers, allege that’s misleading because the usage limits apply per session or per week, and that in practice the $200 plan provided about six times the weekly usage of Pro and the $100 plan about three and a half times. Magistrate Judge Alex Tse in the Northern District of California let the core claims go forward: deceptive advertising, negligent misrepresentation, and breach of contract. He found that the disclosure explaining how the limits work was buried two clicks away from the main sales pages, and that because customers pay monthly, they could reasonably read “more usage” as applying across the whole billing cycle. He dismissed an unfair competition claim, with permission to amend, and dismissed one named plaintiff whose description of his use was too vague. A few points of perspective. This is a ruling on a motion to dismiss, so the judge assumed the plaintiffs’ factual allegations were true and asked only whether they stated a legal claim. No court has found that Anthropic misled anyone, and no class has been certified. Anthropic has until December 16...
    Show More Show Less
    8 mins
  • A Defeated Texas Justice Heads for the Federal Bench, a Judge Halts Trump’s Arch & Legal Jobs Hit a Record High
    Nov 9 2026
    This Day in Legal History: Wickard v. FilburnOn November 9, 1942, the Supreme Court decided Wickard v. Filburn, one of the most consequential and most debated decisions about the reach of federal power. Roscoe Filburn, an Ohio farmer, grew more wheat than his federal quota under the Agricultural Adjustment Act allowed. He argued that the extra wheat never left his farm. He fed it to his own livestock and used it at home, so it had nothing to do with interstate commerce, and Congress couldn’t regulate it.The Court disagreed unanimously. Justice Robert Jackson wrote that even activity that’s local and not itself commerce can be regulated if it has a substantial effect on interstate commerce, today’s opening quote. And the effect is measured in the aggregate. Filburn’s own extra wheat was trivial, but if every farmer did the same, they’d collectively buy less wheat on the market and undermine the program’s effort to stabilize prices. Taken together with other New Deal-era decisions, Wickard marked the end of the Court’s resistance to broad federal economic regulation.The significance of November 9, 1942 is that Wickard became the foundation of the modern Commerce Clause, supporting federal laws on everything from civil rights in public accommodations to drug regulation, and it’s still at the center of debates over the limits of federal power, as in the Affordable Care Act case in 2012. It’s a reminder that the most important questions about government power are often decided not in dramatic confrontations, but in cases about wheat, and today, about judicial appointments, monuments, and jobs.The President is moving to nominate James Sullivan, a Republican justice on the Texas Supreme Court who lost his reelection race last Tuesday, to a lifetime federal judgeship on the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas in Austin. Sullivan lost to Democrat Chari Kelly. In fact, Democrats won all four Texas Supreme Court seats on the ballot, narrowing the Republican majority on the nine-member court to 5 to 4. Reports say Sullivan submitted his Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaire days before the election, and the Senate is expected to take up the nomination during the lame-duck session, before Democrats take control of the chamber in January. Here’s why the timing matters. As we discussed last week, the new Democratic Senate majority will control which nominees get hearings and votes. Federal judges serve for life, so the President and the outgoing Republican majority have a strong incentive to confirm as many as possible before January 3. Doing that in a lame-duck session is legal, and both parties have done it, though it’s often criticized when the outgoing majority has just lost an election. There’s also a point worth noting about how differently states and the federal government choose judges. Texas elects its judges in partisan elections, and voters just removed Sullivan from his state seat. The federal system uses presidential nomination and Senate confirmation, with lifetime tenure designed to insulate judges from exactly that kind of political pressure. Sullivan’s path, voted off one court and appointed for life to another within weeks, puts that contrast in sharp relief. Supporters will say his qualifications haven’t changed, and that partisan state judicial elections reflect political tides rather than judicial merit. Critics will see it as a rejected judge being rewarded. Either way, expect a busy lame-duck confirmation calendar, and an incoming Democratic majority prepared to slow the pace of judicial confirmations dramatically in January.Trump to nominate Texas Supreme Court justice who lost election to federal bench | Reuters · The Texas Lawbook · Minnesota LawyerLast week we previewed the fight over the President’s planned 250-foot triumphal arch in Washington. Here’s what happened. On Thursday, the National Capital Planning Commission gave its final approval. Minutes later, U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan issued a temporary restraining order barring any construction or site preparation at Memorial Circle for 14 days while the lawsuits by Vietnam War veterans, the District of Columbia, Virginia, and Arlington County proceed. Judge Chutkan found the challengers were likely to succeed because the administration appeared to have skipped required legal steps in rushing the approval, likely violating the Commemorative Works Act, the federal law that governs new memorials on federal land in Washington. She held off for now on whether to suspend the Interior Department’s approval under the Administrative Procedure Act. The White House praised the commission’s approval and criticized the judge’s order. Recall the administration’s main argument: that Congress approved the arch more than a century ago when it authorized a bridge across the Potomac. The Commemorative Works Act sets out a detailed process for new memorials, including congressional ...
