Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
Our Most UNHINGED Dating Stories… cover art

Our Most UNHINGED Dating Stories…

Our Most UNHINGED Dating Stories…

Listen for free

View show details
About this listen

This week, Amy, Lauren, and Whitney rewind to the beginning: how they met their husbands, and the toads (okay, roaches) they kissed along the way.

Lauren's stepmom predicted she'd meet her husband in Nashville, and she was right. It took a bar, a stick shift, AC blowing under the sheets, and one very honest guy. Whitney's love story starts at a small-town coffee shop in Oregon and plays out like a Hallmark movie (homemade risotto included). And Amy finally confesses how it all started with her husband: a Twitter DM she still knows by heart, a phone call she dodged for days, and a teenage cover story her parents may be hearing for the first time.

Then it's time for the dating history. Two of the three hosts dated an actual criminal, one of them waited by the phone for a jail call that never came, and all three agree on the lesson: go for the good guy.

In this episode:

  • 00:29 — Welcome back: how we met our husbands
  • 00:40 — Lauren: a new bartender, a security guy, and her stepmom's prediction
  • 02:59 — The stick shift, the dark park, and AC under the sheets
  • 04:38 — The forehead kiss, and the most honest green flag
  • 05:33 — A family cruise, a breakup processed, and sealing the deal
  • 06:45 — Whitney's "Hallmark movie": a small-town coffee shop in Oregon
  • 08:23 — The Snapchat add, and a year of silence
  • 09:17 — Risotto from his nonna, and She's the Man
  • 11:52 — Amy: why she gets embarrassed telling her story
  • 14:09 — The Tyler, the Creator DM
  • 18:15 — Dodging the phone call, then three hours on the phone
  • 21:43 — A four-hour train ride and a sister in the basement
  • 25:13 — Getting possessive: "You have a choice right now"
  • 26:32 — The almost-proposal at 18
  • 27:11 — The textbook alibi
  • 29:32 — Child bride and groom: married at 21 and 22
  • 30:06 — "What are we?" "I have to go watch the Kardashians"
  • 31:32 — Dating history: Lauren's first boyfriend and the stolen Oakleys
  • 33:49 — The CVS robbery attempt
  • 35:11 — Mean girls, home studies, and "rejection is redirection"
  • 36:25 — Wait, Amy dated a criminal too?
  • 40:33 — "Sorry, mom and dad": skipping the movies
  • 42:15 — "Don't go into my pocket," and the trap house
  • 46:02 — Waiting for the jail call
  • 48:03 — A preview of Amy's icks: men who don't smile
  • 49:14 — Heartbreak, Adele, and a bubble bath
  • 50:12 — Teenage mistake #3
  • 54:36 — Whitney's short (and criminal-free) roster
  • 57:10 — What the toads taught us
  • 59:30 — Go for the good guy: you're marrying the father of your children
  • 1:00:11 — Can you top our stories? Plus a possible part two

Think your dating history beats ours? Tell us your craziest story in the comments. We might just need a part two.

Follow along:

  • Amy: @amymacedo
  • Whitney: @albrightwhitney
  • Tennpop (Lauren's brand): @tennpopofficial
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet