• Liberalism and the Social Question: Helena Rosenblatt on Guizot, Marx, and Napoleon III
    Nov 16 2026
    In this second part of a three-part conversation, historian Helena Rosenblatt follows the liberals of nineteenth-century France into the social question, drawing on her 2018 book The Lost History of Liberalism. She begins with François Guizot, who in her account could accept democracy as a type of society, meaning civil equality and the end of privilege, but not as a form of government, and she explains why Guizot and his circle tied the vote to education and independence. She weighs whether the liberals fell short on principle or on the means to act, and describes laissez-faire as a campaign against feudal obstructions, followed by the pauperism that industrialization brought. She explains how Marx and Engels read the middle class in power. She then turns to Napoleon III, the war with Prussia, and the coinage of “liberal democracy,” which she says came to mean protecting people from democracy, and closes with the reasons European liberals admired Abraham Lincoln and Gladstone.About Our GuestHelena Rosenblatt is Distinguished Professor of history, political science, and French at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York. Her most recent book is The Lost History of Liberalism: From Ancient Rome to the Twenty-First Century (Princeton University Press, 2018), the subject of this conversation. She is also the author of Rousseau and Geneva: From the First Discourse to the Social Contract (Cambridge University Press, 1997) and Liberal Values: Benjamin Constant and the Politics of Religion (Cambridge University Press, 2008). Her present project, for which she was awarded a John Simon Guggenheim Fellowship, is an intellectual biography of Madame de Staël.Show Notes & Timestamps00:00 Highlights01:01 Welcome Back and Part One Recap01:38 Guizot and Democracy as a Type of Society06:05 Principle or Means? The Social Question09:34 Laissez-Faire and Adam Smith15:05 Marx, Engels, and the Middle Class in Power19:14 Napoleon III and the War with Prussia22:22 The Making of Liberal Democracy25:13 Lincoln, Gladstone, and Liberal Leadership29:02 Part Three PreviewKey Concepts & TermsDemocracy as a Type of Society — Guizot’s distinction. Prof. Rosenblatt says democracy does not always mean a form of government and can mean a type of society, which is what she says Guizot means. In that sense society has become equal: civil equality, the rule of law, no more privileges, no more nobility. She says Guizot is definitely not for universal suffrage. He wants the rule of reason, which in his thinking belongs to the educated and independent, and so, she says, to the propertied.Laissez-Faire — let the economy be. Prof. Rosenblatt says early liberals such as Constant and Madame de Staël were absolutely for removing obstructions from the economy. In the early nineteenth century she says these were feudal obstructions: lords’ booths on bridges, tariffs, and guilds that kept people from moving from one profession to another. The liberals argued for freedom of trade and the right to buy, sell, and bequeath property without obstruction. She says they assumed the wealth created would be distributed over a wider public.Pauperism — the new problem of industrial poverty. Prof. Rosenblatt says that a generation or two later, urbanization and industrialization produced paupers: people in industrial urban centers stuck in poverty, who were not rising into the middle class as the earlier liberals had expected. She says freedom of trade and freedom from government intervention were not helping these people, and that the conclusion drawn was that government needed to step in.Liberal Democracy — protecting people from democracy. Prof. Rosenblatt says the term was coined in the era of Napoleon III, who, like his uncle, appealed to the people through plebiscites while dismantling representative institutions. Liberals, she says, finally agreed to democracy and to universal male suffrage, but as something forced on them, and they insisted that the population be educated to become citizens. In her account, “liberal democracy” came to mean individual rights, balance of power, limited government, and educated leaders who would tame democracy and channel it into something good.Fascinating Historical InsightsCicero in the Schoolroom and the Duty of the Educated — Prof. Rosenblatt explains that Guizot and his circle tied the vote to education and independence, which in practice meant property, and that this left out women, who did not have their own property, and poorer people, who lacked time to educate themselves. She adds that she is describing how they thought and does not agree with it. The same thinking carried a duty, she says, a kind of noblesse oblige, that the wealthy and educated would rule on behalf of the poor as well. She notes that young boys read Cicero until very late as part of a liberal arts education, and thinks this emphasis has dropped out of today’s conversation.Marx and Engels Watching ...
