Hannah Pettey

Join us as we play two truths and a lie..Small Town True Crimes style! Tabitha tells three stories from Alabama, Deleware, Hawaii, Georgia, and California. Teresa and Angie have to guess which is the lie....

This story takes place in Ohio County, Kentucky. This local case is VERY local to us. This is the story of Michelle Schroader and how sometimes even after death, your accuser still haunts you.

In this episode, we dive into one of America’s most infamous true crime cases: the story of Lizzie Borden. On August 4, 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden were brutally murdered in their Fall River, Massachusetts home—struck down with a hatchet in broad daylight. Suspicion quickly turned to Andrew’s 32-year-old daughter, Lizzie.

Arrested and tried in a sensational 1893 courtroom battle, Lizzie’s case captivated the nation and helped shape the modern media frenzy around true crime. Though she was ultimately acquitted, questions have lingered for more than a century. Was she a cold-blooded killer—or a woman judged by the rigid expectations of her time?

Join us as we explore the evidence, the trial, and the enduring mystery that still sparks debate today.

The case of Kouri Richins centers on the 2022 death of her husband, Eric Richins, who was found dead in their Utah home from a lethal dose of fentanyl. Prosecutors alleged Kouri had financial motives and access to drugs. The case drew national attention when it was revealed that she "wrote" a children's book about handling grief. Listen to find out what evidence was presented against her.

When tragedy strikes in a small town, your own hometown, you have to tell the story! We will discuss a murder committed by a minor. Some opinions will be given in this episode.

In June 2020, a shocking discovery on Seattle’s Alki Beach stunned the community. What began as a carefree summer day — and a TikTok video — led to the discovery of human remains hidden inside a suitcase near the shoreline. The victims were later identified as Jessica Lewis and Austin Wenner, and the investigation uncovered a disturbing chain of events that ended in violence. In this episode, we explore how the case unfolded, the clues that led detectives to a suspect, and how justice was ultimately served.

In 2023, a horrifying discovery exposed one of the most disturbing funeral home scandals in U.S. history! When authorities investigated complaints of a foul odor, they uncovered a horrific site...nearly 300 decaying, rotting bodies inside a building--many of which had been there for years!