Episodes

  • The White Witch of Rose Hall
    Nov 19 2026

    Three husbands dead. A burial ritual left unfinished. And a woman who, according to legend, never left her home.

    This episode of spooky season, Carrie has prepared one heck of an episode for you. This week Riley explores the stories surrounding Jamaica’s Rose Hall and its infamous mistress, Annie Palmer—the White Witch.

    From Annie’s alleged crimes to Millie’s tragic fate and Takoo’s revenge, we follow the legend through its darkest turns. Then we step into the haunting stories: a woman on the balcony, a rider on a black horse, an unexpected reflection, and a crying baby no one can find.

    Drawing on folklore, reported paranormal experiences, and the fictional storyline popularized by Herbert G. de Lisser, this episode follows the terrifying tale that gave Rose Hall its reputation.

    Would you spend a night inside?

    🎄 The Monstrous Giving Tree — donations close November 30 and reopen January 1

    every year.

    Give here:

    • GoFundMe: https://gofund.me/584d87a77
    • Venmo: https://www.venmo.com/u/Monstrous_Pod
    • PayPal: https://www.paypal.biz/monstroustcpod
    • Amazon e-gift card: email one to monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    Families in need:

    Email monstroustcpod@gmail.com with "Giving Tree" in the subject line. There's no shame in needing a little help — that's exactly what this tree is for. Everything stays private.

    📧 Send us case suggestions and listener stories:

    monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    📱 Follow us on all social media links here:

    https://linktr.ee/monstrouspod

    Show More Show Less
    41 mins
  • The Van Meter Visitor
    Nov 19 2026

    A bright light above the rooftops. A huge winged shape. Gunshots in the dark. And an abandoned coal mine where, according to the story, one creature became two.

    In this bonus episode of Monstrous, Riley takes us to Van Meter, Iowa, where newspaper accounts from 1903 described a strange visitor with enormous wings, an overpowering smell, and a blinding light shining from its head.

    But the monster story was not the only account making headlines. Just days later, residents pushed back, accusing the newspapers of fabricating or exaggerating what had happened.

    We follow the reported encounters, the confrontation at the mine, the contemporary objections, and the later retellings that helped turn a disputed newspaper story into an enduring local legend.

    Was it a misidentified animal? A prank? A sensational story that grew with every telling? Or an encounter nobody could adequately explain?

    🎄 The Monstrous Giving Tree — donations close November 30 every year.

    Give here:

    • GoFundMe: https://gofund.me/584d87a77
    • Venmo: https://www.venmo.com/u/Monstrous_Pod
    • PayPal: https://www.paypal.biz/monstroustcpod
    • Amazon e-gift card: email one to monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    Families in need:

    Email monstroustcpod@gmail.com with "Giving Tree" in the subject line. There's no shame in needing a little help — that's exactly what this tree is for. Everything stays private.

    📧 Send us case suggestions and listener stories:

    monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    📱 Follow us on all social media links here:

    https://linktr.ee/monstrouspod

    Show More Show Less
    42 mins
  • The Atlas Vampire Murder
    Nov 18 2026

    In May 1932, 32-year-old Lilly Lindeström was found murdered inside her Stockholm apartment. Her death remained unsolved—but the case became infamous under a chilling name: the Atlas Vampire.

    At the center of the legend was an ordinary kitchen ladle and a disturbing suspicion that grew more sensational with each retelling. But what did the evidence actually establish?

    This week on Monstrous, Carrie has handed us an unbelievable true crime care that has earned one of the spookiest monikers. In this one we examine Lilly’s final reported evening, the investigation, and the uncertain details behind one of Stockholm’s strangest murder stories. Beyond the vampire nickname is a woman whose life deserves to be remembered—and a murder that never received an answer.

    🎄 The Monstrous Giving Tree — donations close November 30 every year.

    Give here:

    • GoFundMe: https://gofund.me/584d87a77
    • Venmo: https://www.venmo.com/u/Monstrous_Pod
    • PayPal: https://www.paypal.biz/monstroustcpod
    • Amazon e-gift card: email one to monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    Families in need:

    Email monstroustcpod@gmail.com with "Giving Tree" in the subject line. There's no shame in needing a little help — that's exactly what this tree is for. Everything stays private.