    Show More Show Less
    30 mins
  • From Liberal to Liberalism: Helena Rosenblatt on the History of a Word
    Nov 3 2026
    In this first part of a three-part conversation, historian Helena Rosenblatt traces the history of the words “liberal” and “liberalism,” the subject of her 2018 book The Lost History of Liberalism. She calls her approach a word history, asking what these terms meant to the people who used them, and begins with the Latin liber, which she says means both free and generous. She follows the word from Cicero through the Enlightenment, then explains why she holds that liberalism does not exist before the word for it, a position she acknowledges can be contested. Rosenblatt places that moment around 1813, in the circle of Madame de Staël and Benjamin Constant, who responded to the Terror and to Napoleon, and credits Spanish scholars with finding that the word apparently first appeared in a Spanish newspaper, used by counter-revolutionaries. The conversation then turns to democracy and the vote, the July Monarchy of 1830 and the workers it disappointed, and Alexis de Tocqueville’s concern about what he called democratic despotism.About Our GuestHelena Rosenblatt is Distinguished Professor of history, political science, and French at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York. Her most recent book is The Lost History of Liberalism: From Ancient Rome to the Twenty-First Century (Princeton University Press, 2018), the subject of this conversation. She is also the author of Rousseau and Geneva: From the First Discourse to the Social Contract (Cambridge University Press, 1997) and Liberal Values: Benjamin Constant and the Politics of Religion (Cambridge University Press, 2008). Her present project, for which she was awarded a John Simon Guggenheim Fellowship, is an intellectual biography of Madame de Staël.Show Notes & Timestamps00:00 Highlights01:34 Welcome and Guest Introduction03:03 Her Work and How the Book Began07:24 Isms and the Word Liberalism09:13 Free and Generous10:35 Rights and Obligations11:56 Prehistory of Liberalism17:22 Liberalism Before the Word19:26 Madame de Staël and Benjamin Constant21:39 Napoleon and the Making of Liberalism25:31 Democracy and Suffrage27:53 The July Monarchy of 183030:20 Liberals, Workers, and Socialism33:02 Tocqueville and Democratic Despotism36:50 Part Two PreviewKey Concepts & TermsWord History — Rosenblatt’s method. She calls her book a word history, tracing what “liberal” and “liberalism” meant to the people who used them. She says she began with conceptual history, urged by a colleague at the Graduate Center to focus on the concept rather than on the men and their texts. That led her to ask how people defined liberalism, why they argued about it, and what the arguments were about. She describes the book as a methodological intervention in the scholarship and says she looks at context, at what caused changes in the term.Liber (LEE-ber) — free and generous. Rosenblatt says the Latin liber, the root of the word, means both free and generous. Many people focus on the freedom side, she says, and she wants to remind them of the generosity side. She places both at or near the core of liberalism through the ages, though liberals and their enemies defined it differently depending on context. In Cicero’s Rome, she says, to be liberal meant having the qualities of a citizen: free and freedom-loving, but also generous to the commonwealth rather than selfish.Liberal Arts Education — education for citizenship. Rosenblatt describes the Renaissance liberal arts as education for citizenship, and says rulers were expected to be liberal in their magnanimity, in the city-states of Italy especially. She stresses that these were ideals, and that people did not always live up to them. She adds that the concept was aristocratic or elitist at first, meant to train young men, the future leaders, to contribute to the community.Liberals of Movement and Liberals of Order — a split after 1830. Rosenblatt says the liberals who came to power in 1830 divided into two camps. The liberals of movement wanted to broaden the franchise to include poorer people, while the more stationary liberals, the liberals of order (she thinks that is what they called themselves), did not. She describes the resulting system as an oligarchy, geared to what was called the middle class but was really the upper middle class.Fascinating Historical InsightsWhen the “-isms” Were Insults — Rosenblatt notes that terms ending in “-ism” are largely nineteenth-century coinages and that many began as insults, naming Calvinism and Lutheranism. She places the coining of “liberalism” around 1813 and credits Spanish scholars with finding that the word apparently first appeared in a Spanish newspaper, used by counter-revolutionaries who disliked the liberals. On her account, to those critics it meant selfishness, anarchy, revolution, and atheism.A Woman Could Not Be Liberal — Rosenblatt explains that until the Enlightenment “liberal” described the qualities of a ...