    Show More Show Less
    8 mins
  • A Kentucky Law Professor’s Free-Speech Fight, Big Tech Sues Over California’s Youth Social Media Law & the Battle Over Trump’s Triumphal Arch
    Nov 5 2026
    This Day in Legal History: Susan B. Anthony VotesOn November 5, 1872, Susan B. Anthony walked into a polling place in Rochester, New York, and cast a ballot in the presidential election, along with fourteen other women from her ward. This was a deliberate legal test. Anthony and other suffragists argued that the Fourteenth Amendment, ratified four years earlier, made women citizens, and that voting was one of the privileges of citizenship that no state could deny.Two weeks later, a deputy federal marshal arrested her at her home for voting illegally. She refused to post bail. At her trial in June 1873, before Justice Ward Hunt of the Supreme Court, sitting as a trial judge, she wasn’t allowed to testify, and at the close of evidence the judge directed the all-male jury to return a guilty verdict, without letting them deliberate. When asked if she had anything to say before sentencing, Anthony delivered a famous speech condemning the proceedings. She was fined $100 and never paid it. Two years later, in Minor v. Happersett, the Supreme Court rejected the argument outright, holding that citizenship didn’t automatically include the right to vote.The significance of November 5, 1872 is that Anthony used the law itself, a vote, an arrest, and a trial, to expose the gap between constitutional promises and how they were applied. It took until 1920 and the Nineteenth Amendment to close it. Her case is a reminder that legal change often begins with someone willing to test the boundaries of what they’re allowed to say and do, and that’s exactly the question in our first story.A federal judge in Kentucky will hold a hearing later this month on whether the University of Kentucky violated the First Amendment by suspending a tenured law professor over his comments about Israel. The professor, Ramsi Woodcock, has made statements describing Israel as a “colonization project” and calling for the world to wage war against it. The university barred him from teaching and opened an investigation, which Woodcock says was driven by political pressure from state lawmakers seeking tougher action against antisemitism. Reports indicate the judge declined to give Woodcock an immediate order returning him to the classroom but set a hearing on his broader request for a preliminary injunction. Reports differ on some details of the procedural history, so I’ll keep this at the level of the legal framework. Here’s how courts analyze this. Woodcock works for a public university, so the First Amendment applies. When a public employer disciplines an employee for speech, courts use a balancing test from Pickering v. Board of Education and later cases. If the employee spoke as a private citizen on a matter of public concern, which commentary on Israel and the war in Gaza plainly is, the court weighs the employee’s free-speech interest against the employer’s interest in running its operations effectively, including avoiding disruption. Speech that’s offensive, even deeply offensive to many people, generally remains protected; the question is whether it caused or was reasonably likely to cause the kind of disruption that justifies discipline. Professors have an additional layer of protection, because courts have long recognized academic freedom as a special concern of the First Amendment. On the other side, universities have obligations under federal civil rights law to address harassment of students, including antisemitic harassment, and statements calling for war can raise questions about whether they cross from advocacy into something else. The judge will have to sort out where Woodcock’s statements fall. This case joins several others around the country, and the answers matter for public universities everywhere.Judge to review US law professor’s suspension in free speech case over Israel remarks | Reuters · Court Cast · AOLGoogle, Meta, and TikTok have each sued to block California’s new law restricting social media features for children under 16. We covered the law when Governor Newsom signed it in September as part of a package of what he called the strongest child-safety tech laws in the nation. The law, Assembly Bill 1709, bars platforms from giving users under 16 “psychologically exploitative” features that can lead to compulsive use, like personalized recommendations and autoplay, and requires deleting children’s accounts that use those features. The three companies filed separately in three federal courts: Google in San Jose, Meta in San Francisco, and TikTok in Los Angeles. They argue the law violates the First Amendment and Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, that it forces them to present content the way the state prefers, and that it substitutes the state’s judgment for parents’ choices. The Electronic Frontier Foundation has also criticized the law as a privacy and free-speech problem, partly because enforcing age limits generally requires verifying users’ ages. This was ...
    Show More Show Less
    8 mins