    📧 Send us case suggestions and listener stories:

    monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    📱 Follow us on all social media links here:

    https://linktr.ee/monstrouspod

    Show More Show Less
    42 mins
  • The Great Watseka Wonder
    Nov 17 2026

    A thirteen-year-old girl begins falling into trances.

    She says she can see the dead.

    Then one day, she opens her eyes and says she is no longer herself.

    In 1877, Mary Lurancy Vennum—known as Lurancy—became the center of one of America’s most unsettling alleged possession cases. Her family feared she was losing her mind and might be sent to an asylum. But after she began claiming to see spirits, a local Spiritualist physician and a grieving family offered another explanation.

    They believed the spirit of Mary Roff—a young woman who had died twelve years earlier—had taken control of Lurancy’s body.

    According to the accounts, Lurancy recognized Mary Roff’s family, used private nicknames, remembered details from Mary’s life, and spent about one hundred days living in the Roff family home while claiming to be their dead daughter.

    Was it spirit possession?

    Was it grief, suggestion, trauma, dissociation, or an illness people in 1878 could not understand?

    In this bonus episode of Monstrous, Riley explores the Watseka Wonder: the trances, the reported memories, the Roff family’s loss, the Spiritualist movement, and the question that still refuses to fade.

    Did Mary Roff really come home?

    🎄 The Monstrous Giving Tree — donations close November 30 every year.

    Give here:

    • GoFundMe: https://gofund.me/584d87a77
    • Venmo: https://www.venmo.com/u/Monstrous_Pod
    • PayPal: https://www.paypal.biz/monstroustcpod
    • Amazon e-gift card: email one to monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    Families in need:

    monstroustcpod@gmail.com with "Giving Tree" in the subject line. There's no shame in needing a little help — that's exactly what this tree is for. Everything stays private.

    📧 Send us case suggestions and listener stories:

    monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    📱 Follow us on all social media links here:

    https://linktr.ee/monstrouspod

    Show More Show Less
    28 mins
  • The Great Amherst Mystery
    Nov 16 2026

    A note from Monstrous: Carrie and MawMaw are taking a leave from weekly hosting to focus on personal family matters. Carrie will continue researching and writing our episodes, with Riley bringing you the weekly stories. Carrie may also appear for interviews as they are arranged; those appearances do not necessarily mark a return to weekly hosting. There is no return date to announce. Thank you for respecting their privacy and supporting the show.

    In 1878, 18-year-old Esther Cox lived with her sister’s family in a small yellow cottage at 6 Princess Street in Amherst, Nova Scotia.

    Then the knocking began.

    According to the accounts, objects moved without anyone touching them. Esther’s body swelled.

    Knocks answered questions. Fires started inside the home. Matches fell from the ceiling. And one terrifying message reportedly appeared above Esther’s bed:

    “Esther Cox, you are mine to kill.”

    But was Esther Cox haunted by a poltergeist?

    Or was this a story shaped by trauma, fear, a crowded household, public obsession, Victorian Spiritualism, and a writer who turned her private suffering into a bestselling supernatural tale?

    In this episode of Monstrous, researched and written by Carrie and narrated by Riley, we explore the Great Amherst Mystery from beginning to end: Esther’s reported encounter with Bob MacNeil, the strange events inside the Teed family home, the fires, witnesses, Walter Hubbell’s role, Esther’s failed public tour, the contested details of her late-1879 conviction, and the legacy that still keeps her story alive in Amherst today.

    We also separate what the historical record supports from the claims, folklore, and later supernatural retellings that turned Esther Cox into one of Canada’s most famous paranormal figures.

    Was it a poltergeist?

    A hoax?

    A trauma story no one knew how to hear?

    🎄 The Monstrous Giving Tree — donations close November 30 every year.

    Give here:

    • GoFundMe: https://gofund.me/584d87a77
    • Venmo: https://www.venmo.com/u/Monstrous_Pod
    • PayPal: https://www.paypal.biz/monstroustcpod
    • Amazon e-gift card: email one to monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    Families in need:

    Email monstroustcpod@gmail.com with "Giving Tree" in the subject line. There's no shame in needing a little help — that's exactly what this tree is for. Everything stays private.