    Show More Show Less
    38 mins
  • Is Capitalism Past Its Use-By Date? Michael Roberts on Three Futures About This Episode
    Oct 19 2026
    In this third and final part of the conversation, Marxist economist Michael Roberts brings the argument of his 2016 book The Long Depression into the present. He begins with the view that the system works as long as decisions are good, which he finds unconvincing: a system that produces for profit, he argues, delivers both vitality and grotesque inequality, and cannot continue as it is. He describes a generation now worse off than its parents and presents the postwar golden age as the exception, a period when profitability was high enough for capitalism to make concessions. Turning to the current cycle, Roberts considers whether the long depression that followed 2008 may be ending, whether AI could lift profitability for a time, and why he expects the law of profitability to reassert itself, possibly in the 2030s or later. He answers economist Robert J. Gordon on stagnation and Thomas Piketty on taxing billionaires, and closes on three futures: a renewed expansion, a longer stagnation, or, if working people do not change the system, fascist and military regimes and what he calls barbarism, drawing on the fall of Rome.About Our GuestMichael Roberts worked in the City of London as an economist for more than thirty years before retiring. He is the author of The Great Recession: A Marxist View (2009) and The Long Depression (2016), the book at the center of this conversation; joint editor of The World in Crisis (2018); author of Marx 200: His Economics (2018) and Engels 200: His Economics (2020); and, with Guglielmo Carchedi, Capitalism in the 21st Century (2023). His next book, Time Is Running Out: The World Economy in the 2020s, is expected in December 2026. He writes regularly at thenextrecession.wordpress.com.Show Notes & Timestamps00:00 Capitalism Fails People01:17 Welcome and Recap01:37 Financialization and Crisis Myths03:02 How Capitalism Works04:06 A Generation Worse Off06:12 Golden Age Was Exception08:19 Inflation and Profitability Shift10:19 Another Expansion or New Slump12:49 Who Benefits From Profits13:49 Working Class Alternative16:04 Reaction and Fascism Risk17:01 Three Future Scenarios21:06 Rome and Barbarism Warning23:34 Closing Thanks and WrapKey Concepts & TermsLaw of Profitability — Roberts’s name for the pattern, set out in the earlier parts, by which the rate of profit falls over time. In Part Three he applies it to the present: the pandemic slump and technologies such as AI may create the conditions for a new level of profitability in some sectors, particularly in the United States, but on his account profitability would start to fall again if too much is invested in machines and AI relative to labor, which could bring a serious slump in the 2030s or a little later.The Golden Age — Roberts’s label for the postwar decades, when, as he remembers it, young people did better than their parents and housing, health, and education were expanding. He calls this the exception. On his account capitalism could make concessions then, such as the universal healthcare Britain has had since 1948, because profitability was high, and today’s struggle to raise living standards is the norm.Counter-Reforms — Roberts’s term for the period from the 1980s and 1990s onward in which, on his account, gains workers had won were rolled back: wages, trade union rights, state ownership through privatization, and welfare. He says calls to cut welfare continue because capitalists do not want to fund it when profitability is low, and remarks that arms spending is rarely named as an alternative.The Stagnation Thesis — The view Roberts attributes to the American economist Robert J. Gordon: that capitalism is doing badly, with productivity growth slowing right down and a stagnant economy as the result. Roberts treats stagnation as a possibility for a while longer, expects the economy to move either down or up, and says that in his view the stagnation is starting to come to an end.Fascinating Historical InsightsA Reversal Since 2008 — Roberts observes that after the Second World War young people did better than their parents, and that since 2008 the pattern has run the other way. He says twenty years of depression amounts to a generation, and he points to Generation X and the millennials, who on his account will not match the living standards or the housing of his own generation, with problems across housing, roads, health, and education.Marx and the Materialist Conception of History — Roberts says that Marx described capitalism as the dominant system of the present, and that in Roberts’s view the next system will work only if it is socialist. He adds that Marx’s phrase, the materialist conception of history, did not mean an automatic passage from capitalism to socialism, and he warns of forces of reaction that seek to reverse workers’ gains and could bring fascist and military regimes.Who Is Utopian? — Roberts notes that Marxists are usually accused of being utopian for ...
