In this second part of a three-part conversation, historian Helena Rosenblatt follows the liberals of nineteenth-century France into the social question, drawing on her 2018 book The Lost History of Liberalism. She begins with François Guizot, who in her account could accept democracy as a type of society, meaning civil equality and the end of privilege, but not as a form of government, and she explains why Guizot and his circle tied the vote to education and independence. She weighs whether the liberals fell short on principle or on the means to act, and describes laissez-faire as a campaign against feudal obstructions, followed by the pauperism that industrialization brought. She explains how Marx and Engels read the middle class in power. She then turns to Napoleon III, the war with Prussia, and the coinage of “liberal democracy,” which she says came to mean protecting people from democracy, and closes with the reasons European liberals admired Abraham Lincoln and Gladstone.About Our GuestHelena Rosenblatt is Distinguished Professor of history, political science, and French at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York. Her most recent book is The Lost History of Liberalism: From Ancient Rome to the Twenty-First Century (Princeton University Press, 2018), the subject of this conversation. She is also the author of Rousseau and Geneva: From the First Discourse to the Social Contract (Cambridge University Press, 1997) and Liberal Values: Benjamin Constant and the Politics of Religion (Cambridge University Press, 2008). Her present project, for which she was awarded a John Simon Guggenheim Fellowship, is an intellectual biography of Madame de Staël.Show Notes & Timestamps00:00 Highlights01:01 Welcome Back and Part One Recap01:38 Guizot and Democracy as a Type of Society06:05 Principle or Means? The Social Question09:34 Laissez-Faire and Adam Smith15:05 Marx, Engels, and the Middle Class in Power19:14 Napoleon III and the War with Prussia22:22 The Making of Liberal Democracy25:13 Lincoln, Gladstone, and Liberal Leadership29:02 Part Three PreviewKey Concepts & TermsDemocracy as a Type of Society — Guizot’s distinction. Prof. Rosenblatt says democracy does not always mean a form of government and can mean a type of society, which is what she says Guizot means. In that sense society has become equal: civil equality, the rule of law, no more privileges, no more nobility. She says Guizot is definitely not for universal suffrage. He wants the rule of reason, which in his thinking belongs to the educated and independent, and so, she says, to the propertied.Laissez-Faire — let the economy be. Prof. Rosenblatt says early liberals such as Constant and Madame de Staël were absolutely for removing obstructions from the economy. In the early nineteenth century she says these were feudal obstructions: lords’ booths on bridges, tariffs, and guilds that kept people from moving from one profession to another. The liberals argued for freedom of trade and the right to buy, sell, and bequeath property without obstruction. She says they assumed the wealth created would be distributed over a wider public.Pauperism — the new problem of industrial poverty. Prof. Rosenblatt says that a generation or two later, urbanization and industrialization produced paupers: people in industrial urban centers stuck in poverty, who were not rising into the middle class as the earlier liberals had expected. She says freedom of trade and freedom from government intervention were not helping these people, and that the conclusion drawn was that government needed to step in.Liberal Democracy — protecting people from democracy. Prof. Rosenblatt says the term was coined in the era of Napoleon III, who, like his uncle, appealed to the people through plebiscites while dismantling representative institutions. Liberals, she says, finally agreed to democracy and to universal male suffrage, but as something forced on them, and they insisted that the population be educated to become citizens. In her account, “liberal democracy” came to mean individual rights, balance of power, limited government, and educated leaders who would tame democracy and channel it into something good.Fascinating Historical InsightsCicero in the Schoolroom and the Duty of the Educated — Prof. Rosenblatt explains that Guizot and his circle tied the vote to education and independence, which in practice meant property, and that this left out women, who did not have their own property, and poorer people, who lacked time to educate themselves. She adds that she is describing how they thought and does not agree with it. The same thinking carried a duty, she says, a kind of noblesse oblige, that the wealthy and educated would rule on behalf of the poor as well. She notes that young boys read Cicero until very late as part of a liberal arts education, and thinks this emphasis has dropped out of today’s conversation.Marx and Engels Watching ...
Show More
Show Less