This Day in Legal History: Justice Douglas RetiresOn November 12, 1975, Justice William O. Douglas retired from the Supreme Court after serving since 1939, longer than any justice in the Court’s history: thirty-six years and seven months. He had suffered a serious stroke at the end of 1974 and tried for months to continue working before finally stepping down.Douglas was a former Yale law professor and chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission when Franklin Roosevelt appointed him at 40. On the Court, he became one of its most liberal and most individualistic members, a fierce defender of free speech and civil liberties, and the author of Griswold v. Connecticut, which recognized a constitutional right to privacy. He was also famously prolific and impatient, writing quickly, dissenting often, and publishing books on everything from conservation to travel. He survived two impeachment efforts, including one led by then-Representative Gerald Ford, who as president would name his successor.The significance of November 12, 1975 is partly about a remarkable career, and partly about the hard question of when a judge should step down, a question that arises again and again with life tenure. It’s a fitting anniversary on a day when we remember another long-serving, prolific, opinionated, and deeply influential judge, one who also left the bench on his own terms, and who, like Douglas, didn’t fit neatly into anyone’s ideological box.Judge Richard Posner has died. He was 87. The University of Chicago Law School, where he taught for decades, confirmed that he died on Tuesday. Posner had largely withdrawn from public life after being diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease in 2018, a few months after he retired from the bench. It’s hard to overstate his influence. Posner was born in New York in 1939, studied English at Yale, graduated first in his class at Harvard Law School, where he was president of the Law Review, and clerked for Justice William Brennan. He worked at the Federal Trade Commission and in the Solicitor General’s office under Thurgood Marshall before joining the University of Chicago faculty in 1969. His 1973 book, Economic Analysis of Law, helped found the law and economics movement: the idea that legal rules can be understood, and often improved, by asking how they affect incentives and efficiency. Along with Robert Bork, he reshaped American antitrust law around the effects on consumers and prices, an approach that still dominates the field. Studies have identified him as the most-cited legal scholar of the twentieth century. President Reagan appointed him to the Seventh Circuit in 1981, where he served for 36 years, including as chief judge, while writing nearly 40 books and an enormous number of opinions, apparently all of them himself, and in plain, direct prose. He disliked the Bluebook, calling it “a monstrous growth.” He co-wrote a blog with the Nobel economist Gary Becker. And he often illustrated points in his opinions with examples involving his cats. What made Posner unusual was his willingness to change his mind publicly. He described himself as a pragmatist: in his view, a judge should first ask what a sensible resolution of a dispute would be, then check whether the law stands in the way. That approach drew sharp criticism, including from people who thought it gave judges too much room, and some of his views, on privacy, on education, and in a 2016 column dismissing the value of studying the Constitution’s history, drew strong objections. But it also produced some of his most important rulings. In 2007, he wrote the opinion upholding Indiana’s photo voter ID law, later affirmed by the Supreme Court in Crawford v. Marion County Election Board. Six years later, in his book Reflections on Judging, he wrote that he would “plead guilty to having written the majority opinion (affirmed by the Supreme Court) upholding Indiana’s requirement that prospective voters prove their identity with a photo ID—a type of law now widely regarded as a means of voter suppression rather than of fraud prevention.” He later clarified he wasn’t formally recanting his vote, but he said judges hadn’t had the information they needed. And in 2014, in Baskin v. Bogan, he wrote the unanimous Seventh Circuit opinion striking down Indiana’s and Wisconsin’s same-sex marriage bans. Responding to the states’ reliance on tradition, he wrote the line at the top of today’s episode: “Tradition per se therefore cannot be a lawful ground for discrimination—regardless of the age of the tradition.” And he added that when a tradition provides no social benefit and harms people beyond offending them, “it is not just a harmless anachronism.” He retired in 2017, earlier than he’d planned, after disagreements with colleagues over how the court treated people representing themselves, a cause he took up in his last years. Whether you agreed with him or not, and many people didn...
Show More
Show Less