    Show More Show Less
    13 mins
  • Two Depressions, One Cause? Michael Roberts on 1873, 1929, and the Rate of Profit
    Oct 5 2026
    In this second of a three-part conversation, Marxist economist Michael Roberts takes the central claim from Part One — that the 2008 crash opened a long depression — back to the two historical cases on which his 2016 book The Long Depression rests. He begins with the 1870s, answering the Austrian-school argument that no depression took place and a rival monetary explanation tied to the gold standard; his reply draws on the data for Britain, the hegemonic economy of the period. He then sets out the mechanism he takes from the third volume of Marx’s Capital: capitalists invest only when it is profitable, and competition drives them to invest ever more in machinery relative to labor, which Roberts argues pulls the rate of profit down over time, held back for a while by counteracting tendencies. The same pattern, on his account, ran beneath the stock-market boom of the late 1920s and the slump of the 1930s. The episode closes on the rival crisis theories Roberts contests — policy error, unregulated finance, underconsumption, and overproduction — and on his case for profitability as the driver of booms and slumps alike.About Our GuestMichael Roberts worked in the City of London as an economist for over 30 years before retiring. He is the author of several books: The Great Recession: A Marxist View (2009); The Long Depression (2016), the book at the center of this conversation; World in Crisis (joint editor, 2018); Marx 200: His Economics (2018); and Engels 200: His Economics (2020). With Guglielmo Carchedi, he co-authored Capitalism in the 21st Century (2023). His new book, Time Is Running Out: The World Economy in the 2020s and Beyond, is forthcoming in December 2026. He writes regularly at thenextrecession.wordpress.com.Show Notes & Timestamps00:00 Profit Drives Capitalism01:41 Setting Up Three Crises02:38 1873 Depression Debates05:22 Profitability Causes Slumps07:22 Marx’s Law Explained09:56 Organic Composition Basics13:13 Counteracting Tendencies15:07 Profit Waves Through History18:32 From 1929 to War Economy23:58 Competing Crisis Theories28:06 Why Profit Matters MostKey Concepts & TermsOrganic Composition of Capital — Roberts’s term, following Marx, for the growing weight of investment in machinery and plant relative to labor as capitalists compete. Roberts credits this process with making capitalism dynamic, and locates its weak point in Marx’s view that value can come only from human labor: machines help workers create more value but produce none themselves, so a rising share of investment in machines pulls the rate of profit down over time.Counteracting Tendencies — The factors Roberts says Marx sets out in Volume 3 of Capital that slow the fall in the rate of profit: employing more workers, longer hours, more intense work, much cheaper machinery, and profit brought home through foreign trade and investment. On Roberts’s account each has limits, so the general law reasserts itself over a period of time.Underconsumption — One of the rival crisis theories Roberts contests: that workers’ wages are too low to buy all the goods capitalists produce. Roberts answers, citing Engels, that this is always the case and so cannot explain why booms give way to slumps; he adds that most sales take place between capitalists.Overproduction — The rival theory, as Roberts describes it, that capitalists keep producing without limit until the economy goes over a cliff. Roberts replies that a slump is overproduction, but that the theory does not say why growth runs smoothly and then suddenly collapses, or why booms return afterward.Fascinating Historical InsightsA Depression Engels Feared Would Lead to War — Roberts notes that Marx died in 1883, in the middle of the first long depression, and that his close colleague Engels wrote about it at length. On Roberts’s account, Engels saw something different from another round of boom and slump: a depression that might last, and one that could set the capitalist powers fighting over the available profits. Roberts credits Engels with predicting the First World War on this basis.Britain, the Hegemonic Economy — Roberts reminds listeners that in the late nineteenth century the leading economy was Britain, not the United States, with Germany and France rising. Against the claim that the 1870s saw no depression, he points to contemporaries in the 1870s and 1880s who were convinced one was under way, and to data showing Britain’s growth running at a lower trend than in the previous period, documented in detail by scholars he cites in the book.Euphoria on the Stock Market, Falling Profits Underneath — Roberts says the Roaring Twenties looked like an upswing, especially in the United States, while profitability was already falling beneath it. Investors borrowed heavily to buy stocks in a boom he likens to the present, and the mainstream economists of the time, by his account, expected no collapse. After the 1929 crash he describes a ...