    📧 Send us case suggestions and listener stories:

    monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    📱 Follow us on all social media links here:

    https://linktr.ee/monstrouspod

    Show More Show Less
    42 mins
  • The Winchester Mystery House
    Nov 4 2026

    A mansion with doors that open into empty space.

    Staircases that end at ceilings.

    Windows that look into other rooms.

    For more than a century, people have said the Winchester Mystery House was built to confuse ghosts.

    The legend says Sarah Winchester—the widow of William Wirt Winchester and heiress to the Winchester Repeating Arms fortune—was haunted by the spirits of everyone killed by a Winchester rifle. Supposedly, a medium warned her that she would die if she ever stopped building.

    So she built.

    For decades.

    But was Sarah Winchester really trying to escape a curse?

    In this episode of Monstrous, we explore the real woman behind the legend: Sarah’s devastating losses, her move from Connecticut to California, the creation of Llanada Villa, the 1906 earthquake, the mansion’s strange architecture, the famous Séance Room, and the ghost story that grew after her death.

    The Winchester Mystery House is real. Its maze-like design is real. But many of the most famous claims—nightly séances, nonstop construction, a Boston medium, and a curse tied to Winchester rifle victims—are far less certain than the legend makes them sound.

    Was Sarah Winchester building a home?

    Or was she building a way out?

    📧 Send us case suggestions and listener stories:

    monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    📱 Follow us on all social media links here:

    https://linktr.ee/monstrouspod

    Show More Show Less
    56 mins
  • The Kelly-Hopkinsville Goblins
    Sep 7 2026

    It’s officially spooky season, and we’re kicking things off with one of the strangest UFO encounters in American history.

    On the night of August 21, 1955, a group of people near Kelly and Hopkinsville, Kentucky, claimed that their farmhouse was surrounded by small, strange figures. The beings were described as silver or gray, with large heads, long arms, pointed ears, and glowing eyes. According to the witnesses, the creatures approached the windows, appeared on the roof, and repeatedly returned even after the family fired at them.

    The frightened group eventually went to the Hopkinsville police station and asked officers to come back with them. Police found evidence that weapons had been fired, but no physical evidence of the alleged creatures.

    Were the witnesses attacked by extraterrestrial visitors? Did they mistake animals, shadows, or other ordinary sights for something impossible? Was the story exaggerated over time—or did something truly unknown appear outside that Kentucky farmhouse?

    In this episode, we examine the Kelly-Hopkinsville encounter, the witness accounts, the police investigation, the Project Blue Book connection, the major theories, and the case’s transformation into one of America’s most enduring paranormal legends.

    This is our first full episode of spooky season.

    Listen now—and keep your eyes on the windows.

    📧 Send us case suggestions and listener stories:

    monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    📱 Follow us on all social media links here:

    https://linktr.ee/monstrouspod

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 8 mins
  • The Chicago Tylenol Murders
    Sep 26 2026

    A bottle of pain reliever. A familiar brand. A normal morning.

    In late September 1982, seven people across the Chicago area took Extra-Strength Tylenol capsules for everyday reasons.

    But within days, all seven were dead.

    The capsules had been contaminated with potassium cyanide.

    Mary Kellerman was 12 years old. Adam Janus was 27. Adam’s brother, Stanley Janus, and Stanley’s wife, Theresa, both took capsules from the same bottle and became victims, too. Mary McFarland, Lynn Reiner, and Paula Prince were also killed.

    Investigators ultimately recovered eight cyanide-tainted bottles and identified 56 contaminated capsules. The evidence pointed to tampering after the product had left the manufacturer and entered the retail system—but the person, or people, responsible have never been identified.

    In this episode of Monstrous, we examine the Chicago Tylenol murders: the victims, the terrifying realization that ordinary medicine had become a weapon, the national panic, the massive recall, the investigation into James Lewis and Roger Arnold, the changes to packaging and federal law, and the question that remains more than four decades later.

    Who did it?

    📧 Send us case suggestions and listener stories:

    monstroustcpod@gmail.com

    📱 Follow us on all social media links here:

    https://linktr.ee/monstrouspod

    Show More Show Less
    54 mins