Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!
Lizzie Borden took an axe, gave her mother forty whacks.
Wrong. It was her stepmother. It was eighteen or nineteen blows, not forty. And a jury in New Bedford acquitted her in about an hour.
So why does Netflix’s new series say, in its own official logline, that she kills her parents?
This episode isn’t about whether she did it. It’s about how she walked. The confession-adjacent inquest testimony the court threw out, given without a lawyer and under prescribed morphine. The attempted prussic acid purchase the day before the murders, which the jury was never allowed to hear about. A defense attorney who was a former Governor of Massachusetts — and who had personally appointed one of the three judges to the bench. And a jury charge from that same judge, which other judges later described as a plea for the defense.
Plus the detail that reframes all of it: women could not serve on a Massachusetts jury until 1950. The same belief that kept them out of the jury box — too delicate, too pure, too easily upset — is exactly what her lawyer sold to the twelve men who let her go.