    Show More Show Less
    15 mins
  • A Marxist in the City of London: Michael Roberts on The Long Depression
    Sep 21 2026
    In this first of a three-part conversation, Marxist economist Michael Roberts joins Notions of Progress to lay out the central argument of his 2016 book The Long Depression: that the 2008 financial crash was not an ordinary recession, but the opening of a longer structural depression driven by capitalism’s own tendency toward falling profitability. Before getting there, Roberts traces his own path — from a Marxist conversion as a student to a three-decade career as an economist inside the City of London, a combination he treats as complementary rather than contradictory. He then lays out a materialist conception of history underlying his economics: social change driven by who owns and controls production, not by ideas or political leadership taken on their own. Capitalism, on his account, is real progress — rising productivity, rising living standards — and, at the same time, structurally exploitative and radically unequal. The episode closes on the specific technical definition of a “depression” that Parts Two and Three will test against the historical record: not simply a downturn, but one whose recovery never returns to the prior trend line.About Our GuestMichael Roberts worked in the City of London as an economist for over 30 years before retiring. He is the author of several books: The Great Recession: A Marxist View (2009); The Long Depression (2016), the book at the center of this conversation; World in Crisis (joint editor, 2018); Marx 200: His Economics (2018); and Engels 200: His Economics (2020). With Guglielmo Carchedi, he co-authored Capitalism in the 21st Century (2023). His new book, Time Is Running Out: The World Economy in the 2020s and Beyond, is forthcoming in December 2026. He writes regularly at thenextrecession.wordpress.com.Show Notes & Timestamps00:00 Cold Open: The Contradictions of Capital01:03 Welcome & Introduction03:38 Michael’s Background08:38 A Marxist in the City of London11:03 The Nature of Capitalism16:25 Inequality & Systemic Change20:35 The Long Depression Thesis28:31 Next Time: Historical ParallelsKey Concepts & TermsMaterialist Conception of History — Roberts’s term, following Marx, for the view that social and historical change is driven primarily by a society’s economic foundations — who owns and controls production — rather than by political leadership or ideas considered on their own.Means of Production — The productive assets of an economy — factories, companies, capital — whose ownership Roberts identifies as the key dividing line of capitalist society: control over investment and employment decisions rests with those who own them.Tendency of the Rate of Profit to Fall — The Marxist thesis, central to Roberts’s economics, that capitalism’s drive to invest and compete generates a long-run downward pressure on profitability — the mechanism Roberts identifies behind the 2008 crash and the depression that followed it.Long Depression — Roberts’s working definition, distinct from an ordinary recession: a period of low growth and low investment whose recovery never returns the economy to its prior trend line — a category he applies to the 1870s, the 1930s, and, in this episode’s argument, the period after 2008.Fascinating Historical InsightsA Marxist Inside the City of London — Roberts describes becoming a Marxist as a university student in the late 1960s and early ’70s, after encountering the materialist conception of history in economic-history books whose authors, he later discovered, were Marxists — and then spending the next three decades working as an economist for major financial institutions and banks, a combination he frames as a productive vantage point rather than a contradiction.A Depression Capitalism Could Not Exit on Its Own — Roberts recounts the Great Depression of 1929–41/42 as roughly thirteen years in which employment, production, and investment collapsed and stayed collapsed — government stimulus and profitability measures included — until wartime state control of investment, financed partly through war bonds, finally broke the depression.Progress and Exploitation as a Single Argument — Roberts presents Marx’s assessment of capitalism as genuinely two-sided: it raised productivity and living standards far beyond feudal society, and it was, at the same time, built on the exclusion of most people from any control over the investment decisions shaping their lives.A Very Small Number of Decision-Makers — Roberts points to a concentration of ownership — by his account, roughly 0.01% of the U.S. population controlling the largest companies and assets — and extends the point explicitly to today’s dominant AI, technology, banking, and energy firms.Resources & Further ReadingPrimary SourcesMichael Roberts, The Long Depression (2016) — the book at the center of this conversation.Works DiscussedMichael Roberts, The Great Recession: A Marxist View (2009)Michael Roberts and ...
    Show More Show Less
    30 mins
  • Nothing About This Is Inevitable: Gavin Mueller on Automation, AI, and a Different Future
    Sep 7 2026
    This episode closes out a three-part conversation with Gavin Mueller (University of Amsterdam), author of Breaking Things at Work. In Part 2, Mueller traced Marx's own ambivalence toward machinery through the split between orthodox and heterodox Marxism, Frederick Taylor's theory of workplace control, the Technocracy Movement, and Norbert Wiener's early warnings to organized labor about automation. In this final part, Mueller brings that history into the present. The conversation moves from Shoshana Zuboff's early sociological research inside computerized factories to her later, better-known work on surveillance capitalism, and from there into Mueller's own reading of artificial intelligence: the argument that AI systems depend on training data gathered without most people's consent, the concept of cognitive offloading, and the rapidly growing, cross-partisan resistance movement against AI data centers. Mueller closes with what he calls Luddism's real legacy — not a rejection of the future, but the insistence that a different one is still possible.About Our GuestGavin Mueller is an Assistant Professor of New Media and Digital Culture at the University of Amsterdam, where he also teaches Marxist Theory for the Critical Studies MA at the Sandberg Instituut. He holds a Ph.D. in Cultural Studies from George Mason University, is a Contributing Editor at Jacobin, and sits on the editorial collective of Viewpoint Magazine. He is the author of two books. Breaking Things at Work: The Luddites Are Right About Why You Hate Your Job (Verso, 2021) — the book at the center of this three-part conversation — argues that machine-breaking has functioned throughout history as a rational form of labor politics rather than an irrational reflex against progress. Media Piracy in the Cultural Economy (Routledge, 2019) examines how piracy operates from within the media industries it disrupts, rather than simply against them.Show Notes & Timestamps00:00 Introduction02:21 Shoshana Zuboff and Computerized Labor05:18 AI and the Automation of Work07:50 Training Data Without Consent09:54 Cognitive Offloading and Social Degradation14:30 Resistance and Data Center Opposition18:03 The Good Life and Luddism's Legacy23:01 Next Time on Notions of ProgressKey Concepts & Terms– Surveillance Capitalism — Zuboff's term for an economic model built on extracting human behavioral data and converting it into predictive products sold in new markets.– Cognitive Offloading — Mueller's term for the practice of handing routine thinking over to an AI tool, with the risk that independent judgment weakens from disuse.– Luddism — in Mueller's argument, drawing on historian Eric Hobsbawm, a rational labor tradition of resisting how new machinery gets deployed against workers, rather than a blanket rejection of technology itself.Fascinating Historical InsightsBefore Surveillance Capitalism, There Was the Factory FloorLong before she became known for her work on surveillance capitalism, Shoshana Zuboff was a sociologist studying early computerized factories — workplaces where embodied labor was already being translated into displays, buzzers, and lights, a shift Mueller connects back to the same managerial goals Taylor pursued decades earlier.A Debate About ConsentMueller points to the Anthropic author settlement as a concrete instance of the training-data question he raises: a case in which an AI company's use of copyrighted material became the subject of a formal legal resolution, rather than remaining an abstract argument about data ethics.A Resistance Movement That Crosses Party LinesMueller describes local opposition to AI data centers — driven by concerns over electricity and water use — as a movement that has drawn support across the political spectrum, making it, in his account, one of the more unusual coalitions to form around technology policy in recent memory.The Word “Luddite” Doesn't Mean What Most People ThinkAs established across this three-part conversation, historian Eric Hobsbawm's rehabilitation of the Luddites reframed their machine-breaking as organized labor strategy rather than blind technophobia — the historical throughline Mueller carries into his reading of AI in this closing part.Coming Up NextEconomist Michael Roberts (author of The Long Depression) joins Notions of Progress to lay out his Marxist account of capitalism's boom-and-slump cycles and the tendency of the rate of profit to fall.Listen & SubscribeApple PodcastsSpotifyYouTubeAmazon MusicWebsite — notionsofprogress.comEmail: marshall@notionsofprogress.comAbout the ShowNotions of Progress is a podcast tracing ideas of progress from antiquity to the age of artificial intelligence. Hosted by Marshall Madow — an independent researcher whose MA in History (Cambridge) examined Georges Sorel's epistemology of myth, and whose MSc (Oxford, Saïd Business School) focused on Complexity Science and Leadership — the show surfaces the debates ...
    Show More Show Less
    13 mins
  • Theorizing the Machine: Gavin Mueller on Marxism, Taylorism, and Cybernetics Interview pt 2 of 3
    Aug 24 2026
    In Episode 17, Gavin Mueller (University of Amsterdam) traced the Luddites back to the guild economy of England's Midlands. In this second installment of a three-part conversation, Mueller follows that struggle into the twentieth century: Karl Marx's own ambivalence toward machinery, and the split between Karl Kautsky's “orthodox” Marxism — which treated capitalist technology as a scientifically inevitable path to socialism — and the workers' movements that resisted that framing directly on the shop floor. Mueller traces Frederick Winslow Taylor's “scientific management” as, above all, a theory of control rather than efficiency; the short-lived but influential Technocracy Movement's vision of automation as an unstoppable social force; and mathematician Norbert Wiener's cybernetics, including his largely unheeded 1949 letter warning UAW president Walter Reuther that automation posed a genuine threat to organized labor. The episode closes on how that warning intersected with civil rights-era debates about automation's disproportionate impact on Black workers. As with the whole series, the through-line is not a settled verdict on technology and progress, but the recurring argument over whether machines serve human ends or reshape them.About Our GuestGavin Mueller is an Assistant Professor of New Media and Digital Culture at the University of Amsterdam, where he also teaches Marxist Theory for the Critical Studies MA at the Sandberg Instituut. He holds a Ph.D. in Cultural Studies from George Mason University. He is a Contributing Editor at Jacobin and a member of the editorial collective of Viewpoint Magazine. He is the author of Breaking Things at Work: The Luddites Are Right About Why You Hate Your Job (Verso, 2021), the book at the center of this three-part conversation, and Media Piracy in the Cultural Economy (Routledge, 2019).Show Notes & Timestamps00:00 Welcome Back: Picking Up the Conversation01:31 Mueller's Project: Connecting Luddites and Marxism05:38 Marx's Own Ambivalence Toward Machinery10:41 Bridging Back to the Luddites16:35 Orthodox and Heterodox Marxism23:57 Taylorism as a Theory of Control31:43 The Technocracy Movement36:30 Cybernetics and Norbert Wiener41:25 Contemporary Echoes: From the '60s to NowKey Concepts & TermsCybernetics — the science of control and communication in machines and living thingsCoined by mathematician Norbert Wiener, cybernetics derives from the Greek kybernetes (“steersman”) and describes systems that regulate themselves through feedback. Wiener applied the concept first to anti-aircraft targeting, then — as Mueller discusses — to a broader warning about automation's threat to industrial labor.Scientific Management (Taylorism) — a system for controlling how factory work gets doneDeveloped by Frederick Winslow Taylor and built on time-and-motion study of workers' individual tasks. Mueller argues, following historian Harry Braverman, that its real function was less about efficiency than about transferring control of the production process from workers to management.Kautsky — the theorist behind “orthodox” MarxismKarl Kautsky, the leading theoretician of the German Social Democratic Party, held that socialism would emerge automatically from the development of capitalist productive forces. Mueller treats Kautsky's determinism as the dominant — and, in his account, mistaken — current within the early twentieth-century workers' movement.The Technocracy Movement — a 1930s proposal for engineer-led economic ruleA short-lived American movement centered on Howard Scott's Committee on Technocracy at Columbia University, which argued that trained engineers, not elected politicians or capitalists, should administer the economy through “energy accounting.” Mueller treats its rapid rise and fall as an early instance of automation panic detached from any actual working-class movement.Fascinating Historical InsightsThe Stopwatch That Started a StrikeOn August 11, 1911, molders at the Watertown Arsenal in Massachusetts walked off the job the moment Taylor's stopwatch appeared on the shop floor. The dispute escalated all the way to a congressional hearing in January 1912 — and Congress sided with the workers, discontinuing the Taylor system at Watertown and reinstating the fired molder.The Warning Walter Reuther Never Acted OnIn August 1949, Norbert Wiener wrote directly to UAW president Walter Reuther, warning that automation could unleash “disastrous” unemployment and offering to help labor secure a share of the resulting profits. Reuther eventually invited Wiener to address a UAW conference in 1952 — but Wiener, in poor health at the time, never gave the talk.A “Bloodless Revolution” That Lasted Barely a YearAt its 1930s peak, the Technocracy Movement drew crowds eager for its promise that trained engineers, not politicians, could administer the economy through “energy accounting.” Its influence was, by most accounts, a ...
    Show More Show Less
    24 mins
  • Breaking Things at Work: Gavin Mueller on the Luddites and Labor Resistance pt 1 of 3
    Aug 14 2026
    They've been remembered as machine-smashers who tried to stop the future with a hammer — but historian Eric Hobsbawm called what they were doing “collective bargaining by riot.” In this episode, Prof. Gavin Mueller (University of Amsterdam), author of Breaking Things at Work, walks through who the Luddites actually were: skilled textile workers in England's Midlands, organized under the mythical banner of King Ludd, fighting to preserve their wages, their working conditions, and the quality of their craft against machines introduced without negotiation. Mueller makes the case that this was a rational response to an existential threat, not an irrational rejection of progress — a reading that places the Luddites' resistance inside the history of the idea of progress rather than outside it.This episode is the first of a three-part conversation with Mueller drawn from a single recorded interview. Episode 18 turns to Marx and the theorists who followed him; Episode 19 carries the argument through to Shoshana Zuboff and today's debates about artificial intelligence.About Our GuestGavin Mueller is an Assistant Professor of New Media and Digital Culture at the University of Amsterdam, where he also teaches Marxist Theory for the Critical Studies MA at the Sandberg Instituut. He holds a Ph.D. in Cultural Studies from George Mason University. He is a Contributing Editor at Jacobin and a member of the editorial collective of Viewpoint Magazine. He is the author of Breaking Things at Work: The Luddites Are Right About Why You Hate Your Job (Verso, 2021), the book at the center of this episode, and Media Piracy in the Cultural Economy (Routledge, 2019).Show Notes & Timestamps- Introduction — 0:13- Guest Introduction: Gavin Mueller — 1:13- About the Book: Breaking Things at Work — 1:50- Why the Luddites? — 8:44- The Luddite Movement — 11:36- Guilds vs. Unions — 21:36- Hobsbawm & Rehabilitating the Luddites — 25:49- Outro & What's Next — 32:27Key Concepts & TermsLudditeEarly-1800s English textile workers who organized to resist machines introduced into their trade without negotiation, named for the mythical figure Ned Ludd. The word is now often used as an insult for anyone who resists technology — a meaning that differs from the historical movement's actual grievances.GuildA trade association of skilled workers that set standards for wages, training, and the quality of goods produced. Guilds structured England's textile trade before industrialization reorganized it around factory-owned machinery.Combination ActsLaws passed by the British Parliament in 1799 and 1800 that made it illegal for workers to organize collectively to negotiate wages or conditions, closing off legal routes to the kind of bargaining unions would later provide.Gig MillA mechanized cloth-finishing machine, along with the stocking frame, at the center of the Luddite disputes. These machines could produce goods faster and with less-skilled labor, undercutting the wages and standards guild-trained workers had maintained.Fascinating Historical InsightsCollective Bargaining by RiotHistorian Eric Hobsbawm's phrase, discussed in this episode, reframed Luddite machine-breaking as a form of negotiation rather than mindless destruction — a strategy workers turned to precisely because the Combination Acts had closed off legal organizing.A Mythical LeaderThe Luddites organized under the banner of a fictional figure, “King Ludd” or “Ned Ludd.” Letters and proclamations were issued in his name rather than any real leader's — a structure that let the movement act without a leader who could be arrested and used to dismantle it.Guilds vs. UnionsGuilds regulated an entire trade's standards and training; unions, illegal until decades later, organized workers within a single employer relationship to bargain collectively. The two represent different structures of worker power, not simply an older and newer version of the same thing.Not Anti-ProgressThe Luddites' documented demands centered on wages, working conditions, and product quality. Their resistance sits inside a debate about who progress serves, not outside the idea of progress altogether.Resources & Further ReadingPrimary SourcesGavin Mueller, Breaking Things at Work: The Luddites Are Right About Why You Hate Your Job (Verso, 2021) — the book at the center of this episode.Works DiscussedE.P. Thompson, The Making of the English Working Class (New York: Vintage, 1966).Eric J. Hobsbawm, “The Machine Breakers,” Past and Present 1 (February 1952).Kevin Binfield, Writings of the Luddites (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2015).Peter Linebaugh, Ned Ludd and Queen Mab: Machine-Breaking, Romanticism, and the Several Commons of 1811–12 (Oakland: PM Press, 2012).Coming Up NextIn Episode 18, “Theorizing the Machine,” the conversation with Gavin Mueller continues from Marx through the cyberneticists who followed him.Listen & SubscribeApple ...
    Show More Show Less
    35 mins